Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Music & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 9, 2026

Forbidden Island vs Forbidden Desert: Which Co-op Fits?

Choose Forbidden Island if your group of two to four wants to look at one map and decide what it can afford to lose. Choose Forbidden Desert for a fifth player, or for friends who enjoy coming up with a new route when the wind moves the one they had planned. These are two complete cooperative games. You do not need Island to play Desert, and you cannot add Desert’s fifth adventurer to a game of Island.

Best for

People who want to win or lose together and enjoy talking through what one person can do to help the next.

Probably not for

A solo buyer following the printed player counts, six players who all need a seat, or a table that wants private objectives and individual scores.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Buying questionForbidden IslandForbidden Desert
Gamewright stock number317415
Players2 to 42 to 5
Publisher playtime30 minutes45 minutes
Actions available on a turnUp to 3, then draw Treasure and Flood cardsUp to 4, then draw Storm cards
How the map changesFlooded tiles can sink and leave permanent gapsTiles slide into the storm space and accumulate sand
What the group needs to escapeFour treasures, everyone at Fools’ Landing, and a Helicopter Lift cardFour machine parts and everyone on an unblocked Launch Pad

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Gamewright Forbidden Island, first edition board game, #317

Adventurers pool matching treasure cards and keep key parts of their island above water long enough to leave by helicopter.

Pros

  • Face-up hands make it easy for a new player to spot who needs a card
  • Flooded and missing tiles show the stakes without personal resource meters

Cons

  • Stops at four even though the box contains six possible roles
  • A lost landing site ends the trip regardless of how many treasures you saved

Who it’s for: A small group teaching its first cooperative game, or a host who wants a shorter expedition with a visible objective.

Check Gamewright Forbidden Island, first edition board game, #317 on Amazon

Gamewright Forbidden Desert: Thirst for Survival, board game #415

Work out where four machine parts are buried, keep each adventurer supplied with water and collect the team at the launch site.

Pros

  • Accommodates five without anyone sharing a role
  • Part-location clues give players a reason to study the changing map together

Cons

  • Tracking each canteen adds another job during the storm phase
  • Finding both clues to a part does not guarantee a clear path to collect it

Who it’s for: A family of five or a regular game group that wants the puzzle to keep changing after it has found a promising route.

Check Gamewright Forbidden Desert: Thirst for Survival, board game #415 on Amazon

The difference you can explain before opening either box

On the island, the helicopter leaves from one place. Find Fools’ Landing among the tiles and show it to everyone. If the team lets that one tile disappear, it no longer matters that somebody is holding a perfect set of treasure cards. Now point to the two places where the team can claim a particular treasure. Losing one hurts; losing both before claiming that treasure ends the game. A newcomer can already offer a useful opinion about which bit of ground is worth saving.

The desert poses a different question: where is the thing you came to get? A clue can tell you the row for a machine part, but you still need its partner to locate the column. Until the second clue turns up, the first tile can blow into a different position. If your family likes to point to a goal at the start and work backward, the island gives you several such goals. If the discovery itself is what you want to play through, that half-known map is a reason to get Desert.

Both games let the people around the table advise the person taking a turn. A player who likes puzzle solving but dislikes negotiating a move may prefer the Rush Hour and Rush Hour Junior comparison. Those sliding-vehicle challenges can be handed to one person to solve. Here, even a beautifully planned turn can depend on someone else being willing to spend their next move on a rescue.

An island turn: which card needs to travel?

Suppose one player has three cards showing the same treasure and a partner has the fourth. Lay those hands where both players can see them. Under the ordinary rules the partner must meet the collector on a tile and spend an action to give the card. The collector cannot walk up and take it. Look at who plays next before moving: ending beside the partner who can give now is different from ending beside one who just finished a turn. The Messenger role changes the meeting requirement.

There is another wrinkle if the collector already holds five cards. Receiving a sixth means letting something go, even if there is a good plan for every card. That matters particularly when one of them is the helicopter you need at the end. Four matching cards still have to reach one of the two corresponding locations, and the collector must have an action left to exchange them for the treasure. For a group that likes working out handoffs out loud, those three actions per turn can make a lively little puzzle.

When a flood card comes up, turn a dry tile to its flooded side or remove the tile if it was already flooded. A flooded tile is still usable. For example, someone standing at a flooded treasure site can claim the treasure before worrying about drying it out. Ask whether anyone will need to walk there again once that treasure is safe. Sometimes a useful turn ends with a wet tile left exactly as it was and a player one step closer to the helicopter.

A desert turn: can you get there and get back?

Imagine uncovering the second clue for a propeller and setting the part on its tile. The group now knows where it is; it does not yet own it. Count from the nearest pawn. Does sand block the approach? Has anyone excavated the destination? Picking up the part is an action of its own. Once placed, the propeller travels with its tile in the wind, so following the two arrows again next turn can give you the wrong destination. Follow the propeller instead.

Two sand markers ordinarily block a tile; one lets a pawn through but still covers the surface you wanted to excavate. If a teammate can clear just one marker from the next player’s path, that may be enough to let them cross to shelter. Clearing that same tile for a dig takes more work. It helps to say whether you want a road or a dig site. Otherwise two players can agree that the route is clear and have quite different ideas about what the next person can do.

Water is personal even though defeat is shared. Consider a player beside a possible well with room in their canteen and a thirsty teammate one move away. Dig now and only the people on the tile get the water if it is a well. Wait and both might benefit, but the weather gets a turn before everyone arrives. One of the three water symbols hides a mirage. A group that likes an uneasy decision with no guarantee may enjoy that more than handing over a card that everyone can see.

Make room for the storm, or make room for the cards

For Desert, clear a square patch of table big enough for five tiles across and five down. The empty place in the middle is intentional, not a missing piece. Put the storm deck at the edge everyone has agreed is north. When a card sends tiles one way, two players looking from opposite seats can easily interpret left differently. Have one person hold the card in its proper orientation while another slides the affected tiles and moves the pieces riding on them.

Island also has 24 tiles, but the spare space you need is different. Each person wants a spot for a visible hand, and the host needs room for separate Treasure and Flood discards. Do not toss those discards into a single pile as you clear the table between turns. When the water rises, previously drawn Flood cards go back on top of the Flood deck. A tile you have just seen flood can therefore be in danger again soon, right when someone had planned to cross it.

Who has a seat, and who gets to make the decision?

Count actual players before picking a theme. Three people can take distinct roles in either box. Five need Desert; the spare roles in Island are for variety, not extra seats. Gamewright gives Island half an hour and Desert three quarters of an hour. Leave time for explaining the first map as well. For a gift where age labeling matters, note that Gamewright lists Island for ages ten and up but the linked Amazon first-edition title says fourteen and up. Check the marking on the exact copy you intend to give.

For mixed-experience players, try letting the active adventurer name a goal before anyone offers a plan. “I want to get you some water” is an invitation for a teammate to help find a route; having the route dictated before touching a pawn is a different evening. If your group wants everyone choosing privately at the same time, the Sushi Go! and Sushi Go Party! comparison covers two alternatives. If a shared problem is the appeal, pick Island to decide which ground to save, or Desert to find a way through a map that will not sit still.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 9, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.