Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed November 6, 2026

Ateco 5357 vs 14410: More Round Sizes or Two Edge Styles?

Choose Ateco 5357 for eleven plain round cutters covering a wider diameter range. Choose 14410 for five cutters with both plain and fluted edges, provided its narrower size range fits your recipes. The useful distinction is not eleven pieces versus five: it is more circle sizes versus two border styles on each piece.

Best for

Home bakers choosing a graduated stainless-steel round cutter set for rolled cookies, pastry pieces and fondant decorations.

Probably not for

Someone needing a guaranteed intermediate diameter not itemized in the documentation, a handled cutter, a rolling wheel or an oven-rated baking ring.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Buying detailAteco 5357Ateco 14410
Exact set11 Piece Plain Round Cutter Set5 Piece Double Sided Round Cutter Set
Manufacturer UPC014963053577014963144107
Number of cutters115
Edge choicesPlain roundPlain on one side, fluted on the other
Manufacturer diameter range0.75 to 3.63 inches1.63 to 3 inches
MaterialStainless steelStainless steel
Listing selection to checkPlain Edge, 11-piece round setDouble Sided - Fluted & Plain, Round (5 pcs)

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Ateco 5357 Plain Edge Round Cutters, Stainless Steel, 11-Piece Set

This is the plain-edge round assortment, with eleven cutters and a tin storage box. Its range extends both below and above the five-piece alternative. The extra pieces buy diameter choices, not fluted edges or a selection of unrelated cookie shapes.

Pros

  • Wider diameter range, including smaller circles below the 14410 range
  • Eleven plain round cutters and an included tin storage box

Cons

  • No fluted cutting edge
  • A larger size assortment may duplicate cutters you already use

Who it’s for: Choose 5357 when smooth circles and diameter flexibility are the priority. Skip it if a scalloped border is central to the design you intend to make.

Check Ateco 5357 Plain Edge Round Cutters, Stainless Steel, 11-Piece Set on Amazon

Ateco 14410 Double Sided Small Round Cutters, Stainless Steel, 5-Piece Set

Each of these five nesting cutters has one plain edge and one fluted edge. The set offers two border treatments within a smaller diameter range, rather than ten different round sizes. It is the small five-piece selection, not Ateco's separate six-piece double-sided assortment.

Pros

  • Both plain and fluted edges on each cutter
  • Five nesting pieces cover a focused range of round shapes

Cons

  • Does not reach the smaller or larger ends of the 5357 range
  • Both ends are cutting edges to account for when handling and storing

Who it’s for: Choose 14410 when both border styles will be used and the published size limits fit your projects. Skip it when a small center cutout or a circle over 3 inches is essential.

Check Ateco 14410 Double Sided Small Round Cutters, Stainless Steel, 5-Piece Set on Amazon

Start with the finished outline you want

A plain circle and a fluted circle make different visual starting points. The plain version leaves an uninterrupted outline for a simple round cookie, a pastry disc or a decoration whose detail will be added later. A fluted edge builds a repeated border into the cut shape itself. Neither is inherently more suitable for a special occasion. Look at the design you actually want to reproduce and decide whether that border belongs there before comparing the number of metal pieces.

This makes the 14410 appealing when the same baking session calls for both treatments. You can use a plain edge for one design and the opposite edge for another without buying a separate fluted assortment. On the other hand, if every project in your notebook uses smooth circles, the second edge has no particular job. In that situation, the additional diameter choices in the 5357 may be more relevant than a feature you will rarely use.

Read the range as boundaries, not a complete size list

The manufacturer gives the 5357 range as 0.75 to 3.63 inches and the 14410 range as 1.63 to 3 inches. Amazon describes the corresponding endpoints using familiar fractions: 3/4 to 3 5/8 inches and 1 5/8 to 3 inches. Those descriptions establish an important shopping boundary. A project requiring a circle smaller than the five-piece set's minimum cannot be solved simply by flipping one of its cutters to the other edge.

Neither of the linked manufacturer product pages itemizes every intermediate diameter. Do not assume the sets advance in a particular fraction, or that each contains an exact 2-inch size, solely from the endpoints and piece count. If a recipe, printed stencil or packaging insert depends on one precise circle, confirm that individual size before ordering. A flexible home-baking project can often begin with the cutter you own; a project that must match a specific template needs a more exact answer.

