Lawn & Garden Comparisons · Reviewed November 12, 2026
Burpee SuperSeed Trays: 36 Cells or 16 XL for Seedlings?
Choose the 36-cell SuperSeed for a batch of starts that will leave the tray together, such as two dozen lettuce plants for a new bed. Choose the 16 XL for a smaller batch, such as a dozen tomatoes you intend to keep, when you would rather give each plant more room from the start. Both let you push out one seedling from below. The difference is how many places you have to fill today and how much room you will need when those plants come out.
Best for
Home gardeners sowing indoors who want reusable individual cells and a separate tray to catch drainage.
Probably not for
Growing a crop to maturity indoors, sowing a broadcast flat of microgreens, or buying a complete seed-starting setup with mix, light and humidity cover.
Specifications at a glance
| At the seed bench | SuperSeed 36 Cell | SuperSeed 16 XL Cell |
|---|---|---|
| Burpee item number | 96512 | 93412 |
| Grid in the tray | 6 by 6; 36 individual cells | 4 by 4; 16 extra-large individual cells |
| One marked row holds | Six planting positions | Four planting positions |
| How seedlings come out | Press up on one flexible silicone bottom | Press up on one flexible silicone bottom |
| Water handling | Corner drainage slots and a separate catch tray | Corner drainage slots and a separate catch tray |
| What to supply | Seeds, seed-starting mix and a suitable light source; no dome or coir pellets | Seeds, seed-starting mix and a suitable light source; no dome or coir pellets |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Burpee SuperSeed 36 Cell reusable seed starting tray, item 96512
Six rows of six give each transplant a separate starting place. The row and column markings correspond to a paper planting map.
Pros
- Room for 24 starts plus 12 spare positions in one tray.
- Six starts of the same variety fit neatly in a single row.
Cons
- Less room per seedling than the XL cells.
- Keeping all 36 plants after they need larger pots can take considerably more shelf space.
Who it’s for: A batch for a bed, a plant sale or a neighbor, with somewhere for the seedlings to go as they outgrow the cells.
Check Burpee SuperSeed 36 Cell reusable seed starting tray, item 96512 on Amazon Paid linkBurpee SuperSeed 16 XL Cell reusable seed starting tray, item 93412
Four rows of four give a smaller collection more room per plant. The larger cells have the same individual push-out action as the regular size.
Pros
- Four starts each of four varieties fit on a simple row-by-row map.
- An extra-large pocket gives a young root ball more room before its next move.
Cons
- A single tray cannot give 24 plants their own cells.
- XL cells still have a limit; a delayed planting date can mean moving the plants into pots.
Who it’s for: A small group of keeper plants, particularly when you have more use for root space than for another twenty starts.
Check Burpee SuperSeed 16 XL Cell reusable seed starting tray, item 93412 on Amazon Paid linkCount the places in the garden first
Take a pencil to the planting plan before opening a seed packet. Suppose a new bed has room for 24 lettuce transplants at the spacing on your packet. On the 36-cell tray, four complete rows give you 24 places and the remaining two can hold spares. On the 16 XL, filling every pocket still leaves you eight short. Sowing two seeds per XL cell might give you more leaves, but it does not give you a second root ball that lifts out separately. For a bed you want to plant in one session, the 36 solves the actual problem.
Now picture six patio planters, each earmarked for one tomato. You want one backup of each variety until you know which plants are doing well. Twelve XL cells cover the plan, with four left over. Filling the other tray simply because it has more holes would commit you to finding homes for extra plants. It is perfectly reasonable to leave cells empty in either version. If the important number is twelve, the case for the XL is the room each of those twelve gets, not a promise that a bigger pocket makes a seed germinate.
Leave direct-sown crops off this count. If your carrot packet calls for sowing in place, the length of your carrot row tells you nothing about which indoor tray to buy. If you normally buy two tomato transplants and direct-sow everything else, a couple of clean pots with drainage and a saucer may already cover your spring plan.
Map varieties so a tray can turn without losing its place
Burpee marks the grid with letters and numbers and includes a Plant-o-Gram, its paper map. Record a corner by its printed marking, not by its position next to the window. Then the map still works if you rotate the tray or carry it to the sink. Two pepper varieties can look much alike before they fruit. A name scribbled beside “left half” is no help once you have turned the tray around; a variety assigned to a marked row still has an address.
