Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Sewing & Craft Comparisons · Reviewed November 5, 2026

Clover 8816 vs 8800 Punch Needle: Yarn or Floss?

A ball of medium-weight yarn and a piece of monk’s cloth point to the blue Clover 8816 Punch Needle. Three strands of embroidery floss and a small drawing on cotton twill point to the 8800 Embroidery Stitching Tool. Both tools leave loops on the far side of the cloth. The difference is the scale at which you can draw: think of filling the body of a bird in yarn versus drawing its feet in thread.

Best for

Someone choosing a punch needle for a specific pattern, or trying to use yarn, floss and fabric already in the sewing basket.

Probably not for

Someone fastening a seam, embroidering directly on a stretchy T-shirt or looking for a complete project with a hoop, cloth and fibers included.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Project detail8816 Punch Needle8800 Embroidery Stitching Tool
What feeds through itMedium to bulky yarnIncluded needle: three strands of No. 25 embroidery floss or No. 40 lace yarn
Backing for this setupCoarse, sturdy cloth such as monk’s clothDense nonstretch cloth such as Oxford cotton or twill
Depth adjustmentSpacer rings: 2.5, 3.5, 4.5 or 5.5 cm of exposed needleFive needle positions in the holder; position 3 is standard
Starting stitch spacing in Clover’s instructions5 to 8 mm, adjusted for yarn and appearance2 to 3 mm with the supplied three-strand needle
Threading accessories in the packTapestry needle and stringNeedle threader

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Clover Punch Needle 8816, blue

Use this one when the yarn itself is part of the drawing. A stripe made from one row of chunky loops looks quite different from a stripe built up out of many rows of floss. The spacer rings change how deeply the same needle goes into the cloth, so you can vary the relief without swapping tools or changing colors.

Pros

  • Medium and bulky yarn suit bold outlines and blocks of color
  • Four repeatable length settings let you return to a previous texture

Cons

  • Broad yarn can swallow narrow gaps in a motif
  • Long settings need clearance under the stretched cloth

Who it’s for: Choose the 8816 for a wall panel with a few big shapes on a punch-needle backing. Leave it out of the basket for a fine monogram on tightly woven cotton.

Check Clover Punch Needle 8816, blue on Amazon

Clover Embroidery Stitching Tool 8800, three-strand needle

The 8800 package includes the handle, a three-strand needle and a threader. Its smaller stitches give you room to turn a corner or leave a sliver of background between two lines. You can use the same handle with other Clover needle sizes, but buying the tool does not give you the whole range.

Pros

  • Finer starting scale suits lettering and narrow stems
  • Replaceable needle lets the handle serve other thread sizes later

Cons

  • An intact six-strand length of floss calls for a different needle
  • Covering a broad background in fine thread takes many passes

Who it’s for: Pick the 8800 to draw with floss. If a pattern calls for a particular refill, match that number as well as the handle before gathering the other supplies.

Check Clover Embroidery Stitching Tool 8800, three-strand needle on Amazon

Start with the smallest gap in the drawing

Take a design with two cherries on joined stems. At the size of a dinner plate, the fruit and the stems might all work in medium yarn. On a pocket-sized patch the fruit may still read clearly, but two yarn stems could merge into one. Lay a strand across the narrowest gap on the paper pattern at its finished size. If that strand already hides the gap, shortening the 8816 needle will not turn it into a finer line.

If you love the yarn more than the drawing, enlarge the motif or simplify the part that disappears. If the size of the patch is fixed, keep the drawing and choose the 8800 with floss. The stitch-spacing figures in the table are distances between punches along a line, not guarantees about how wide the finished line will look. The looped face spreads differently from the flatter face, so look at the side you plan to display.

Read the cloth as carefully as the yarn label

The needle has to enter the backing, but the backing also has to hold what the needle leaves behind. Clover pairs the 8816 with sturdy, coarse fabric such as monk’s cloth. For the needle supplied with the 8800, it lists denser materials. A scrap of nonstretch denim may be a sensible place to try the floss tool; it is not a reason to push the thicker yarn needle through an old jacket.

A useful sampler need not be a miniature of the whole picture. On an offcut of your actual cloth, draw one curve, one corner and two parallel lines as close together as the ones in the design. Hoop the cloth so it stays taut, then stitch those marks with the intended fiber. Turn the hoop over. Are the two lines still separate? Did a bare spot appear inside the corner? A different setting, a simpler corner or a change of backing is easier now than halfway through the picture.

If you plan to transfer a template in chalk, keep any line fine enough to tell which side of it you mean to punch. The Clover Chaco Liner vs triangle tailor’s chalk guide compares following a narrow edge with marking a broader curve. Check that your chosen mark comes off the offcut, especially where bare cloth will remain visible.

Depth, direction and the table underneath

On the 8816, 5.5 cm is the longest exposed needle setting, not a promise of a loop standing 5.5 cm tall. Leave space below the hoop for the whole stroke. A shallow hoop resting flat on a tabletop can stop the tip before the handle reaches the cloth. Clover recommends its separate raised punch-needle hoop for long settings. Keep the hand holding the hoop out of the path of the point.

For the supplied 8800 needle, start at the holder’s standard third position. Mark the working side of the cloth deliberately. For a flat stitched initial you can follow the letter as it reads on that face. For an initial made of loops, the loops appear on the other side: reverse the outline before tracing it on the back. A lowercase b on a scrap is a better rehearsal for that choice than a symmetrical heart.

If the previous loop vanishes as you make the next one, first check whether the working thread is free to move. A ball trapped under the project bag can tug the yarn without your noticing. Put some slack beside the hoop. Punch fully, withdraw straight and slide the point just above the cloth to reach the next spot. A higher lift pulls on the very loop you are trying to leave behind.

Will anything catch the finished loops?

A picture behind a frame and a pouch that rubs against keys ask different things of the back. For the 8816, Clover distinguishes securing the yarn ends on a low-contact panel from securing the whole reverse on an item that can snag. Plan that finishing step before sewing a panel into a lining; you need access to the side you intend to secure. For either tool, follow the finishing directions for the chosen materials before trimming loops or tails.

Pass on both if your design is made of loose wisps of wool rather than a continuous strand. The Clover needle-felting tool comparison explains the tools for attaching wool fibers to a base without feeding them through a hollow needle. And if the only job is a single straight line of initials and you already have an ordinary embroidery needle, draw the first letter with that. A punch tool earns its place when the loops or the repeated punching motion are part of the result you want.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 5, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.