Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Kitchen Comparisons · Reviewed November 13, 2026

Fox Run Madeleine Pans: 12 Standard vs 20 Mini Shells

Choose the Fox Run 44925 for a recognizable individual tea cake, especially if your recipe calls for a standard madeleine pan. Choose the 44933 for a bite-size shell to put beside an espresso or add to a dessert assortment. The mini fits eight more cakes on a narrower tray; it does not make eight more servings of the same size.

Best for

Bakers choosing between a standard madeleine and a miniature shell for tea service, gift boxes or a dessert assortment.

Probably not for

Crisp hollow shells to fill with cream, a deep muffin cup or bakers looking for uncoated metal.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
At the baking counterFox Run 44925Fox Run 44933
Shells on one pan12 standard20 mini
Outside length × width15.5 × 7.5 inches15.5 × 4.75 inches
Outside height1 inch0.5 inch
Pan constructionCarbon steel with nonstick coatingCarbon steel with nonstick coating
For 24 individual cakesTwo loads of 12 standard cakesOne load of 20 minis, then four more
Choose forA single cake to dip or serve with teaSmall portions alongside other desserts

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Fox Run 44925 Non-Stick Madeleine Pan, 12 cups

A nonstick carbon-steel pan with a dozen standard shell-shaped wells. The broader of these two pans is 7.5 inches wide.

Pros

  • Standard wells match recipes written for a regular madeleine pan
  • One full pan makes an exact dozen for a box or tea table

Cons

  • Needs more shelf width than the mini
  • A second load is needed for a sixteenth guest to get a cake

Who it’s for: Pick the 44925 when the madeleine is the pastry on the plate, not an accent beside it.

Check Fox Run 44925 Non-Stick Madeleine Pan, 12 cups on Amazon

Fox Run 44933 Non-Stick Mini Madeleine Pan, 20 cups

A slim carbon-steel tray with 20 miniature shell impressions. The extra eight wells are useful when you want one small cake per guest, not larger servings.

Pros

  • Twenty individual bites for a tasting tray from a full pan
  • Fits a narrower storage slot than the 12-cup model

Cons

  • Twenty wells to portion and empty for one full batch
  • Still needs the same 15.5 inches of length as the standard version

Who it’s for: Pick the 44933 when one or two small shells per person fit the rest of the menu.

Check Fox Run 44933 Non-Stick Mini Madeleine Pan, 20 cups on Amazon

What goes on the saucer?

Picture a tea service for six. You can put two standard madeleines on each plate from one full 44925. There is room on each cake for someone to hold the narrow end, dip the other end in tea and still have a second bite. Swap the teacup for a little espresso cup on a saucer already occupied by a spoon, and a different portion makes sense. The 44933 makes bite-size shells that leave room for a second kind of dessert. If you usually serve just one cake beside the cup, decide whether that small portion is really what you want before choosing the pan with more wells.

A gift box makes the same choice visible. If four madeleines are the whole gift, standard cakes can be the centerpiece. If the box already contains truffles and shortbread, little shells give you another shape without asking the recipient to commit to a full pastry. Lay out the actual box and paper dividers first. The dimensions of the mini mold describe the impression, not an allowance for the dome of the cake, a layer of chocolate or the tissue between rows. Neither pan makes a hollow shell: the grooves are a design on the cake, not a pocket for filling.

Count pieces before you count oven loads

For a book club of sixteen, one madeleine each calls for two loads in the standard pan or one in the mini, provided you have enough batter for the portion you choose. A meeting of twenty-four is less obvious. The 12-cup pan can deliver two full dozens in two loads. The 20-cup mini also needs two loads: twenty in the first and four in the second. If the reason for buying the mini was to avoid the second trip to the oven, it buys you nothing on that guest list. It still makes sense if you want the small cake itself.

Now change the invitation to two little cakes apiece for ten people. One full mini pan supplies all ten plates. The same pan does not automatically stretch one standard-pan recipe to twenty people. Pieces per tray, servings per person and the amount of batter in the bowl are three separate numbers. For an event where the recipe is new, note how much batter a partial row takes, then check whether the bowl will actually fill the remaining wells. Keep the count by flavor if guests are promised a choice; twenty lemon cakes are not a substitute for ten lemon and ten vanilla.

A standard recipe does not set the timer for a mini

Read the pan named in the recipe before getting out a scoop. King Arthur Baking’s vanilla madeleines call for a slightly rounded tablespoon of batter in each well of a standard pan. That makes the 44925 the direct match for that particular instruction. The measurement is a recipe portion, not a Fox Run specification for the volume of every shell. In the 44933, the smaller hollows leave less room for a portion to spread. A ridge of batter bridging two cups will bake onto the flat metal between them, where there is no shell pattern.

If your favorite recipe only gives directions for standard cakes, a mini-specific recipe is the simpler starting point for the 44933. Otherwise, put a small trial row in before committing a bowl of batter. Record the portion and start checking before the time specified for the larger cake. For the King Arthur recipe, the visual cue is a lightly browned edge. Use the directions for the batter you actually made; changing from chocolate batter to plain changes how easy it is to see that cue. Do not turn the ratio of twelve wells to twenty into a ratio of baking times. It says nothing about the thickness of batter in either pan.

A teaspoon and a second spoon to push the batter off it will do for a few samples. If you prefer to pipe many small portions, the reusable and disposable piping bag comparison is useful for deciding whether washing a bag makes sense for your run. A decorating tip is not what makes the ridges; the metal well does that.

Mini saves width, not length

Here is the surprise when putting these away: both pans are fifteen and a half inches long. The mini comes in at four and three quarters inches across, against seven and a half for the regular. A six-inch-wide shelf slot can take the mini lying flat, assuming it is long enough, but not the regular. A shallow cupboard with only fourteen inches of usable depth will not take either pan straight in lengthwise. Try a rectangle of scrap cardboard in the drawer and shut it with your other bakeware still in place. A protruding handle on a neighboring pan can take up the space you thought you had.

Check the oven separately if it is a countertop model. The door has to close and the pan has to rest level on the actual rack, with the clearances the oven maker specifies. A pan that can be turned diagonally in an empty oven may not be practical to lift out level while wearing mitts. For planning two pans side by side, two minis alone span nine and a half inches of width; two standard pans span fifteen inches, before any clearance is allowed. Do not count on either arrangement merely because the oven is advertised to take a particular size of pizza.

Allow room for the cakes after baking

For chocolate-dipped gifts, the bottleneck can be the space where dipped cakes set. Put the cooling rack over a piece of parchment before you start dipping. Give each piece its own patch of rack so a neighbor does not pull away its coating when you lift it. The standard cake gives you more to hold by the dry end; a short dip on the mini leaves more of its small shell visible. For a kitchen where another batch needs the counter as well, the single and stackable cooling rack comparison explains the space tradeoff. Reserve room above any fresh coating.

A first madeleine pan should solve the problem that comes up on your own table. For a dozen cakes from a familiar standard recipe, choose the 44925; there is no portion conversion to work out before guests arrive. For a mixed dessert plate where the lemon cake should be a bite between other flavors, choose the 44933 and portion for its smaller wells. If the recipe specifies uncoated bakeware or if what you really want is a deep cup to hold curd, put both back. Changing the number of wells will not change either the coating or the shallow shell they leave on the cake.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 13, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.