Craft & DIY Comparisons · Reviewed October 31, 2026
Clover Amour vs Soft Touch: Where Does Your Thumb Sit?
Choose the Amour if your fingers move around the handle as you turn a stitch. Choose the Soft Touch if your thumb likes a broad place to land each time. Both are single Clover size H hooks with a 5 mm aluminum working end. The meaningful choice is what your hand meets behind the yarn.
Best for
Crocheters choosing one H hook for a pattern, replacing a missing hook mid-project or deciding which grip to try before buying more sizes.
Probably not for
A pattern that calls for another diameter, fine steel thread hooks, or a Tunisian project that must hold a whole row of loops on the hook.
Specifications at a glance
| At the worktable | Clover Amour | Clover Soft Touch |
|---|---|---|
| U.S. item number | 1047/H | 1008/H |
| Linked size and count | H, 5.0 mm; one hook | H, 5.0 mm; one hook |
| Working end | Aluminum | Aluminum |
| Handle construction | Curved elastomer grip, soft around the handle | Wide ABS resin handle with a soft grip area |
| Finding the H | Deep blue in the size-coded Amour line | Large size marking on the handle |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Clover Amour 1047/H, deep blue, 5.0 mm
On the Amour, the soft material surrounds the grip. If you start a stitch with your thumb on top and finish it with your fingers slightly farther around the side, you are still holding elastomer. The deep blue H is also easy to pick out if the rest of your hooks are color-coded Amours.
Pros
- Curved grip gives the fingers more than one soft place to rest
- Color helps identify this size within the Amour family
- A single H lets you try the shape on a familiar project
Cons
- The curve is still a particular shape, not a plain cylindrical handle
- Blue is a cue within this line, not a universal marking for 5 mm
Who it’s for: Pick it for a hand that rolls the handle or settles in different places for different stitches. If you want a distinct spot you can find with your thumb without looking, consider the Soft Touch.
Check Clover Amour 1047/H, deep blue, 5.0 mm on Amazon Paid linkClover Soft Touch 1008/H, 5.0 mm
The Soft Touch pairs a wide handle with a soft grip area. Its shape gives the thumb a landmark: set the hook down to count stitches, pick it up again, and there is a particular face to return to. Clover also prints a large size marking, useful when different hooks share a drawer.
Pros
- Broad face suited to a thumb that stays in one spot
- Large marking lets you identify the hook without remembering a color
- Rounded tip and modest groove are documented features of this line
Cons
- The cushioned area may not be where your fingers naturally land
- Choosing the wide handle does not change the 5 mm diameter that forms the loop
Who it’s for: Pick it if you already look for a thumb rest on a bare metal hook. If your favorite part of the handle is usually its side, the Amour gives you soft material there as well.
Check Clover Soft Touch 1008/H, 5.0 mm on Amazon Paid linkWatch your thumb on three stitches
Take a hook you already own and work three stitches slowly. On the first, notice where your thumb meets the handle as you insert the hook. On the second, watch what happens as you catch the yarn and draw it back. On the third, look at your fingers as the new loop settles onto the shaft. Does your thumb come back to one spot each time, or do the pads of several fingers take turns steering? That observation is more useful than deciding that one of these is the hook for all beginners.
A pencil hold puts the handle between the fingers; a knife hold brings the hand over it. Neither name settles the purchase. Two people using a knife hold might steer quite differently: one presses a thumb against the face, while the other rolls the handle between thumb and fingers. The first has a reason to look at the Soft Touch. The second may prefer the Amour. Keep the hold you normally use when judging the shape. Changing your hand position just to reach a cushion defeats the point of buying that cushion.
What 18 stitches instead of 16 will do to a panel
Suppose a pattern calls for 16 stitches in four inches and a bag panel is 48 stitches across. At the intended gauge, that panel is 12 inches wide. If you get 18 stitches in four inches with the same yarn, 48 stitches span about 10⅔ inches. That is more than an inch short before you turn the panel into a bag. H is a starting size, not a promise that your loops and the designer’s loops will match.
