Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Music & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 6, 2026

LP150 vs LP170 Cyclops Tambourines: Steel or Brass?

Choose the black LP150 when you want the nickel-plated steel version of the Cyclops handheld tambourine. Choose the black LP170 when brass is the sound you want to explore in the same product family. Latin Percussion describes the steel voice as loud and cutting, and the brass voice as warm and cutting. Those descriptions suggest different tonal directions, not a promise that brass will be quieter or that either instrument will suit every song.

Best for

A singer or percussionist choosing a handheld tambourine by jingle material and its intended role in a rehearsal, performance or recording.

Probably not for

A player who needs a rod-mounted tambourine, wants both hands continuously available for another instrument, or expects a quieter instrument simply because its jingles are brass.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Exact-model detailLP150 CyclopsLP170 Cyclops
Selected versionBlack, handheldBlack, handheld
JinglesNickel-plated steelBrass
Manufacturer tonal descriptionLoud and cuttingWarm and cutting
HandleTextured Ultra-Comfort handleTextured Ultra-Comfort handle
Jingle retentionPatented pinning systemPatented pinning system
Dimensions, as listed by LP2.6 x 10 x 7.5 inches2.2 x 10 x 8 inches

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Latin Percussion LP150 Cyclops, Steel Jingles, Black, Handheld

The LP150 is the black steel-jingle option. Its useful distinction here is the nickel-plated steel, not a different playing format: you still hold the instrument by its textured handle. It is a sensible starting point for someone specifically replacing a steel Cyclops or following an arrangement that calls for that familiar choice. It does not become the default winner just because the manufacturer emphasizes projection in the description.

Pros

  • An exact steel-jingle choice for an existing Cyclops-based setup
  • Textured handle and pinned jingles are included without switching to the brass version

Cons

  • Does not provide the brass-jingle option that motivates choosing LP170
  • The handheld format occupies a hand during playing

Who it’s for: Consider LP150 when steel is an intentional part of the brief. Skip it when you specifically want brass or need a permanently mounted percussion accessory.

Check Latin Percussion LP150 Cyclops, Steel Jingles, Black, Handheld on Amazon

Latin Percussion LP170 Cyclops, Brass Jingles, Black, Handheld

The LP170 substitutes brass jingles while retaining a handheld Cyclops format and textured grip. It is worth considering when the purpose of the purchase is a different jingle color rather than more controls or mounting hardware. The manufacturer describes this brass voice as warm but still cutting. Treat it as a tonal alternative, not an automatic solution for a rehearsal that is already too loud.

Pros

  • Brass jingles offer a clearly identified alternative to the steel model
  • Keeps the handheld format for a player who wants to choose tone without changing the whole setup

Cons

  • Brass material alone does not establish a lower playing volume
  • Not the dimpled-brass variant or a mounted Cyclops model

Who it’s for: Consider LP170 when a brass tambourine is a deliberate addition to your musical palette. Pass if your main requirement is hands-free playing or an exact replacement for LP150.

Check Latin Percussion LP170 Cyclops, Brass Jingles, Black, Handheld on Amazon

Decide what the tambourine will do in the song

A useful shopping brief is more specific than wanting a good tambourine. Write down one song and the moment when percussion should enter. Perhaps the chorus needs a new layer while the verse stays sparse. Perhaps a small acoustic group needs occasional accents from a singer who is not playing guitar. In either case, identify the job before choosing a material. You are buying a sound to arrange around, not a guarantee that every measure will benefit from another instrument.

For a chorus-only part, decide who will pick the tambourine up, who gives the entrance cue and where it goes after the final accent. For a continuous part, think about whether that person can concentrate on the rhythm while also singing or reading music. These questions apply equally to LP150 and LP170. A change from steel to brass will not resolve a part that is awkwardly assigned or a transition nobody has rehearsed.

If you already own a tambourine, name the specific reason for replacing or supplementing it. A damaged instrument, a preference for another jingle material and a need for mounted playing are three different reasons. Only the first two potentially lead to this handheld pair. If your present instrument already covers the part satisfactorily, trying a simpler arrangement may be more useful than buying a second tambourine because its description sounds more professional.

