Voting Rights, Courts & Government Accountability
Justice Department withdraws lawsuit seeking to segregate 20,000 California ballots
DOJ voluntarily dismissed its California ballot case after courts denied emergency relief and the ballots could no longer be separated. The dismissal ends this case without deciding every underlying eligibility allegation.
DOJ said the requested remedy was no longer available
The U.S. Justice Department filed a notice on November 6 voluntarily dismissing its lawsuit that sought to prevent California from counting mail ballots associated with more than 20,000 registered voters whom federal officials alleged were likely noncitizens. DOJ said that by the scheduled November 13 hearing the challenged ballots would already be mixed with other lawful ballots, making segregation impossible. [1][2][3]
The dismissal followed a district judge’s refusal to impose emergency restrictions, a divided Ninth Circuit decision denying an injunction pending appeal and the Supreme Court’s summary denial of emergency relief. The Ninth Circuit concluded the government had not shown that federal criminal law required California to adopt the requested ballot-verification procedure. [5][6][8]
Courts questioned both the legal theory and the list
U.S. District Judge David Carter said the requested late change risked disenfranchising eligible citizens and disrupting an election already under way. California and Los Angeles County also challenged the reliability of the federal list; local review found that some flagged people appeared to be U.S.-born. The dismissal means the planned evidentiary hearing will not test the list in this case. [2][3][6]
DOJ maintained that noncitizen voting is unlawful and said it would continue using civil and criminal remedies against suspected election-law violations. California Attorney General Rob Bonta described the withdrawal as the end of an unlawful effort to interfere with the election. Those competing statements describe the parties’ positions; the voluntary dismissal is not a finding that every person on the list was eligible or ineligible. [2][7][8]
The case ends without a final merits judgment
A voluntary dismissal at this stage ends this particular lawsuit without a final trial judgment on all claims. Separate prosecutions or voter-roll litigation may continue, but they require their own evidence and procedures. The government’s allegation that a person was “likely” a noncitizen does not by itself prove that the person registered or voted unlawfully. [4][1][2]
How the sources compare
| Source | What it adds | Scope or limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Reuters, AP and Los Angeles Times · November 6–7 | The dismissal, stated reason, procedural chronology and responses from both sides. | The dismissal notice was not independently hosted in an accessible court repository at review time. |
| District court and Ninth Circuit orders | The courts’ actual legal reasoning, evidentiary concerns and limits on emergency relief. | These orders addressed preliminary relief rather than resolving every possible eligibility case. |
| DOJ and California attorney general | The original federal allegation and California’s response. | Each is a litigant or government advocate; neither statement substitutes for adjudicated facts. |
What remains unclear
Whether DOJ brings a narrower case supported by individualized evidence.
How many flagged voters, if any, are ultimately shown to have registered or voted unlawfully.
Whether related voter-roll and privacy litigation produces later rulings.
Whether the dismissal is with or without consequences for the pending appellate matters.
Sources & translations
- Reuters — Trump administration ends California balloting lawsuit
- Associated Press — US Justice Department drops bid to force California to set aside disputed ballots
- Los Angeles Times — Feds move to dismiss case over 20,000 California ballots after Supreme Court denied appeal
- Democracy Docket — Trump DOJ drops California ballot segregation lawsuit after Supreme Court defeat
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit — Order denying injunction pending appeal, No. 26-7231
- U.S. District Court for the Central District of California — Order denying temporary restraining order, No. 2:26-cv-12025
- U.S. Department of Justice — United States sues California after determining more than 20,000 likely noncitizens are registered to vote
- California Department of Justice — Attorney General Bonta secures fourth legal victory as U.S. Supreme Court denies emergency request
Updates & corrections
- — Initial report distinguishes withdrawal of the requested remedy from a final merits ruling and preserves the untested status of individual eligibility allegations.