India, Digital Rights & Government Accountability
India unblocks 95 websites after forged court orders expose blocking gaps
India’s telecom department reversed 95 website blocks after discovering that purported High Court orders were fake. A police case and internal review are examining how the directives passed without court verification.
Forged documents produced real nationwide blocking directions
India’s Department of Telecommunications directed internet providers to block 129 betting websites in two batches—34 on July 21 and 95 on September 2—after receiving documents presented as orders from the Rajasthan and Allahabad High Courts. Reuters reported that court registries and police records showed the orders were not genuine. The sites were described as betting or gambling services, but the accountability issue is that government action followed unverified judicial documents. [4][1][8]
The September file published by the department includes the purported order, email exchanges and a list of 95 domains. It shows officials noted that supporting case papers were absent and later asked the sender for the website list in an editable format. The public record reviewed for this report does not show that the order was verified with the court before the blocking direction was sent. [1][8][7]
The department reversed 95 blocks and opened an internal review
A later department order instructed all licensed internet providers to unblock the 95 domains immediately. The document’s embedded approval-date field was not rendered as an ordinary calendar date, while the department’s orders page and Indian reporting place publication on November 13. That metadata defect is preserved rather than converted into a more precise date than the document displays. [2][3][6]
Reuters and The Hindu BusinessLine reported that the telecom ministry opened an internal investigation and that the prime minister’s office summoned Telecom Secretary Amit Agrawal for an explanation. The prime minister’s office and department had not issued a detailed public account of the reported summons by the reviewed cutoff. Uttar Pradesh police were investigating alleged forgery and cheating by unidentified people; no arrest or finding of guilt was reported. [5][6][4]
The two totals should not be collapsed
The documented reversal covers 95 sites tied to the purported Allahabad order. The original reporting describes 129 blocked sites across two purported orders. The reviewed material did not establish that the separate group of 34 had also been unblocked, so “95 unblocked” should not be rewritten as “all 129 restored.” [2][5][6]
The forged documents used official-looking seals, case details and QR codes. Reuters could not establish who created them or whether artificial intelligence was used. Their appearance alone therefore does not prove an AI-generated forgery; the verified failure was that false documents entered an enforcement process and produced blocking instructions. [4][7][8]
The case raises a broader due-process problem
Website operators, users and any organization subject to Indian blocking systems are affected by the verification gap. Illegal content can be restricted under Indian law, but a forged order cannot supply lawful judicial authority. The next meaningful records will be the ministry’s findings, police filings, any authentication safeguards adopted and the status of the remaining 34 domains. [3][6][7]
How the sources compare
| Source | What it adds | Scope or limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Department of Telecommunications | The September blocking file, the 95-domain reversal and the department’s public orders index. | The files do not identify the forger, explain the verification failure or establish that all 129 domains were restored. |
| Reuters | Court-registry checks, police records, the reported internal probe and reported summons of the telecom secretary. | The summons relies on unnamed government sources; the offices involved had not publicly confirmed the meeting in detail. |
| The Hindu BusinessLine, MediaNama and Transclew | Independent Indian review of the department files, reversal scope and digital-rights implications. | Some underlying court and police records were described through Reuters rather than independently published in full. |
What remains unclear
Who created and submitted the forged orders and whether anyone inside government knowingly assisted.
Whether the remaining 34 websites were unblocked or remain restricted under another authority.
What authentication controls the telecom department will require before acting on future court orders.
Whether police or courts will bring charges and what evidence any prosecution will establish.
Sources & translations
- India Department of Telecommunications — September 2 blocking direction and purported Allahabad High Court order
- India Department of Telecommunications — Direction to unblock 95 websites
- India Department of Telecommunications — Orders and Notices index
- Reuters — India ordered website takedowns on fake court orders, Reuters finds; police launch probe
- Reuters — Modi summons telecom secretary over website takedowns, sources say
- The Hindu BusinessLine — PMO summons DoT Secretary to explain takedown based on fake court orders
- MediaNama — 129 betting websites blocked on fake court orders: Who verifies orders?
- Transclew — Government ordered 129 betting sites blocked on fake High Court orders
Updates & corrections
- — Initial report distinguishes the 95-site reversal from the 129-site combined total and treats the reported PMO summons as sourced reporting rather than a published official finding.