The six-by-six layout particularly suits six starts of each of several varieties. If you only want three of a variety, split a row in half on the map and mark which end holds which packet. On the four-by-four grid, four varieties with four starts each occupy one row apiece, with no dividing line to remember. If a cell fails and you resow it, add the new sowing date to that one entry. A younger plant in the middle of a row need not leave the tray when its neighbors do.
A shared tray also means a shared trip outdoors. Read the packet dates before assigning two crops to adjacent rows. If one batch will be ready for cool spring days while the other still belongs indoors, matching their planting calendars matters more than filling the grid. Separate pots or two smaller batches let you carry the ready plants out without moving the others. A blank row gives leaves extra space but does not make the two halves of the tray portable.
Reserve space for the second pot
Set out the pots you would use if the garden stayed too wet to plant. For example, 24 square pots measuring three inches across need a rectangle at least 18 by 12 inches when arranged six across and four deep, before allowing for rims or a drainage tray. That is the next home for just four rows of the 36-cell model. Look at the area your light actually covers, not only the width of the shelf. Pots that fit in the dark strip at the far end do not solve the problem.
The XL version is useful when you expect to keep a few plants indoors longer, but it buys space, not a fixed number of weeks. Utah State University Extension points to leaves beginning to overlap and roots filling the cell as cues to move a seedling. You might have one vigorous tomato ready for a pot while another in the same tray has barely spread its first true leaves. Inspect those two plants individually rather than picking a single transplant date because they were sown together.
For a different way to save space at the start, the Ladbrooke Mini 4 vs Micro 20 soil blocker guide explains how to make freestanding blocks and move a smaller block into a larger one. That is useful if you want to rearrange individual starts on a flat. The Burpee insert keeps the empty cell in its place even after you remove the plant.
A catch tray is not a self-watering kit
On both SuperSeed models the colored cell bottoms flex, the slots let excess water out and the base catches it. Burpee sells other systems with a wick mat or humidity dome. Its SuperSeed kits do not include a dome or expanding coir pellets. Have seed-starting mix ready when the tray arrives. A household measuring cup can supply water to the base; no special nozzle is needed to reach an empty corner. If you also water individual pots on a crowded shelf, the Bloem vs Elho watering can comparison addresses that separate question of spout reach.
For either grid, moisten the mix before filling the cells so the first watering does not have to soak a dry pocket from top to bottom. The University of Minnesota Extension notes that a misted surface can look wet while the mix beneath stays dry. Water can also move up from the base; drain what remains after the mix absorbs what it needs. The raised edge keeps drainage off the shelf, but it is not a mark telling you how much water to leave there between visits.
Check a planted edge cell as well as one in the middle. An empty XL cell or a spare row with barely sprouted seeds cannot tell you how much water a leafy transplant next door is using. Neither tray distinguishes between those plants for you. If two batches consistently need different care, pot up the ready ones or start the next sowing separately rather than keeping the whole tray wetter for the sake of one plant.
Move one plant without emptying the row
Set the receiving pot nearby, fill it with moist mix and make a hole before lifting the insert from the catch tray. Press the flexible bottom of the occupied cell and support the plug as it rises. The goal is to move roots and their surrounding mix together, not to tug on the stem. If a plant needs steadying from above, support a leaf. Transfer the variety name to the new pot immediately: once a tomato is out of its marked cell, the paper grid alone can no longer identify it.
If you are lifting the whole batch, move across each recorded row in order. If only one plant is ready, cross out just its position and put the insert back on its base. The same release method works on both sizes. Choose the 36 when you can name a destination for its extra plants, the 16 XL when the number you want to keep already fits in four rows of four. If neither the garden nor the lighted shelf has space for another pot, changing the tray will not create that space.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 12, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Burpee: 36-cell tray, item 96512, six-row grid photos and individual cell construction
- Burpee: 16 XL tray, item 93412, four-row grid photos and drainage features
- Burpee: differences between the SuperSeed trays, greenhouse kits and self-watering systems
- Utah State University Extension: recognizing when a seedling needs more space
- University of Minnesota Extension: watering, drainage and supporting the root ball when moving a seedling
- Amazon US: Burpee SuperSeed reusable starter tray, 36-cell variant Paid link
- Amazon US: Burpee SuperSeed reusable starter tray, 16 XL cell variant Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.