Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed November 6, 2026
Ateco 786 vs 787: Which Piping Tip Set Fits Your Cakes?
Choose the Ateco 786 when you want several sizes within the plain and star families, plus a cake icer, cleaning brush and storage box. Choose the 787 when its six particular tips cover your planned designs, especially if you want the 898 basketweave tip. The smaller set is not simply half of the larger one: only their 804 and 808 plain tips overlap.
Best for
Home bakers choosing a stainless-steel nozzle assortment for piping cake decorations, cupcake toppings and pastry shapes with separately selected bags.
Probably not for
A buyer seeking a complete bag-and-coupler starter kit, dedicated fine-writing tips or a particular nozzle number that neither set contains.
Specifications at a glance
| Included component | Ateco 786 | Ateco 787 |
|---|---|---|
| Exact selection | 12 Piece Large Tube Set; Amazon Jumbo Tip Set, Silver | 6 Piece Pastry Tube Set; Amazon #787 6 pc selection |
| Manufacturer UPC | 014963007860 | 014963007877 |
| Tip material | Stainless steel | Stainless steel |
| Plain tips | 802, 804, 806, 808 | 804, 808 |
| Star tips | 822, 825, 828 | 827 |
| Closed-star tips | 843, 847 | 846 |
| French-star tips | 863, 869 | 864 |
| Other tip | 789 cake icer | 898 basketweave |
| Listed storage and cleaning extras | Plastic storage box and tube brush | No storage box or brush listed by Ateco |
| Bags and couplers | Not listed as included | Not listed as included |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Ateco 786 12-Piece Large Tube Set, Stainless Steel
This is the boxed stainless-steel assortment identified by manufacturer part number 786 and UPC 014963007860. Its twelve nozzles span several sizes of plain and star-style openings. A separate brush accompanies the tips; the advertised twelve is the nozzle count, not a total padded with the box and cleaning accessory.
Pros
- Multiple choices within each plain and star-style family
- Includes a 789 cake icer, a tube brush and a storage box
Cons
- Does not include the 787 set's 827, 846, 864 or 898 tips
- A bag and any needed coupler remain separate purchases
Who it’s for: Pick 786 when you can name several included sizes you will use or want its cake-icing accessory. Pass if one specific 787-only nozzle is the reason you are shopping.
Check Ateco 786 12-Piece Large Tube Set, Stainless Steel on Amazon Paid linkAteco 787 6-Piece Stainless Steel Pastry Tube Set
The selected 787 assortment contains two plain tips and one each in star, closed-star, French-star and basketweave styles. It offers a focused selection, not the full range of sizes in the 786. Manufacturer documentation lists the six metal tips without a storage box, brush, pastry bag or coupler.
Pros
- Includes the 898 basketweave tip and three star-style alternatives absent from 786
- Six numbered pieces make a short, specific shopping list
Cons
- Only one size in each star-style family
- Requires your own storage and cleaning arrangement
Who it’s for: Pick 787 for a design plan that calls for its particular tips, or to complement tools you already own. Pass if you want a boxed size assortment or the 789 cake icer.
Check Ateco 787 6-Piece Stainless Steel Pastry Tube Set on Amazon Paid linkStart with the nozzle number in your project
Take the cake photograph, class supply sheet or recipe you intend to follow and write down the actual tip numbers. A shopping list that says only star tip leaves an important decision unresolved. In these sets, the star, closed-star and French-star selections differ completely. Buying the larger box does not guarantee that the nozzle named by your instructor will be inside. The inventory table above is more useful for that decision than either package's headline piece count.
Neither selection is a substitute for every decorating technique. If your first goal is a narrow written birthday message, check the specified writing tip separately; these assortments are not dedicated writing sets. Similarly, a project built around a particular leaf or petal nozzle needs that shape, not an assortment purchased on the assumption that twelve must cover everything. Begin with the project you will actually make, then decide whether additional shapes serve the next few projects you have in mind.
More sizes and more styles are different purchases
The 786 gives you four plain tips, while the 787 supplies two. Both include 804 and 808, so a baker whose planned work uses only those two numbers gains no additional plain-tip option by choosing 786. Its extra 802 and 806 matter when those sizes fill a real gap. Treat the expanded range as a set of specific choices, not evidence that every result will look more polished.
The distinction becomes less intuitive among the textured openings. The 786 includes closed-star 843 and 847, whereas the 787 includes 846. Its two French-star selections are 863 and 869, versus 864 in the smaller assortment. These are alternatives, not duplicate shapes supplied in different quantities. If you are experimenting freely, a range can be useful; if you are reproducing a named design, the exact match matters more. Manufacturer tip numbers also should not be treated as an automatic cross-brand equivalence chart.
