Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed November 9, 2026
Ateco vs Wilton Icing Combs: Ridges or Filled Stripes?
For a low cake with a smooth top and combed sides, the Ateco 1447 puts a plain edge and several toothed ones on a single tool. For a taller cake or two-color stripes, choose the Wilton 417-1154: its set includes a long, square-notched edge that leaves channels you can fill. A full set of combs is unnecessary if you only want smooth frosting.
Best for
Bakers choosing between adding a little texture to a low layer cake and carrying a regular pattern all the way up a taller one.
Probably not for
Applying a crumb coat, piping raised ropes of frosting, or trimming uneven cake layers. Start with a spatula, a piping bag, or a cake knife for those jobs.
Specifications at a glance
| At the decorating stand | Ateco 1447 | Wilton 417-1154 |
|---|---|---|
| What comes in the package | One four-sided aluminum comb and smoother | Three double-sided pattern combs |
| Dimensions per tool | 6 by 3.8 inches in the Ateco catalog | 9 by 3 inches in the Wilton catalog |
| Edge choices | One smooth edge and three toothed edges | Six textures, including a square-notched pattern |
| After combing | Turn to the plain edge for smoothing | Use a separate straight edge to finish filled stripes |
| Storage | One flat piece | The three combs snap together |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Ateco 1447 Decorating Comb and Icing Smoother
A rectangular aluminum tool with four usable edges. Ateco lists it both for smoothing icing and for making designs on cake tops or sides.
Pros
- A plain edge is right there if you want to erase the pattern and start again
- One small tool can smooth the background and texture a section of it
Cons
- The two short edges cannot cover as much height as the long ones
- No edge reaches the full height of a seven-inch cake
Who it’s for: Pick the 1447 for a short layer cake, or for drawing a band across the top of a sheet cake and leaving room for lettering.
Check Ateco 1447 Decorating Comb and Icing Smoother on Amazon Paid linkWilton 417-1154 Three-Piece Icing Smoother Comb Set
Three nine-inch combs provide six textures. Wilton demonstrates the square-notched edge for two-color buttercream stripes; the set is separate from its plain icing smoother.
Pros
- Long sides suit a tall cake that would need two passes with a shorter tool
- A square notch forms a channel for piping in a second color
Cons
- A different straight tool is needed to scrape filled stripes flush
- The set takes up nine inches of drawer length even when snapped together
Who it’s for: Choose the set when the side of the cake is the decoration, particularly if you want a regular pattern from the board to the top rim.
Check Wilton 417-1154 Three-Piece Icing Smoother Comb Set on Amazon Paid linkMeasure the cake from the board up, not across the pan
A six-inch round cake can mean a cake six inches across or a tall stack that happens to stand six inches high. Only the second measurement tells you which comb will reach. Set a ruler beside the finished stack, with the bottom on the cake board. Include the filling and the frosting at the rim. The board itself does not count unless you plan to frost its edge too.
Consider a chocolate cake three inches high. The Ateco measures six inches along its long side and about three and three quarters along the short side. Either direction gives you room to work on that cake. Now picture a seven-inch-high birthday cake. Even the longest edge of the Ateco would stop well below the top. The nine-inch Wilton has room to extend above the rim. That extra reach matters because two trips around at different heights can leave a visible join halfway up the side.
Those measurements describe the whole tool, not a guarantee about the last tooth. If your cake is almost as tall as the comb, hold the pattern you actually want beside it before loading on the final coat. You may want a plain band at the base for a piped border. In that case the teeth only need to cover the decorated part, and the shorter tool you already own may be quite enough.
Choose an edge by the shadow it will leave
Think of a vanilla cake you want to serve without adding another color. Fine ridges catch the light along their crests while the furrows stay in shadow. A few parallel tracks can make the side look finished while leaving a smooth top for candles. The Ateco suits that cake: run the plain edge around first, look for bare patches, and use a toothed edge only when the base looks even. You do not have to find room on the counter for a separate smoother between the two passes.
