Speech, Political Rights & Government Accountability
Macao sentences former lawmaker Au Kam San to 12½ years in first national-security case
A court imposed a consolidated 12-year, six-month term after closed hearings on subversion, overseas links and secrecy charges. Two other subversion counts ended in acquittal, and the public evidence remains limited.
The court imposed a consolidated 12½-year term
Macao’s Court of First Instance sentenced former legislator Au Kam San, 69, to 12 years and six months on November 6 in the territory’s first prosecution under its national-security law. The court’s Portuguese-language statement, Reuters and AP agree on the consolidated term. The component sentences were 11 years and three months for subversion, three years and nine months for each of two overseas-link offences, and nine months for breach of secrecy; they were combined rather than simply added. [1][2][3][4]
The court acquitted Au on two additional subversion counts for insufficient evidence, Reuters reported. A conviction on the remaining counts establishes the trial court’s findings at this stage; it does not turn every political allegation about Au or Macao’s opposition movement into an adjudicated fact. [2][3][1]
The hearings were closed, while the sentence was read publicly
Au was arrested in July 2025 and tried on September 16 and 18. AP and Portuguese-language reporting said the evidentiary hearings were closed on national-security grounds, although the sentence was read in public. Prosecutors alleged that Au spread material intended to provoke hostility toward China’s central government, worked with overseas organizations and disclosed confidential information connected to casino-license renewals. [3][5][2]
The court said Au’s intent and the potential consequences were grave. His wife and overseas counsel described the prosecution as political, while Macao and Chinese authorities defended the case as lawful national-security enforcement. Those responses document the parties’ positions; the reviewed public record does not disclose the complete evidence heard behind closed doors. [3][2][1]
Portugal, the EU and rights groups raised due-process and speech concerns
Portugal said it conveyed serious concern and rejection of the sentence because Au is also a Portuguese citizen. The European Union said the outcome reflected declining political pluralism and expression and criticized restrictions on public, press and diplomatic access. Human Rights Watch separately said due-process violations marred the case. These are diplomatic and advocacy assessments, not appellate judgments overturning the conviction. [5][6][2]
Au served in Macao’s legislature for nearly two decades and was known for advocating democratic reform. The sentence therefore matters beyond one defendant: civic groups and journalists now have a concrete example of how the amended security law is being applied, but the boundaries of lawful criticism remain difficult to assess without fuller reasons and evidence. [3][2][4]
How the sources compare
| Source | What it adds | Scope or limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Macao Court of First Instance · Portuguese, November 6 | The charges, component terms, consolidation range and final 12½-year sentence. | The public statement does not disclose the complete evidentiary record from the closed hearings. |
| Reuters and AP · English, November 6 | Independent confirmation, acquittals on two counts, parties’ responses and political context. | Neither publishes the full written judgment or sealed evidence. |
| Lusa/Portuguese and EU reporting · Portuguese, November 6 | Portugal’s and the European Union’s objections and the distinction between closed hearings and a public sentencing session. | Diplomatic criticism does not decide the appeal or legal validity of the conviction. |
What remains unclear
Whether Au or prosecutors appeal and whether an appellate court changes any conviction or term.
When the full written judgment and non-confidential evidence become public.
How broadly Macao authorities apply the national-security law to future peaceful speech, journalism and overseas advocacy.
Sources & translations
- Macao SAR Government / Court of First Instance — Court sentences Au Kam San to 12 years and 6 monthsThe offence names, component terms, consolidation range and final term were reviewed in Portuguese and cross-checked against Reuters, AP and local English reporting.
- Reuters — Macau ex-lawmaker jailed for 12-1/2 years in city’s first national security trial
- Associated Press — Former pro-democracy lawmaker sentenced to 12½ years in Macao’s first national security case
- Macau Daily Times — Au Kam San sentenced to 12 years and six months in city’s first national security case
- Lusa via Correio da Manhã — European Union deplores sentence of Portuguese citizen Au Kam SanThe EU statement, access restrictions and hearing-stage distinctions were summarized from Portuguese and checked against AP and the court statement.
- Lusa via Correio da Manhã — Portuguese foreign ministry rejects Au Kam San sentencePortugal’s diplomatic response was summarized in English without reproducing the article.
Updates & corrections
- — Initial report records the consolidated sentence and partial acquittals, separates court findings from political allegations, and identifies the limits created by closed hearings.