Music & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 6, 2026
Ernie Ball Polypro vs PolyLock: Which Guitar Strap Fits?
Choose the black Polypro P04037 for conventional leather ends and the longer maximum length specified by Ernie Ball. Choose the black PolyLock P04056 when you want a locking attachment on compatible existing electric-guitar or bass buttons. Both use two-inch polypropylene webbing. The useful question is not which strap looks more professional: it is whether the ends and adjustment range work with your actual instrument and playing position.
Best for
A guitarist or bassist choosing between a conventional strap and an integrated locking design without replacing compatible instrument buttons.
Probably not for
Someone shopping for a padded shoulder section, a headstock-tie acoustic strap, or a guaranteed fit for every button shape and mounting position.
Specifications at a glance
| Exact-model detail | Polypro P04037 | PolyLock P04056 |
|---|---|---|
| Selected color | Black with black ends | Black |
| Webbing | Polypropylene | Polypropylene |
| Webbing width | 2 inches | 2 inches |
| Attachment design | Conventional stitched leather ends | Integrated PolyLock ends |
| Current Ernie Ball adjustment range | 41-72 inches | 38-67 inches |
| Main selection question | Do standard ends and the length suit your setup? | Do the locking ends fit both existing buttons? |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Black, P04037
The P04037 is the conventional option: polypropylene webbing, stitched black leather ends and a Delrin adjustment buckle. It makes sense when you already like a standard strap attachment and want to replace it without adopting another mechanism. Its current manufacturer page also specifies a greater maximum length than the P04056. That extra reach matters only if your chosen position needs it.
Pros
- Conventional leather-end attachment keeps the setup familiar
- Manufacturer specifies adjustment up to 72 inches
Cons
- Does not include the PolyLock attachment mechanism
- No padded shoulder section in this selected model
Who it’s for: Consider it for an established standard-button setup, particularly when a long adjustment is important. Skip it if an integrated locking end is the main reason you are replacing your strap.
Check Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Black, P04037 on Amazon Paid linkErnie Ball PolyLock Guitar Strap, Black, P04056
The P04056 puts the locking mechanism at the strap ends. Ernie Ball designs it to connect to compatible existing electric-guitar or bass strap buttons without instrument modification. This is the black polypropylene version, not either padded neoprene PolyLock option. Its shorter specified minimum can be relevant to a player who needs a higher instrument position, provided the attachment fits.
Pros
- Integrated locks avoid a separate replacement-button installation on compatible instruments
- Manufacturer specifies adjustment down to 38 inches
Cons
- Selected Amazon listing warns of possible incompatibility with Danelectro and newer SG-style guitars
- The 67-inch specified maximum may exclude a very long setup
Who it’s for: Consider it when keeping the existing buttons and adding a locking strap are both priorities. Pass if either end cannot engage correctly or your preferred length falls outside its range.
Check Ernie Ball PolyLock Guitar Strap, Black, P04056 on Amazon Paid linkLook at both attachment points before choosing
Start with the guitar, not the strap color. Inspect the button near the tail and the other attachment point near the neck or body. Note where each sits, how much space surrounds it and whether it is an ordinary button or part of an existing lock system. A photograph of both points is useful when asking a shop or the manufacturer about fit. The guitar model name alone may not reveal hardware that a previous owner changed.
PolyLock is attractive when the goal is a locking connection without changing the instrument hardware. That advantage is conditional. The selected listing specifically warns that some Danelectro and newer SG-style guitars may not be compatible. Treat that as a reason to confirm your exact setup, not as a problem to solve by forcing the end over a button. A lock that cannot fully engage is not an acceptable near-fit.
For a guitar that already has another maker's strap-lock buttons, identify that system before ordering either strap. Do not assume that two products described as locking connect to each other. Keeping a working system and choosing a strap compatible with its own fittings may be the simpler route. A conventional leather end is also not a universal compatibility promise; its opening still has to seat properly on the hardware you have.
Measure a useful length, not your height
Your height is an incomplete shortcut because the instrument body, button locations and preferred neck angle all affect where the guitar hangs. If your present strap puts the instrument where you want it, leave its adjuster alone, remove it while supporting the guitar and measure between its attachment points along the strap. Record that as a starting reference. Include the instrument name if you use different settings for guitar and bass.
