Art & Craft Comparisons · Reviewed November 12, 2026
Caran d’Ache Neocolor I vs II: Wax Resist or Wash?
Neocolor I keeps a wax pattern visible beneath a watercolor wash. Neocolor II lets the wash begin in the pattern itself: draw a line, pick up a damp brush and pull color from it. Both come as sticks you can use dry. The reason to buy one over the other is what you want water to do next.
Best for
Artists choosing a first set of wax pastels for patterned illustrations, dry rubbings or sketchbook drawings finished with a brush.
Probably not for
Artists shopping for a powdery soft pastel, a pointed watercolor pencil or a way to mask a shape and then uncover bare paper.
Specifications at a glance
| Set detail | Neocolor I | Neocolor II Aquarelle |
|---|---|---|
| Standard assortment | 10 colors, ref. 7000.310 | 10 colors, ref. 7500.310 |
| Stick diameter | 8.65 mm | 8.65 mm |
| Medium | Water-resistant wax pastel | Water-soluble wax oil pastel |
| When used dry | Direct drawing, overlays and texture rubbings | Direct drawing; selected passages can be wetted later |
| Role of a damp brush | Apply a separate wash around or over the wax marks | Draw color out of the pastel marks or pick it up from a palette |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Caran d’Ache Neocolor I, standard 10-color set (7000.310)
Water-resistant wax sticks for building a picture with strokes, layered shapes and rubbings. Choose these if a later watercolor pass should reveal a pattern rather than dissolve it.
Pros
- A separate wash can pass over a wax pattern without turning that pattern into paint
- The side of a stick can catch a raised texture through paper
Cons
- Water will not draw out a graded wash from the stick
- Wax left on the sheet is not a removable mask
Who it’s for: A patterned book cover illustration, a relief rubbing or a dry drawing finished with a separate watercolor.
Check Caran d’Ache Neocolor I, standard 10-color set (7000.310) on Amazon Paid linkCaran d’Ache Neocolor II Aquarelle, standard 10-color set (7500.310)
Water-soluble sticks that work dry or supply color to a brush. They suit drawings in which only some edges should dissolve, and small paintings for which the sticks double as a palette.
Pros
- One mark can have a firm edge on one side and a brushed shadow on the other
- Color mixed on a palette can be applied without leaving a crayon outline
Cons
- A wet pass across a line can move color you meant to leave alone
- A wash adds paper and drying requirements that dry sketching does not have
Who it’s for: A travel sketch, a soft-edged still life or a drawing with a few deliberately brushed passages.
Check Caran d’Ache Neocolor II Aquarelle, standard 10-color set (7500.310) on Amazon Paid linkA fish with bright scales, or a fish with a shadow?
Picture a small illustration of a mackerel on a blue plate. One way to draw the fish is to put down its pale scales first, then sweep a blue watercolor across the whole body. Neocolor I suits that sequence. Each arc of wax can remain visible against the blue that settles on the exposed paper. Another way is to draw a stripe of blue along the back and pull that blue down toward the belly, leaving the belly almost white. The color for that shadow has to come from the stripe. That calls for Neocolor II.
This is why the Roman numeral matters more than the number of colors on the lid. Both standard sets contain ten sticks, each 8.65 mm across. You can turn either stick on its side for a broad stroke or use an edge for a narrow one. The II is not an upgrade that does everything the I does. If the point of the picture is a row of scales that will stand up to a wet brush, solubility is precisely the feature you do not want.
Use Neocolor I when the pattern goes down first
For a repeat pattern on a book cover illustration, try drawing pairs of little leaves in a pale Neocolor I on watercolor paper. Leave a gap between the two halves of each leaf, then brush a darker watercolor over the row. The wash can settle in the gaps to suggest veins. Those veins do not require a fine brush because you drew their boundaries in wax at the start. Plan the gaps before filling the leaves; once the wax bridges one, a watery line painted on top is a poor way to reopen it.
