Laynie Hasan.

← News & Current Events

Surveillance, Privacy & Police Accountability

Pinellas prosecutor files new misconduct charge over deputy’s license-plate searches

A Florida prosecutor filed one charge against former deputy Karl Gwynne. A separate audit led to Ronald Scott’s arrest over alleged searches involving his estranged wife and others.

Published
Updated
Event: New case filed November 6, 2026, following a separate arrest November 5

A new filing after prosecutors declined the first case

Pinellas-Pasco State Attorney Bruce Bartlett opened a new case on November 6 charging former Pinellas County deputy Karl Gwynne with one count of official misconduct. The Tampa Bay Times reported that an October 30 notice declined all five original arrest charges. Bartlett told the newspaper that prosecutors continued reviewing the evidence. Gwynne’s lawyer, Kym Rivellini, said the defense would contest the new charge. [1][4]

The sheriff says a reporter’s inquiry in August prompted investigators to examine how often Gwynne searched for a woman he wanted to date. The agency attributed 381 searches across five systems to him between January 2025 and July 2026. Of those, 300 were searches of her license plate. An automated plate reader records where a vehicle passed a camera, so repeated queries can reveal a person’s travel patterns. [4][1][5]

Bartlett’s October notice said he would seek legislative changes. In the later statement, he declined to explain his legal reasoning while the new case was pending. Florida’s official-misconduct statute covers specified acts such as falsifying a public record with the intent to obtain a benefit or cause unlawful harm. The search count alone does not establish those elements. [1][6]

An audit flagged a second deputy’s searches

Sheriff Bob Gualtieri said a review using improved audit tools flagged more than 100 instances of suspected misuse by Ronald Scott between February 14 and June 19. According to the sheriff, Scott searched Flock plate-reader records and other databases for information about his estranged wife, her boyfriend and relatives. Spectrum Bay News 9 reported that the sheriff said Scott entered investigative reasons for the personal queries. [2][3]

Scott resigned November 4. The next day deputies arrested him on three counts of unauthorized computer or electronic-device access and one count of official misconduct. Gualtieri said the agency had completed its review of historical searches. He had previously acknowledged that its audits did too little to flag repeated queries of one plate. The source records give the sheriff’s account of the searches. Both former deputies’ criminal cases remain unresolved in the reporting reviewed. [2][3][5][1]

How the sources compare

SourceWhat it addsScope or limitation
Tampa Bay Times, November 6Tony Marrero reported from the earlier court filing and obtained statements directly from the prosecutor and Gwynne’s defense lawyer after the new case opened.The newsroom’s report supplies the filing history. A copy of the new charging instrument was unavailable for this report.
Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office, September 30 and November 5The sheriff gave separate accounts of how the two investigations began, the periods searched and the arrest charges.The agency’s findings and assessment of its audit program have not been tested in the criminal cases.
Spectrum Bay News 9 and WFTS Tampa Bay 28Local coverage explains what deputies entered when searching and why frequent queries could escape earlier audits.The search counts in these reports come from the sheriff’s investigation.

What remains unclear

What evidence prosecutors will present for the new official-misconduct charge against Gwynne and how the defense will answer it.

How Scott will respond to the charges and what future reviews of database queries will find.

Sources & translations

  1. Tampa Bay Times via AOL — New case filed against ex-Pinellas deputy accused of abusing license plate reader databaseNovember 6, 2026, updated 22:01 UTC · English · Independent court reporting and on-record statements from prosecutor and defense counsel
  2. Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office — Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office Arrests Deputy For Official Misconduct (26-093)November 5, 2026 · English · Primary arrest and audit statement
  3. Spectrum Bay News 9 — Pinellas County Sheriff's Office deputy arrested, accused of misusing systemsNovember 5, 2026, updated 6:28 p.m. Eastern · English · Local reporting on the sheriff’s press conference
  4. Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office — Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office Arrests Two Deputies For Official Misconduct (26-083)September 30, 2026 · English · Primary record of Gwynne investigation and original arrest
  5. WFTS Tampa Bay 28 — Pinellas sheriff acknowledges gaps in Flock-style camera oversight after deputy’s arrestSeptember 30 briefing, reviewed November 7, 2026 · English · Independent local reporting on agency audit policy
  6. Florida Legislature — 2026 Florida Statutes, section 838.022, Official misconduct2026 statutory edition, reviewed November 7 · English · Primary statutory text

Updates & corrections

  • — First publication.