Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Sewing & Craft Comparisons · Reviewed November 5, 2026

Fiskars 1/8 vs 1/4 Inch Circle Punches for Gift Tags

A little tag tied to a jar with a single strand of thread calls for a different hole than a luggage-shaped tag hung on a doubled loop of cord. Choose the Fiskars 1/8-inch circle for fine ties and narrow paper borders. Choose the 1/4-inch circle when getting a folded tie through the hole matters more than keeping it inconspicuous. Neither is adjustable. Before deciding, lay the actual tie across the tag in the shape it will have when you thread it.

Best for

Paper crafters making gift tags, favor labels or hang tags who know what cord or ribbon they want to use.

Probably not for

Wide ribbon that needs to lie flat in a slot, deep holes near the middle of a sheet, or batches of three-hole binder pages.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
What changes1/8-inch circle1/4-inch circle
US model number23517097J23527097J
Diameter of opening1/8 inch (3.175 mm)1/4 inch (6.35 mm)
Radius to allow on each side of center1/16 inch1/8 inch
Handle and clippingsCushioned grip; built-in catcherCushioned grip; built-in catcher
Selected packageOne fixed-size circle punchOne fixed-size circle punch

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Fiskars 23517097J 1/8-inch Circle Hand Punch, one punch

On a narrow tag, the smaller punch leaves more of the top intact around the tie. It also makes the hole less conspicuous when you use fine thread: the lettering or little drawing can stay the focus. Its drawback appears when the tie has to pass through as a loop rather than a single end.

Pros

  • Leaves more paper between the opening and a nearby cut edge
  • Makes small, closely spaced dots for paper decoration

Cons

  • A folded cord or frayed tip may not pass even if one strand fits
  • The small circles are fiddlier to pick up for individual placement

Who it’s for: Choose it for a slender tie on a small tag. If you routinely double your cord before threading, judge this size against the folded end first.

Check Fiskars 23517097J 1/8-inch Circle Hand Punch, one punch on Amazon

Fiskars 23527097J 1/4-inch Circle Hand Punch, one punch

Doubling the diameter changes how you can dress a tag. There is more room for a folded cord or a ribbon gathered at the opening, and the cutout is large enough to read as a deliberate polka dot. Both effects take space away from a small design. A quarter inch is the diameter, not a promise that every quarter-inch ribbon will hang the way you want.

Pros

  • More threading room for folded ties or bulky ends
  • Larger punched dots stand out against a contrasting paper backing

Cons

  • The wider cut takes more out of a narrow paper border
  • Fine thread can leave a conspicuous gap around the tie

Who it’s for: Choose it when the tie needs clearance and the tag has room for the hole. Skip it for a ribbon that must sit flat across its full width; a slot suits that job.

Check Fiskars 23527097J 1/4-inch Circle Hand Punch, one punch on Amazon

Thread the tag the way it will actually hang

Start with the knot, not the spool. If you run one free end through the tag and tie it to a package afterward, only that end needs to pass. With a loop attachment, you fold the cord, feed the bend through the hole, then pass the two free ends through the loop. The tight turn at the fold is the part to measure. Two ends of the very same string can lead to different punch choices depending on which attachment you want.

Draw two circles at actual size on scrap card, using a ruler to check their diameters. Lay the folded cord over each outline. If it already hides the entire smaller circle before you include the fuzz or the bend, the larger model is the better bet. If you have a tag with a known-size hole, try threading that instead: a drawing can rule a size out, but it cannot show how a folded ribbon will crease. Include any stiffened tip that has to pass through.

Think about the other end of the tie, too. Suppose you plan to hold a name tag on a cord with one stopper knot. A bigger opening can admit the knot as well as the cord. Tie the actual knot and check it against the outline. If clearance for threading and clearance for the stopper work against each other, change the attachment: a loop around the edge of the tag does not rely on the knot being bigger than the hole.

Leave a bridge of paper above the circle

The pencil dot you mark is the center of the cut. If that dot sits 1/4 inch below a straight top edge, the small punch leaves 3/16 inch of paper above the hole. The large punch leaves 1/8 inch. Those are layout measurements, not strength ratings. Stock, grain, how tightly the tie pulls, and a crease beside the hole can all change what happens to the finished tag. Hang the first sample from the intended tie before committing the rest.

A tag with clipped corners has two more edges to consider. Sketch the full circle, including its sides, before trimming the corners of your pattern. It is easy to leave ample space above the hole and almost none toward a sloping shoulder. If the opening crowds the lettering, moving the first line down may be cleaner than shifting the hole sideways and having the tag hang at an angle.

For a sheet of identical labels, cut one finished blank first. If cutting the blanks square is the slow part, the Dahle 507 vs Vantage 50 rotary trimmer comparison addresses that separate job. Punch the sample, lay it over each blank with the edges flush, and pencil the center through its hole. Remove the sample before punching. A template provides a reference without turning the work into a stack-punching experiment.

Decide whether you want the opening or the dot

For a row of windows along the bottom of a greeting card, the holes are the design and the little pieces left in the catcher are surplus. On dark paper over a pale insert, outline the planned row on scrap first. At the same center-to-center spacing, a 1/4-inch hole leaves less solid paper between neighbors than a 1/8-inch hole. The small punch suits a dotted line; the large one makes more of the backing color visible.

For confetti made from colored offcuts, the pieces in the catcher become the project. A circle twice the diameter has four times the face area, so a handful of quarter-inch dots gives a different effect from the same number of eighth-inch dots. Empty the catcher between colors if you are assembling a pattern. For a single large seal, lettering disk or photograph cutout, look at punches measured in whole inches; neither tool here makes anything that size.

When a different punch makes more sense

A hand punch reaches inward from an edge. Do not take the overall length of the tool as the distance it can reach into a card. For an opening near the middle of a large sheet, choose a punch with a documented reach that covers the position. For binder pages, the problem is lining up several holes repeatedly. The Swingline vs Bostitch three-hole punch comparison covers tools that keep that spacing for you.

For a paper tag, keep the choice tied to the finished object: a fine strand and a narrow border favor 1/8 inch; a doubled cord and a broad shoulder favor 1/4 inch. If the design needs thick chipboard, start with a tool rated for that material instead of assuming a wider hole means heavier cutting capacity. These two sizes let you choose the opening. They do not change what the paper or the attachment can safely carry.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 5, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.