Music & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 3, 2026
D’Addario EJ16 vs EJ11: Which Light Acoustic Strings?
If you like the feel of light acoustic strings but want a different sound, the EJ16 and EJ11 let you keep all six diameters the same. Try the EJ16 for the warmer balance D’Addario associates with phosphor bronze. Try the EJ11 if you want more of the crisp edge it describes for 80/20 bronze. The useful surprise: the two thinnest strings are the very same parts in both sets. What you play on the other four should guide the purchase.
Best for
Someone restringing a six-string steel-string acoustic that suits light 12 to 53 strings, especially a player choosing between two alloys without changing gauge.
Probably not for
A classical guitar built for nylon, a twelve-string guitar needing all twelve strings, or a player specifically seeking a coated set or a lighter high E.
Specifications at a glance
| What is in one set | EJ16 Phosphor Bronze | EJ11 80/20 Bronze |
|---|---|---|
| Instrument and quantity | Six-string steel-string acoustic; one set | Six-string steel-string acoustic; one set |
| Plain high E and B, inches | .012, .016 (PL012, PL016) | .012, .016 (PL012, PL016) |
| Wound G, D, A and low E, inches | .024, .032, .042, .053 | .024, .032, .042, .053 |
| Wrap on the four wound strings | Phosphor bronze | 80/20 bronze |
| Construction of wound strings | Round wound on hexagonal high-carbon steel | Round wound on hexagonal high-carbon steel |
| String coating | None | None |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
D’Addario EJ16 Phosphor Bronze Light, 12 to 53, one six-string set
The phosphor bronze winding is the reason to buy the EJ16. Consider it for an accompaniment that spans a thumbed bass line and ringing middle strings: if you want those notes to sit underneath the words rather than announce each pick stroke, warmth is a useful direction to explore. It is a preference, not a promise about how loud your guitar will sound.
Pros
- Lets you try a warmer tonal direction without stepping up in diameter
- Matches the EJ11 plain strings if you already like how the top two play
Cons
- Not the obvious change if your current phosphor bronze set already sounds too subdued
- No coating for someone who specifically wants coated strings
Who it’s for: Pick this set if you know you like the sound of fresh phosphor bronze, or want to compare it against the sharper edge of a familiar 80/20 set. If you want a thinner string for bending the high E, the EJ16 does not offer one.
Check D’Addario EJ16 Phosphor Bronze Light, 12 to 53, one six-string set on Amazon Paid linkD’Addario EJ11 80/20 Bronze Light, 12 to 53, one six-string set
The EJ11 changes the wrap on the G string down through the bass E. D’Addario describes this alloy as bright and crisp. If a picked bass run between chords gets lost to your ear and you want a more distinct start to each note, this is the direction to try first. It is still a light, uncoated set, not a heavier string disguised by a different name.
Pros
- Offers a brighter alternative for picked bass and chord accents
- A single set lets you try the alloy without committing to a multipack
Cons
- A crisp attack may be precisely what you dislike on a bright-sounding guitar
- Switching to this set does not change the high E or B specification
Who it’s for: Choose EJ11 when the change you want is on the wound strings, especially if a fresh set of your usual strings still sounds too mellow. Skip it if you are trying to take the edge off sharp pick attacks.
Check D’Addario EJ11 80/20 Bronze Light, 12 to 53, one six-string set on Amazon Paid linkRead the old envelope before choosing the new one
Look for three things on the packet you last installed: the instrument, the gauge and the model code. A six-string acoustic designed for steel is the starting point, not just a guitar with a sound hole. Do not fit either set to a nylon-string classical guitar. If the instrument is borrowed or inherited and you cannot identify it, check the model with its maker before pulling off the existing strings.
Next, read beyond the word light. The numbers describe the string diameters in thousandths of an inch. A set that starts at .012 and ends at .053 is what both of these packets contain; the four diameters in between also agree. If your usual high E is .010, buying either of these is a gauge change as well as a possible material change. Check the gauge range recommended for your particular guitar before treating the switch as a simple swap.
Finally, distinguish a duplicate from an experiment. If your saved envelope says EJ16 and you loved how it sounded when you put it on, there is nothing wrong with ordering the same set. If it says EJ16 but even the new strings sounded too round for your alternating bass part, EJ11 is an experiment with a clear purpose. If you cannot remember the sound of the old set when new, write down the code this time.
Choose a phrase that actually uses the changed strings
A melody confined to the open B and high E tells you surprisingly little about this choice. D’Addario lists PL016 for the B and PL012 for the high E in both packets. If those are the only strings you pluck, you have not asked the different wrap wires to do anything. To bring the wound G into the picture, play the open B, then play the same note at the fourth fret of the G. Keep that pair of notes in the phrase when you next change strings.
For an accompaniment, try a verse you know well. On a G chord, play the bass note on the sixth string, pick the inner notes, then strum the whole chord. Listen for the moment when the bass gives way to the other notes. Do you want a clearer boundary between them, or do you like hearing the notes blend beneath your voice? That is a more useful question than deciding whether one packet suits all strummers and the other suits all fingerpickers.
Keep the pick, pitch and recording position the same
You need not restring twice in one sitting. Save a short recording of the familiar part early in the life of your present set. When that set needs replacing, record the same part with the new one at a similar stage. Use the same guitar, the same tuning and the same pick or picking fingers. In particular, do not move from a flexible pick to a stiff one at the same time; the Dunlop Tortex pick gauge comparison explains why changing that one detail can alter the stroke.
Set the phone on the same shelf facing the same part of the guitar. If the part is normally played with a capo, note the fret. Check tuning both times; the D’Addario clip-on tuner guide compares two ways to see the pitch at the headstock. Listening back is for deciding which take you like, not measuring one alloy against the other. A recording of yesterday’s worn strings against today’s fresh ones cannot separate age from material.
When a replacement string makes more sense than a set
Suppose a nearly new high E breaks and the rest of the set sounds exactly as you want. Both manufacturer charts identify that string as PL012. A matching plain single addresses the break without spending a second set to find out which bronze you prefer. The same reasoning works for a PL016 B. It stops at the G: the two .024 strings carry different part codes, PB024 and BW024. To preserve the set you like, match the prefix as well as the number.
If your real problem is that a set feels difficult to fret, do not buy the other alloy on the assumption that its packet says light and therefore means lighter. The diameters match, although the maker’s tension charts for the wound strings are not identical. Note which string and fret give you trouble and ask a repairer about the setup or an appropriate gauge. Save the choice between EJ16 and EJ11 for the question these two sets actually answer: which wound-string voice do you want to hear from this guitar?
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 3, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- D’Addario: EJ16 single set, wrap, construction, coating and individual string chart
- D’Addario: EJ11 single set, wrap, construction, coating and individual string chart
- D’Addario: tonal descriptions of the two acoustic wrap alloys
- Martin Guitar: recommended string gauges and warning against steel strings on classical guitars
- Amazon US: EJ16 Light, 12 to 53, one pack Paid link
- Amazon US: EJ11 Light, 12 to 53, one pack Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.