Work the pattern stitch in the actual project yarn, with enough width to count four inches away from the edges. Finish the sample as directed in the pattern and lay it flat without tugging. Count horizontally for stitch gauge and vertically for row gauge. If you are getting 18 where the pattern wants 16, try a larger hook and measure again. Switching between these two H hooks changes the handle, not the nominal diameter. Neither is the logical purchase if what your swatch calls for is a different size.
When the hook goes missing halfway through a blanket
Say the first five squares are finished and your hook vanishes on the train. If the label in the project bag says only “H,” lay the squares flat and record how wide one is, how many rounds it has and what yarn you used. If you have a photo that shows the handle, check whether it was the deep blue Amour or the broad Soft Touch. Replacing the same model removes one variable before you start square six.
If you switch handles, finish one replacement square before committing to a stack. Let it settle the same way as the originals and put it on top of one, matching the centers. If the corners line up but the sides ripple, compare stitch counts along each side; an extra increase is not a hook problem. If the counts match but all four edges fall short, measure gauge again. Stretching every square to meet the next one makes the join do work that should have been settled in the stitches.
A tight starting chain is not always the wrong H
A first row that bows inward can make either hook feel too small. Lay the piece flat and look at where it narrows. If it pinches only at the foundation while the rows above measure correctly, do not replace the hook for the entire piece just yet. Make two short starts with your current hook. For the second, form each chain loop on the full shaft instead of cinching it around the narrowing part just behind the head. See which start lies flat under a few rows of the same stitch.
Watch your grip while doing that. If returning your thumb to a broad face makes it easier to repeat the motion, that is a concrete reason to favor the Soft Touch. If you shift backward on the handle to make the chain and forward again for the body, the continuous grip on the Amour is more relevant. A change in where the working loop rests can matter even when the number on the handle never changes.
Choose for the outside of a lined bag
For a bag with a fabric lining, finish the crocheted panels before cutting the fabric. Measure the actual panel rather than the dimensions promised on the pattern. A small gauge difference multiplied over a whole panel can leave a lining too wide or too narrow. Keep the crochet choice separate: the right hook is whichever lets you reproduce the panel with the intended fabric and dimensions. A sewing machine cannot make two crocheted sides of different widths match.
If the lining is the part you plan to repeat across several bags, the Brother sewing machine comparison below addresses that separate purchase. If all you need is a pair of everyday scissors for cutting paper lining templates, the Scotch and Westcott comparison covers that smaller job. Neither purchase is necessary to choose between the two hooks; a scrap of your project yarn supplies better evidence about the decision at hand.
Buy the exact replacement, or keep what works
Clover sells several sizes in each family. For the single Amour here, match 1047/H and 5.0 mm; the U.S. Amazon listing identifies the color as deep blue. For the Soft Touch, match 1008/H and 5.0 mm. Look at the selected size and count, not just a photograph of the family arranged in a row. One H is enough to learn whether you like the handle, but it cannot tell you what diameter the next pattern will require.
For a gift, ask which hook the recipient keeps moving from project bag to project bag. A second copy of that exact model makes sense if two projects already use it. Someone who has not yet found a favorite is a better candidate for a different grip. And if the hook on your table already fits your hand and gives you the fabric you want, there is no stitch this comparison requires you to buy a second H to make.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on October 31, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Clover USA: Amour H, 5.0 mm, article 1047/H, aluminum and elastomer
- Clover: Amour 5.0 mm and the curved grip with nonslip material around the handle
- Clover USA: Soft Touch H, 5 mm, article 1008/H, aluminum and ABS resin
- Clover: Soft Touch handle width, soft grip area, size marking and rounded tip
- Craft Yarn Council: hook sizing, gauge and choosing the direction of a size change
- Craft Yarn Council crochet instructor handbook: measuring stitch and row gauge inside the swatch edges
- Yarnspirations: pencil and knife holds and the parts of a crochet stitch
- Amazon U.S.: one deep blue Amour 1047/H, size H, 5.0 mm, ASIN B008J140RQ Paid link
- Amazon U.S.: one Soft Touch 1008/H, size H, 5.0 mm, ASIN B000QHF90I Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.