If the plan is alternating strawberry and vanilla bands with no raised ridges in the final finish, look for a different shape. The teeth are temporary molds for a stripe, not the decoration you will serve. A shallow scratch that looks lovely in one color gives you very little room to lay down a line in another. Wilton uses the square notches on one of its combs to create distinct channels. You can buy the set for that one edge even if the other patterns never leave the drawer.
For a rectangular sheet cake, there is no need to decorate every inch. Try a narrow run of lines across one end and leave the larger area blank for a birthday message. Start a little beyond one side and finish just beyond the other so the tool does not stop halfway through the frosting. A short Ateco edge can define the width of that band. If you only wanted the soft sweeps left by a spoon, stop there and skip both combs.
Give the comb a steady reference at the base
Watch the gap between the comb and the frosting as you turn the cake once without touching it. If the gap changes on every revolution, the board may be off-center, or the stack may lean. Center the board first; patch an obvious hollow with buttercream before cutting the pattern. A toothed edge removes frosting from a high spot. It cannot supply the missing spoonful on the opposite side, no matter how many times you turn the cake.
Set the lower end on the board or platform and keep it there while the cake turns. If your hand lifts a little each time you reach for the stand, a row that starts at the bottom will climb by the time it comes back around. A spiral can be lovely, but it will not meet itself as a closed ring. If the board slides while the base stays put, the Ateco 612 and 615 turntable comparison explains the difference between grip under the board and grip under the stand.
Pick the back before making the first pass. On a cake with a name written across the top, the far edge of the lettering is a useful place to start and lift away. Pause there to wipe the comb and inspect the side in good light. If just one groove has a gap, dab frosting into that patch and bring the same edge back at the same height. Switching to another pattern will replace the design around the rest of the cake as well.
Make two-color stripes without scraping them away
For a cake with filled stripes, set out three things before you start: the square-notched Wilton comb, the second color in a piping bag, and a clean straight smoother. The first carves, the bag fills, and the last removes the excess. Using the toothed edge again at the end will scoop your new stripes back out. The tool called an icing smoother in Wilton’s striped-cake instructions is a separate item from its three-piece comb set.
In Wilton’s example, a leveled two-layer round gets a generous outer coat. After combing, the cake chills for at least thirty minutes, until the base frosting has formed a dry surface. That rest separates two jobs: working soft icing into a pattern, then filling that pattern without dragging the first color around. A wet streak of base color on the bag tip is a reason to pause. Watch the surface of the frosting as well as the clock, especially if you are using a different recipe.
Pipe into one groove at a time rather than painting a broad swath of contrasting icing across all of them. You can scrape off a line that sits a little proud of the surface; you cannot scrape a half-empty hollow full. Wipe the straight edge frequently so the surplus does not travel onto the next white band. For a second and third accent color, the Wilton reusable and disposable piping bag guide helps decide whether to wash and refill one bag or have the colors ready together.
When one comb earns its drawer space
Imagine packing a small decorating kit to take to a friend’s kitchen. For a short cake with a single-color finish, the Ateco can do both edge jobs. Take something to spread the frosting with, the comb, and a cloth to clean it between passes. For a tall celebration cake with alternating colors, pack the Wilton edge you need, a separate smoother, and the filled bags. Snapping all three combs together is useful for finding them again, but buying the set does not eliminate the straight tool from that packing list.
Finally, consider what happens after you finish decorating. If a rough patch will be hidden behind a row of piped shells or covered with toasted coconut, there is little reason to chase it with another pass. If the side will be completely exposed on a pedestal, look at the cake from serving height: the one uneven join guests can see is worth more attention than a tiny mark under the rim. Decide what will actually show before choosing the size and shape of the edge.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 9, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Ateco catalog: model 1447, aluminum construction, dimensions and intended uses
- Wilton manufacturer catalog: item 417-1154, dimensions of each comb, six textures and snap-together storage
- Wilton technique: square-notched comb, chilling the first color, filling the channels and smoothing the stripes
- Amazon US: Ateco 1447 silver four-sided decorating comb and icing smoother Paid link
- Amazon US: Wilton 417-1154 white and purple three-piece comb set Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.