Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Art & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 2, 2026

Faber-Castell Polychromos vs Albrecht Dürer: Which Tin of 12?

Choose Polychromos if the pencil marks are the finished drawing. Choose Albrecht Dürer if you want to draw a shadow and then pull it across the paper with a damp brush. Faber-Castell lists the same twelve color numbers in these two metal tins. What you gain by switching is a different way to use those colors, not a wider palette.

Best for

A sketchbook artist choosing a first set of twelve, or a colored pencil user deciding whether watercolor pencils would add a technique they will actually use.

Probably not for

Someone looking for a complete painting kit with a brush and paper, or a gift that adds twelve unfamiliar hues to one of these exact sets.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
What comes in the tinPolychromos Artists’ Color PencilsAlbrecht Dürer Artists’ Watercolor Pencils
Faber-Castell itemFC110012FC117512
Contents12 colored pencils, metal tin12 watercolor pencils, metal tin
Core diameter3.8 mm3.8 mm
Response to waterWater-resistantFully water-soluble
Examples from the U.S. contents listsLight Ultramarine 140, Burnt Ochre 187Light Ultramarine 140, Burnt Ochre 187

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Faber-Castell Polychromos Artists’ Color Pencils, 12 in a metal tin (110012)

With Polychromos, the sharpened point can do the whole job: outline the subject, build a shadow and pick out its texture. The water-resistant core makes this the straightforward choice for someone who likes to see the individual strokes on the finished page.

Pros

  • Draw, shade and finish without a brush or drying step
  • A useful fit for hatching and building up layers of dry color

Cons

  • A wet brush is not a way to turn this color into a wash
  • Large shaded areas still need to be filled with pencil strokes

Who it’s for: Pick this tin for a field notebook full of colored diagrams, or for small illustrations you finish entirely in pencil. Pass if the thing you enjoy about watercolor is making an edge disappear into the paper.

Check Faber-Castell Polychromos Artists’ Color Pencils, 12 in a metal tin (110012) on Amazon

Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Artists’ Watercolor Pencils, 12 in a metal tin (117512)

You can leave an Albrecht Dürer mark dry or turn it into paint. The brush does not have to touch the whole drawing. A building can keep its dry pencil windows while a few strokes beneath the eaves become a band of shadow.

Pros

  • Allows dry detail and a brushed wash within one drawing
  • Color can also be picked up from a separate scrap of watercolor paper

Cons

  • Wet work calls for suitable paper and a brush beyond the tin
  • A damp stroke can move an unactivated line you meant to preserve

Who it’s for: Choose this set if the option to paint is part of the project. It is less compelling if all your work happens in a book you cannot get wet and you have no plans to change paper.

Check Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Artists’ Watercolor Pencils, 12 in a metal tin (117512) on Amazon

Draw the same pear two ways

Imagine a pear sitting on a striped tea towel. In a dry Polychromos drawing, you might curl short strokes around the pear to suggest its roundness, then use straight, widely spaced strokes for the woven towel. Build the shadow under the fruit by bringing the strokes closer together. Their direction tells the viewer which surface is curved and which is flat. If that little patch of hatching is your favorite part of the picture, there is no missing brush step.

With Albrecht Dürer, plan where the brush will travel before drawing the stripes. Put color along the bottom edge of the pear, then use a damp brush to carry some toward the middle. Leave paper showing where the light hits the skin. Work on the towel stripes after the nearby wet area dries, or leave a strip of untouched paper between them. That order lets you decide which edges meet instead of trying to separate two wet colors afterward.

If the paper is already chosen, start there

A thin field notebook, a printed coloring book and a pad of watercolor paper present three different buying decisions. In the first two, you may need to keep the back of every page usable, and you may have no spare copy if a printed outline runs. If you cannot spare a page to check what water does, choose Polychromos for a dry project. Water resistance describes the pencil marks, not the printed ink, binding or paper around them.

For a watercolor sketchbook, give yourself a trial patch on the last page. With Albrecht Dürer, draw a narrow band, brush water across just half of it and let the page dry before closing the book. Look at the edge of the band and the reverse of the sheet. If you are shopping for unbound artwork, the Arches cold press versus hot press guide compares two watercolor blocks and helps you decide whether you want the paper texture to show through the drawing.

Twelve colors is not the same as twelve more colors

The two U.S. contents lists match color for color, down to numbers such as 187 for Burnt Ochre and 140 for Light Ultramarine. If a gift recipient owns the Polychromos twelve, the Albrecht Dürer twelve gives them a familiar palette to paint with. If their wish list says they lack a particular violet, look for that color by name and number instead of expecting a second tin to fill the gap.

Make a small reference strip on the paper you normally use. Label it with both the pencil line and the color number, particularly if you own both sets. For dry color, put one light pass beside several overlapping passes. For watercolor pencil, leave some of the mark untouched and use a brush on the rest. The paired samples are more useful than the barrel color when you come back a week later to finish a matching illustration.

A way to paint without drawing a colored outline

Suppose you want a pale sky behind a row of rooftops, with no blue pencil outline around each chimney. Faber-Castell describes using scrap watercolor paper as a palette for Albrecht Dürer. Lay down a patch of blue on the scrap. Pick up a little of the color with a damp brush, try it on a spare corner and carry it onto the sky. You can paint right up to the roof shapes without having to dissolve a dark boundary there.

For a dry Polychromos version of that scene, leave the sky as bare paper and put the color into the buildings. Use short, repeating marks for tiles and longer vertical strokes for siding. That is a different composition, not a pencil substitute for a wash. If you want faint construction lines beneath either version, the GraphGear 1000 versus rOtring 600 guide covers two mechanical pencils for the preliminary layout.

Pack for the session you actually have

For a ten-minute sketch while waiting for a train, will you have somewhere to set a damp page before you leave? A dry pencil tin lets you put down the last mark just before packing up. Albrecht Dürer still makes sense if you plan to draw on location and use water at home. Take a photo or jot down which edges should stay sharp so you know where to stop the brush later.

For a class, read the materials list literally. “Watercolor pencils” points to Albrecht Dürer; “colored pencils, dry media only” makes Polychromos the simpler pick. Check the item number along with the count when selecting a tin: 110012 for dry color, 117512 for watercolor. Both have a 3.8 mm core. That measurement is the width inside the wood, not the width of every line you can draw or the size of a sharpener opening.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 2, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.