Technology Accountability, Children & Courts
UK court upholds Ofcom data demands to Meta, TikTok and X
The High Court rejected platform challenges to Online Safety Act information notices seeking age, moderation, exposure, appeals and user-reporting data. The ruling validates these notices; it does not decide separate fee, fine or WhatsApp-classification cases.
High Court rejects the first challenge to Ofcom’s information-notice power
A two-judge High Court rejected judicial-review challenges brought by Meta and WhatsApp, X and TikTok against information notices issued by Ofcom in February. The decision is the first court test of Ofcom’s power under section 100 of the Online Safety Act 2023 to require information for its online-safety functions. [1][2][3]
Ofcom sought definitions and data on user activity by age, moderated content and accounts, exposure of UK users including children, appeal outcomes and user reports. The notices seek regulatory data; the judgment does not find that any platform exposed a particular child to illegal content or violated a substantive safety duty. [2][4]
Judges found the platforms’ burden evidence insufficient
The court rejected arguments that Ofcom lacked power, acted for an improper purpose, predetermined the notices or failed to follow required procedures. It permitted the proportionality challenge to be argued but dismissed it after finding the companies had not supplied enough factual detail about baseline work and additional resource costs to show the notices were disproportionate. [1][2]
Meta said it was disappointed and maintained that information-gathering at this scale went beyond what was necessary or proportionate. TikTok said it was considering the judgment; X did not immediately respond to Reuters. Ofcom said information gathering is fundamental to its work. These are party responses, not further court findings. [3][4]
The ruling is important but narrower than the whole online-safety regime
The judgment leaves the notices in force and clarifies Ofcom’s section 100 power. Reuters reported that separate litigation remains over Ofcom’s fee and potential-fine calculations and WhatsApp’s categorization. This ruling does not resolve those disputes or establish the outcome of any future enforcement case based on the requested data. [3][1]
How the sources compare
| Source | What it adds | Scope or limitation |
|---|---|---|
| High Court judgment and press summary · primary record | The parties, statutory power, requested categories, legal grounds and reasons for dismissal. | The press summary is not the authoritative judgment; neither document resolves separate cases. |
| Reuters · independent legal reporting | Company and Ofcom responses and the relationship to other pending disputes. | The report summarizes rather than replaces the judgment. |
| PA via Nation.Cymru · independent court reporting | Hearing context and the practical data categories the platforms must provide. | It relies on the same public judgment and party submissions. |
What remains unclear
Whether any claimant seeks permission to appeal.
When the companies will complete the notices and whether Ofcom will open enforcement based on the data.
The outcomes of separate litigation over fees, potential fines and WhatsApp’s regulatory category.
Sources & translations
- Courts and Tribunals Judiciary — R (Meta, X, TikTok) v Ofcom
- Courts and Tribunals Judiciary — R (Meta, X, TikTok) v Ofcom press summary
- Reuters via The Straits Times — Meta, TikTok, X lose legal challenge against British watchdog over online safety data demands
- Nation.Cymru, carrying PA — Social media giants must provide vast amounts of data to Ofcom, court rules
Updates & corrections
- — Initial report distinguishes the validity of information notices from substantive safety violations and from separate pending Ofcom litigation.