Decide whether you want a cake icer or basketweave tip
The other substantial difference is the nozzle outside the plain and star families. Ateco describes the 786's 789 as a cake icer and the 787's 898 as a basketweave tube. Those names point to different plans for the cake surface. If you want the particular 898 used in a basketweave lesson, it is in the six-tip package. If the 789 cake icer is the tool on your list, the twelve-tip package supplies it. Do not assume the two pieces are interchangeable simply because both can be used on a cake.
Picture the whole decorating sequence before buying. Will the side receive a deliberately piped pattern, or will you apply icing and then work toward a smooth surface? For the latter plan, the nozzle is only one part of your setup. Our Ateco 612 and 615 turntable comparison considers how the cake board and stand are held in place while you work. A new tip assortment does not resolve an awkwardly positioned cake or a stand that does not suit your workspace.
Plan the bag connection before filling anything
Neither manufacturer contents list includes a pastry bag or coupler. A coupler is the connection that lets you change compatible tips while leaving the filling in the bag, but it must suit the nozzle. Ateco distinguishes standard, medium and large couplers in its catalog. That is a reason to check compatibility for each intended combination, not to add a standard coupler automatically because the tips and connector share a brand name.
Lay out the empty bag, selected tip and any connector together before committing frosting to the setup. Consult their fitting instructions before trimming a bag opening; do not cut it to accommodate one piece and assume every other nozzle will seat the same way. If you need bags as well, our Wilton reusable and disposable 16-inch piping-bag comparison addresses that separate choice. Bag length, bag quantity and tip selection answer different questions, so build the purchase around all three rather than expecting the nozzle set to supply the entire kit.
Check what an existing collection already covers
For someone replacing an incomplete decorating kit, the shortest useful audit is to put the existing tips on a tray and read their markings. Sort that list into pieces you use, pieces you are missing and pieces you have never needed. A larger assortment can duplicate familiar tools while still omitting the one you wanted. Conversely, the smaller set may introduce precisely the textured nozzles absent from your current collection.
There is also a concrete consequence to buying both. Comparing Ateco's published lists produces sixteen distinct nozzle numbers from eighteen supplied tips, because 804 and 808 appear twice. Duplicate tips may be intentional if you want the same opening ready on two separate bags, but they are not two extra designs. Count distinct requirements first. If only one missing number motivates the purchase, investigate that individual component before committing to another whole assortment.
Give the tips a drying and storage routine
The 786 includes a tube-cleaning brush and plastic storage box, making those accessories part of its practical appeal. The 787 documentation lists no equivalent extras. That does not make the six tips less useful; it means you should already have, or plan, a way to clean and contain them. A drawer full of loose metal nozzles is a different ownership experience from an identified set kept together for the next baking session.
The linked 787 listing specifies hand washing. For 786, consult the supplied care directions rather than assuming that stainless steel establishes permission for every cleaning method or for the plastic box. Inspect the openings for leftover icing and let cleaned pieces dry before closing them away. Keeping a simple inventory with your tools is worthwhile: after a busy decorating session, a missing nozzle is easier to identify by number than by trying to remember which vaguely similar star shape was there.
Make the final choice by included tasks, not quantity
For a baker building an assortment around several plain and star sizes, the 786 has a clear role: more numbered options, the 789 cake icer and included organization accessories. For a baker with a short list centered on 827, 846, 864 or 898, the 787 is the more direct match despite its lower piece count. Neither choice warrants a claim of better piping performance from the specifications alone. The decisions here concern contents, preparation and fit with your projects, not comparative hands-on testing.
At checkout, distinguish the 786 stainless set from other Ateco twelve-piece sets, and keep the 787 six-piece selection active rather than changing to a neighboring option. The linked 786 page uses the title Jumbo Tip Set, Silver, but its manufacturer part number and UPC match Ateco's documentation. When the package arrives, reconcile the actual stamped numbers with your project list before the day you need them. That small check is especially important when following a lesson that depends on one exact nozzle.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 6, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Ateco: 786 identity, UPC, twelve numbered stainless tips, brush and plastic storage box
- Ateco: 787 identity, UPC, six numbered stainless tips and their shape families
- Ateco catalog: set inventories on printed pages 6-7 and standard, medium and large coupler distinctions on page 23
- Amazon US: Jumbo Tip Set, Silver; part number 786, UPC 014963007860, twelve tips with brush and box Paid link
- Amazon US: selected #787 six-piece set; model 787, matching GTIN 00014963007877 and hand-wash instruction Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.