Count useful sizes rather than counting edges

Five double-sided cutters provide two edge treatments on five physical pieces. That is different from owning ten independently sized cutters. The distinction matters when you want a large outer circle and a smaller center opening, or several differently sized fondant dots. Start by listing the separate diameters the project needs, then add whether each outline should be plain or fluted. This short list exposes a missing size that a general claim of versatility can otherwise hide.

For a ring-shaped decoration, consider the outer size, the center opening and the width of material you want to leave between them. A smaller opening may make the 5357 range worth investigating, but it still does not prove that your ideal pair is included. For a sandwich-cookie plan, think separately about the base, top and optional window. Buying a set is useful when several of its pieces serve those roles, not simply because the package contains enough pieces to sound comprehensive.

Give an existing cutter collection a quick audit

Before buying another assortment, lay out the round cutters already in your drawer. Measure the openings, note their edge styles and identify what your next few recipes actually lack. A collection with several familiar plain circles may gain more from a fluted option than from another range of smooth circles. A collection of novelty holiday shapes may instead lack the basic round sizes that will be used throughout the year.

There is no requirement to replace every existing cutter with one matching set. If only a single missing diameter motivates this purchase, compare that need with an individual cutter before adding five or eleven pieces. Equally, do not assume that buying both sets creates sixteen distinct sizes. Their ranges overlap, and the available product descriptions do not supply enough intermediate measurements to count unique diameters accurately. Treat any duplicate as intentional only when you have a reason to keep it.

Separate cutting diameter from dough preparation

A round cutter determines the outline at the moment you press it through the dough. It does not set the thickness of the rolled sheet, establish the recipe's resting schedule or guarantee the final baked dimensions. Keep those decisions with the recipe. If uneven rolling is the problem you are trying to address, changing the cutter set does not address that particular step. Our OXO and Joseph Joseph rolling-pin comparison looks at a separate choice in preparing the sheet before cutting.

Plan the work area as a sequence: prepare the dough, select the needed sizes, cut the shapes and transfer them according to the recipe. Set aside the cutters that are not being used so the next size is easy to identify. A baking liner is also a separate purchase with its own instructions. Our Silpat and OXO baking-mat comparison can help with that decision, but a mat intended to line a tray should not automatically be treated as permission to cut against its surface.

Look beyond the nesting photograph

Nesting describes how the cutters fit together for storage, not how many you will want on the work surface at once. For a project using one circle, either set leaves most pieces unused during the session. For a design involving multiple sizes, arrange the working pieces in order and keep the storage area separate from the dough. This is a practical organization choice rather than evidence that one assortment cuts more accurately.

The 5357 listing explicitly describes a tin storage box. The 14410 description says its cutters nest within one another; do not treat a general Ateco brand photograph as a promise that every pictured accessory accompanies that selected set. Check the specific package contents if a case is essential to you. Also avoid using overall listing dimensions as though they were a complete drawing of each cutter. This comparison does not rank the sets by cutter height, which is described inconsistently across the available documentation.

Plan cleaning around the selected version

The manufacturer pages verify stainless-steel construction, but that fact alone is not a complete care instruction. If dishwasher use is essential to your routine, confirm permission for the exact set with Ateco and follow the directions supplied with it. Do not transfer cleaning advice from another cutter merely because the material and brand match. Include the storage container in that check as well; directions for a metal cutter do not automatically describe the right treatment for its box.

With either set, inspect the cutting edges and interior after washing, then let the pieces dry before nesting them away. For the double-sided design, remember that both ends have a cutting function when handling, washing and storing it. Keep the cutters where they will not be grabbed blindly among loose utensils. None of the verified descriptions used here establishes an oven-use rating, so do not repurpose a cutter as a baking ring on the strength of its metal construction alone.

Make the final choice around one real project

For a first purchase, write down a single project and the next two you realistically intend to make. Choose 5357 if those plans call for plain circles over a broad span of sizes and you have no immediate need for fluting. Choose 14410 if the narrower range is enough and both edge styles have a clear role. The recommendation is about documented contents and practical fit, not an assertion that one set produces better cookies or has been tested against the other.

At checkout, keep the exact round-set selection active. Ateco sells neighboring plain, fluted, double-sided and differently shaped assortments, and changing a variation can change both the piece count and size range. For the links here, look for Plain Edge with eleven round cutters or Double Sided - Fluted & Plain with Round (5 pcs). When the set arrives, check the actual contents and any essential diameter before preparing a time-sensitive batch. That final check matters more than choosing the package with the larger number.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 6, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.