Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Music & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 5, 2026

Alfred Adult Piano: Lesson Book 1 vs All-in-One Book 1

A teacher who assigns page 12 of Alfred’s Adult Lesson Book 1 is sending you to the grand staff, where you read the treble and bass staves together. In the Adult All-in-One, that lesson is on page 24. Buy the Lesson Book to follow a class that uses its page numbers. Choose the All-in-One if you have a free choice and want to write, read and play from the same volume. These are two ways into a first course, not two books to finish in succession.

Best for

An adult starting piano who needs the correct print book for a class, or a student and teacher deciding how to organize assignments between lessons.

Probably not for

A player seeking a collection of full-length classical scores or a course with a particular recording included. Neither selected edition is an audio or video bundle.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
What to checkAdult Lesson Book 1Adult All-in-One Book 1
Alfred item number00-223600-5753
Print ISBN-13978-0-88284-616-3978-0-88284-818-1
Page count112160
Course formatCore lessons with optional companion booksLessons, written theory and technique in one book
Grand staff lessonPage 12Page 24
A shared tune: Joy to the WorldPage 63Page 112

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Alfred’s Basic Adult Piano Course: Lesson Book 1, 00-2236

This is the 112-page lesson book. It introduces chord playing in both hands and points to related material that can be added separately. A teacher who supplies their own theory work can keep the playing sequence intact without assigning a second set of written exercises.

Pros

  • Matches assignments written for the original Lesson Book pagination
  • Identifies where separate books for theory, sight reading and duets can enter the course

Cons

  • The listed companion books are not inside this volume
  • A page reference from an All-in-One class will not reliably locate the same music

Who it’s for: Choose it if the class specifies item 2236 or you want your teacher to select any extra work individually.

Check Alfred’s Basic Adult Piano Course: Lesson Book 1, 00-2236 on Amazon

Alfred’s Basic Adult All-in-One Course: Book 1, 00-5753

The 160-page All-in-One adds written assignments, technique work and repertoire to the lesson material. Alfred identifies this print edition as wire-bound, so it opens flat on a music rest. The extra pages give a teacher several ways to approach a concept without changing books.

Pros

  • Keeps written responses beside the material they refer to
  • Wire binding opens flat for reading or pencil work

Cons

  • Contains substantial overlap if you already own the Lesson Book
  • Work completed in ink will stay in the same copy as the music

Who it’s for: Choose it when the student needs one book to bring to lessons and wants both playing and pencil assignments in it.

Check Alfred’s Basic Adult All-in-One Course: Book 1, 00-5753 on Amazon

What the two editions do with one lesson

Alfred’s samples make the difference visible without requiring you to know how to play. Find the page headed “The Grand Staff” in each. Both show a keyboard above a pair of staves. A brace at the left joins the two staves; below, an exercise asks the player to follow notes and rests. In the Lesson Book there is an explanation of the time signature and a short practice sequence. This is not a book that leaves you to work out the notation from songs alone.

The All-in-One page gives you blanks to fill before you play. One question asks you to identify a sign; another asks what each number in the time signature tells you. It is possible to copy the teacher’s hand movements through the exercise without knowing either answer. The blanks give the teacher and student a way to notice that difference. If you like marking a question for your next lesson, it can stay beside the bar of music that prompted it.

The page difference grows as you go. The grand staff moves by 12 pages; “Joy to the World” moves by 49. Do not make a bookmark that says to add 12 to every assignment. If you change editions mid-course, carry over the name of the piece and the skill you are working on. Ask the teacher to show you the new starting point, even if the tune looks familiar.

Decide who will choose the extra work

The Lesson Book has a useful feature for a teacher with an established routine: its opening chart names optional books and says when they can be introduced. The theory book, for example, can start at lesson page 7; the duet book comes in at page 13. Those are entry points, not a shopping list. If what you look forward to is playing with someone else, ask about the duet material. There is no particular reason to collect a shelf of supplements on the first day.

Consider a different lesson: you can play a C chord when your teacher shows you the keys, but you cannot name its notes after you close the cover. The next assignment might be to write the notes, find each one separately, then play them together. The All-in-One suits a teacher who wants related written and playing work in the book itself. The Lesson Book suits a teacher who prefers to draw one example in a notebook and decide the next example after hearing you play.

Longer does not mean more advanced, and shorter does not mean easier. Both books identify chords and ask you to play them. Count the number of different jobs in an assignment, not the number of pages turned. Writing two answers and playing four measures may be a full evening’s assignment if reading both staves is new to you.

Make the book work at your piano

Take a common early snag: you can name the notes, but the beat stops every time the left hand enters. Circle the entry in pencil. Count aloud through the measure before it, including any silence, then try the two measures together. If a regular click helps you hear the gap, this comparison of Korg and Seiko practice metronomes explains the differences between two standalone options. A click cannot tell you which hand missed the entrance; that is what your mark in the score is for.

Later, the Lesson Book introduces the damper pedal with “Harp Song.” If you play an electronic keyboard, first find out whether you have a working sustain control that suits that instrument. The Yamaha FC3A and FC5 pedal comparison is useful if those are the pedals named for your keyboard. Choosing the All-in-One instead of the Lesson Book does not change which pedal your keyboard accepts.

For a shared piano, decide where written answers will go. Two people can play from one open book; they cannot both have a fresh set of blanks in the same copy. A separate notebook can work for the second reader. Note the page, the question and the answer, not just a row of note names. Otherwise, a week later, the student or teacher has to reconstruct which example those notes belonged to.

Check the assignment, not just the cover

For a class purchase, ask for the item number or ISBN in the table above. “Alfred adult level one” leaves room for both of these books and for editions packaged with other materials. If the instructor has specified a recording, ask which recording and how the class uses it. Do not assume that a book-only copy includes it because an almost identical cover appears beside a disc in another listing.

If you already own one book, take it to the first lesson before replacing it. For private tuition, a teacher may be happy to assign a tune by name and give you a separate exercise. In a group where everyone turns to the same page together, the exact edition has a practical advantage. If you already read both staves and play these pieces comfortably, ask for a placement lesson instead. Another copy of the opening course is a poor substitute for finding the first thing you still want to learn.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 5, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.