School & Office Comparisons · Reviewed November 1, 2026
LAMY Safari vs AL-star: Which Fine-Nib Fountain Pen?
Choose the 16 g Safari umbra for a lighter pen with a matte plastic body. Choose the 24 g AL-star graphite for an anodized aluminum body and a transparent grip. Both of these selections have a fine steel nib and take the same LAMY ink cartridges. The AL-star changes what you hold, not which ink system you have to buy.
Best for
A notebook writer choosing between two single LAMY fountain pens, or a Safari owner deciding whether the AL-star offers a meaningful second pen.
Probably not for
Someone seeking a retractable point, an unshaped round grip, a broad-edged calligraphy nib or a pen guaranteed to suit a particular form or paper.
Specifications at a glance
| Matched fine-nib pens | Safari umbra | AL-star graphite |
|---|---|---|
| LAMY item number | 4000202 | 4000300 |
| U.S. listing model | L17F | L26F |
| Nib grade and material | F, steel | F, steel |
| Body and grip | Matte ASA plastic body, shaped grip | Anodized aluminum body, transparent shaped plastic grip |
| Manufacturer-listed weight | 16 g | 24 g |
| Maker dimensions, W x H x L | 12 x 12 x 144 mm | 13 x 13 x 139 mm |
| Ink options | LAMY T 10 cartridge or optional Z 28 converter | LAMY T 10 cartridge or optional Z 28 converter |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
LAMY safari umbra L17F, fine steel nib, one fountain pen
The umbra Safari has a matte plastic body with flattened sides and a window for checking the ink supply. It is the longer of these two pens by the maker’s overall dimensions, despite being the lighter one. If you carry it in a short zip case, check the length as well as the weight.
Pros
- Lower listed weight for a light writing kit
- Ink window lets you check the supply before leaving your desk
Cons
- Not the aluminum barrel or visible ink duct of the AL-star
- Shaped finger rests may not line up with a habitual rotated grip
Who it’s for: Choose the Safari if you already like a light pen and intend to keep this one in an everyday notebook kit. Pass if the reason you are looking at LAMY in the first place is to have a metal barrel.
Check LAMY safari umbra L17F, fine steel nib, one fountain pen on Amazon Paid linkLAMY AL-star graphite L26F, fine steel nib, one fountain pen
The graphite AL-star uses metal for the body but not for the section you pinch. Its transparent plastic grip gives a view of the ink duct. That distinction matters if you are picturing a cool metal surface directly under your fingertips: this is not that design.
Pros
- Aluminum body with a transparent section for seeing the feed
- A Safari user can retain the same cartridge or converter type
Cons
- Adds 8 g compared with this Safari
- The change of body does not give you a different nib grade
Who it’s for: Pick the AL-star when you want a more substantial pen body but still want LAMY’s shaped grip and familiar filling options. Skip it as a second purchase if the only change you want is a broader line.
Check LAMY AL-star graphite L26F, fine steel nib, one fountain pen on Amazon Paid linkStart with what your fingers actually touch
Take the pen you most often reach for and write a grocery list. Before putting it down, look at the position of your thumb and index finger. Are they opposite each other? Is one finger much farther forward? Both LAMYs have a shaped grip, so if you can try one in a shop, write a few familiar words without arranging your hand specially for the demonstration. The useful question is whether the nib faces the page naturally in your usual hold.
Now separate the barrel decision from the grip decision. The AL-star puts aluminum behind the grip; a visible ink duct sits beneath transparent plastic in front of it. Buy that combination if you like it. If your hand wants a smooth round cylinder instead of finger guides, moving from the Safari to the AL-star does not remove the guides. Neither finish is a substitute for finding a grip shape that fits.
A pen for the notebook loop or a pen for the desk?
Imagine taking meeting notes with the notebook resting on your knee. You want to be able to retrieve the pen, manage the cap and put both away before standing up. Measure the inside of your case or loop rather than the outside of your notebook. The Safari is listed at 144 mm long; the AL-star is 139 mm. In a shallow pen compartment the extra five millimeters can matter more than the fact that the Safari is made of plastic.
Width can reverse that choice: LAMY lists 12 mm for the Safari and 13 mm for the AL-star. A rigid loop with a clip pressing against it does not behave like a stretchy sleeve, so do not take those widths as a fit guarantee. At a desk with a wide pen tray, the measurements may be irrelevant. There, consider whether you prefer to leave the cap beside your notebook or put it on the back of the pen. Compare both pens the same way if you try them.
What a matched F nib settles, and what it does not
These are both F nibs. That narrows the decision more than a comparison between a medium Safari and an extra-fine AL-star would. It does not turn F into a guaranteed line width on your notebook. A fine fountain-pen nib is not a fixed-diameter drafting lead. If the job is filling the little squares of a weekly planner, take a spare page of that planner when trying a pen, rather than judging solely from a large signature on a sample card.
Write the smallest digits you use, then close the loops on a few lowercase letters. Check whether you can still tell an eight from a six at your ordinary writing size. This is a useful personal page check, not a reason to predict one of these bodies will give sharper letters. For layouts that must be revised by erasing, the existing GraphGear 1000 versus rOtring 600 comparison covers two mechanical pencils. Changing from plastic to aluminum does not make ink erasable like graphite.
Pick a refill routine separately from the barrel
For a backpack, a spare T 10 cartridge is a simple plan. You can carry the same spare with either pen instead of maintaining two refill lists. Before a lecture, check whether you have enough ink to get through the session and put the spare somewhere reachable. If you have no interest in bottled ink, you do not need a converter just to start using cartridges.
For a home desk, the Z 28 is the optional route to bottled fountain-pen ink. A converter takes the place of a cartridge; it is not an extra reservoir to install alongside one. LAMY recommends rinsing a pen before moving to a new ink color. Consider when you will actually do that. Two pens kept in two distinct colors may serve a teacher better than repeatedly emptying one pen between lesson notes and corrections. Decide whether you need a second color in use before deciding you need a second barrel.
Match the listing to the job you picked
Look for umbra and Fine Nib on the Safari listing, or graphite and L26F on the AL-star listing. The finish describes the body, not the color of your writing. LAMY specifies blue T 10 ink in its standard configurations; the AL-star retailer listing has a different ink-color field. If a particular color is required for a class or form, confirm the contents or plan a compatible refill rather than depending on that field.
One last practical alternative: if your notebook stays on a crowded counter and the pen needs to open with a click for every short entry, you may be shopping for a different writing instrument. The linked Pilot G2 versus uni-ball 207+ guide compares two gel pens for that routine. For a capped fountain pen, settle the nib and grip first. Once those work for you, choose the Safari for less weight or the AL-star for its metal barrel and transparent front section.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 1, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- LAMY USA: Safari umbra F, item 4000202, body, dimensions, weight and ink system
- LAMY USA: AL-star graphite F, item 4000300, grip, finish, dimensions and weight
- LAMY: cartridge and converter use and rinsing when changing ink colors
- Amazon U.S.: Safari L17F, selected umbra fine-nib fountain pen Paid link
- Amazon U.S.: AL-star L26F, selected graphite fine-nib fountain pen Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.