The current Ernie Ball pages specify 41-72 inches for P04037 and 38-67 inches for P04056. Those ranges overlap substantially; if your reference lies comfortably within both, the attachment design is more important than the endpoints. Near either limit, ask how the seller measures the actual strap before treating the published number as an exact fit guarantee. The selected P04037 Amazon description has also used a 42-inch minimum, so a purchase that depends on precisely 41 inches deserves confirmation.
When trying a strap, support the instrument while adjusting it, then check the result in the clothes you normally wear for rehearsal. Play a familiar chord change, reach the upper frets and return to the first position. You are looking for a usable location for the instrument, not recreating a photograph of another musician. Check the seated position too if lessons or rehearsals involve switching between sitting and standing.
Choose the attachment feature without expecting padding
Both selected straps have two-inch polypropylene webbing. Neither is the neoprene comfort version that appears elsewhere in the PolyLock range. If your shopping brief starts with a wider or cushioned shoulder section, these two models do not answer it. Adding a lock changes how the strap attaches; it does not turn the webbing into a padded strap. Likewise, the plain Polypro is not inferior merely because it omits a feature you do not want.
Consider a bassist who is satisfied with a conventional strap but needs more length. The P04037 is a logical candidate because its maker lists a longer maximum; the PolyLock feature is secondary to that requirement. Now consider a guitarist whose existing buttons are confirmed compatible and who wants to leave those buttons installed. The P04056 addresses that different brief. These are fit-based recommendations, not claims that one strap will feel better or last longer in every rehearsal.
A first standing practice session is also a useful time to settle the small equipment choices you already own. Keep your usual pick while finding the strap position, so a new pick thickness does not distract from the adjustment. If pick feel is a separate unresolved question, the Dunlop Tortex .60 and .88 comparison explains those two thickness options. There is no need to change both accessories in the same session.
Check the connection and the route to rehearsal
Before letting the strap carry the instrument, support the guitar and inspect both ends. With the conventional model, check that the leather is seated around the button as intended. With PolyLock, follow its supplied attachment instructions and verify engagement at each end. Recheck after removing and refitting the strap. Neither design eliminates the need to notice a damaged end, a loose button or hardware that has shifted.
Do the first fit check at home, where you can put the instrument down and ask a question without a rehearsal starting around you. After the position feels workable, play a short sequence from the material you are learning. A regular practice pulse can make it easier to concentrate on the same passage after an adjustment; the Korg MA-2 and Seiko SQ50V metronome guide covers dedicated click devices if you do not already have a suitable source.
Consider the case as well as the playing position. If you leave a strap attached, check that its ends and adjuster do not become trapped between the instrument and the closed lid. If you remove it for transport, plan to inspect the connections when you put it back on rather than attaching it hurriedly while walking into the room. A convenient rehearsal routine is one you can repeat with the actual case and instrument you use.
Keep the version straight at checkout
Use the full identifiers: P04037 is the black standard Polypro here, while P04056 is the black polypropylene PolyLock. Nearby choices include Pickholder, Acoustic and neoprene variants. A shared family picture does not establish the selected model's adjustment range or attachment. For P04056, use the model-specific 38-67-inch specification, which agrees between Ernie Ball and the listing's product description, rather than a generic strap-family graphic.
An acoustic instrument with only a tail attachment needs its own connection plan; neither selected product is the dedicated headstock-tie acoustic strap. For the intended two-button setup, finish with two checks: can both ends attach correctly, and can the strap place the instrument where you need it? Choose P04037 when conventional ends and its length are the useful combination. Choose P04056 when verified button compatibility makes the integrated locks useful. If either check fails, a different strap is a better next step than adapting the instrument to justify this purchase.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 6, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Ernie Ball: exact black P04037, polypropylene width, leather ends, buckle and current 41-72-inch range
- Ernie Ball: exact black P04056, locking attachment, polypropylene width and 38-67-inch range
- Amazon US: Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Black, P04037; listing identity and length wording Paid link
- Amazon US: Ernie Ball PolyLock Guitar Strap, Black, P04056; exact model and Danelectro/SG-style compatibility warning Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.