Paper texture becomes part of the design. A light stroke across a rough sheet catches the high spots and skips the hollows. A wash can reach those hollows, leaving flecks of background color inside the leaf. That is attractive on a speckled leaf, less so on a geometric border intended to look solid. For a border, a smoother sheet or closer, overlapping strokes make more sense. The guide to hot-press and cold-press watercolor blocks explains the choice of surface if you also need the sheet to carry an overall wash.
Resist is not the same as masking. The pale mark on the leaf is wax, not a patch of bare paper you can uncover and paint later. If the plan is to reserve a white window, then fill it with a delicate yellow wash after the background dries, leave the window untouched or use a removable mask suitable for the paper. Neocolor I is the better choice for a permanent pale motif, not a temporary placeholder.
Use Neocolor II to give one line two edges
For a sketch of a folded napkin, draw the deepest crease with the edge of a blue Neocolor II. Touch a damp brush to one side of the line and draw it outward into the shadow. Leave the other side dry to describe the crisp edge of the fold. You do not have to wet the whole drawing. In fact, part of the appeal is the contrast between the dry, broken strokes of the woven cloth and the softer color tucked underneath it.
Move the mixing off the drawing if a visible starting line would look wrong. Rub a little pastel onto a smooth mixing palette and pick up that color with a damp brush. A pale shadow under a white cup can then begin as a brush shape rather than a blue crayon outline. Reserve a little clear space on the palette to dilute the mix. For a bigger shadow, mix enough before you start; repeatedly going back to the stick can give the far end of the shape a darker value than the near end.
A reservoir brush can be convenient outside, but match the brush to the patch you intend to wet. A narrow point can reach just one fold; a larger tip covers a sky with fewer passes. If those are the two jobs you alternate between, the Pentel Aquash small and medium brush comparison helps separate a brush-width decision from a pastel decision. Changing the brush changes how you deliver water. It will not turn Neocolor I into a source of watercolor.
Two ways to use the same afternoon sketch
Suppose you want to record the ribbed texture of a leaf. Put the leaf under a sheet of drawing paper and pass the side of a Neocolor I over it. The raised veins supply the pattern without requiring you to draw each branch. As a dry rubbing, that sheet can be quite thin so it conforms to the leaf. If you want to float a wash over the rubbing later, the paper must serve two jobs: flexible enough to pick up the veins, sturdy enough for the amount of water you intend to add. A heavy watercolor sheet may solve only the second problem.
Now imagine that the sketch is a color note instead: you want to remember the leaf turning from green to yellow along one edge. Draw the two patches with Neocolor II and bring them together with a damp brush only where the colors meet. Keep a little of each patch dry as a reference for the original hues. Later, the page tells you both what you saw and what your brush did to it. If you work in a pocket notebook with thin pages, make the painted version on a separate piece of watercolor paper and tuck it into the book once dry.
What belongs in a ten-stick kit?
Start with what is already in your bag. A small pan of watercolor and a brush can already make a wash; adding Neocolor I gives you a dry pattern that the pan cannot make by itself. If you like painting but dislike outlining every shape in pencil first, Neocolor II offers a different economy: some of the drawing becomes the paint. Get the standard 7000.310 for the first arrangement and 7500.310 for the second. Ten metallic Neocolor I pastels are a different assortment, even though the numeral and count on the label look right.
Neither box is the first thing to reach for if you need a powdery mark you can feather with a finger, or a point that can place tiny lettering between two ruled lines. Look at soft pastels for the former and pencils or a fine pen for the latter. And if all the picture needs is one pale wax highlight under a wash, try the water-resistant crayon you already own on an offcut. A whole set earns its space when different colored marks, not just one patch of white, are part of the picture.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 12, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Caran d’Ache: Neocolor I standard assortment 7000.310, stick diameter and dry techniques
- Caran d’Ache: Neocolor II standard assortment 7500.310, stick diameter and wet or dry use
- Caran d’Ache: the difference between water-resistant and water-soluble pastels
- Amazon US: Neocolor I water-resistant wax pastels, standard 10 colors Paid link
- Amazon US: Classic Neocolor II water-soluble pastels, standard 10 colors Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.