Read steel and brass as tonal choices, not a volume dial

LP gives both models a cutting tonal description, with warmth specifically associated with the brass version. That is useful vocabulary for deciding what to listen for, but it is not a measured comparison of output, decay or frequency response. There is no basis here for assigning a decibel advantage, claiming that one records more cleanly, or saying that one always blends better with a voice. Those conclusions depend on the actual part and setting.

When listening to demonstrations, first confirm the model shown. A black frame does not distinguish LP150 from LP170. Prefer a demonstration that identifies the jingle material and lets you hear more than a single dramatic accent. Listen for whether the sound you like appears during an ordinary repeating pattern as well as isolated shakes. A strongly processed performance clip can be inspiring without being a reliable guide to how the instrument will sound beside an unamplified singer.

Avoid comparing two clips at very different playback levels and declaring the louder one more detailed. Keep the listening setup consistent and consider the surrounding instruments, if any. This is a way to clarify your preference, not a substitute for hearing the exact instrument in your own room. If a teacher, bandleader or recording collaborator has a specific sound in mind, ask for the model or a reference before interpreting warm, bright or cutting on their behalf.

The shared handle deserves its own fit check

Both official pages specify a textured Ultra-Comfort handle and the same type of jingle-pinning feature. Those shared features are not reasons to favor one model over the other. More importantly, the handle name does not tell you how it will feel in your hand. If possible, hold the instrument in the position you would actually use while singing or playing. Notice whether you can maintain that position without constantly adjusting where your fingers sit.

The published dimensions differ: LP lists 2.6 x 10 x 7.5 inches for LP150 and 2.2 x 10 x 8 inches for LP170. Use those figures for rough space planning, not to infer which model is lighter or easier to control. They are outside dimensions, not grip measurements. If a particular bag pocket or storage drawer is a tight fit, confirm the relevant dimensions with the seller instead of assuming that every Cyclops fits because the family name is the same.

Shared equipment adds another consideration. A music group may have several people using one instrument over a month. In that situation, ask the actual players to consider the handle and the intended part, rather than choosing solely from the preference of the person placing the order. Keep the model name with the group inventory so a future replacement does not accidentally substitute a different jingle material.

Plan the hands and the transitions

These are handheld models. A guitarist who needs both hands on the guitar throughout a song cannot solve that requirement by picking one jingle metal over another. The same issue arises for a keyboard player covering a two-handed part. Decide whether the tambourine belongs with another musician, appears only during a deliberate break, or should be replaced by a different kind of percussion arrangement.

If you are exploring percussion while keeping your hands assigned to another instrument, the Meinl Motion and Foot Shaker comparison covers a different attachment and movement decision. It is not a substitute tambourine comparison: a shaker is a separate sound and playing approach. The useful connection is deciding which movements you can intentionally give to percussion without undermining the main part.

For a singer using either Cyclops, plan a reachable resting place before rehearsal starts. Put it where you can set the instrument down without balancing it on a stand edge or reaching through cables. Practice the pickup and put-down during the actual gaps in the arrangement. An otherwise simple part can become distracting when an instrument changes hands at the wrong moment or gets moved while someone else is speaking.

Make the first rehearsal about the part

Begin with one short phrase and agree on its entrance, pulse and ending. Keep the arrangement simple enough that everyone can hear what the added percussion contributes. If the group cannot agree whether the tambourine helps, remove it for the verse and bring it back only where the song needs a change. This gives the player a clear role and makes the choice between repeated rhythm and occasional punctuation more intentional.

Use an existing click source when practicing a repeating figure alone. The Korg MA-2 and Seiko SQ50V metronome comparison explains dedicated options if you need one, but buying another device is not a prerequisite. Start at a tempo where you can keep the intended pattern organized, then work toward the song tempo. Steel or brass should remain the sound choice, not a distraction from learning where each note belongs.

In a group, ask someone away from the playing position to describe the balance. A player hears the tambourine from a different place than the singer across the room. For a recording, evaluate it in the arrangement as well as by itself. If the part dominates, reconsider how much you play and where it enters before treating a change of material as the only possible fix.

Keep the exact variant clear at checkout

The selected Amazon pages identify LP150 as steel, black and handheld, and LP170 as brass, black and handheld. Their shared feature copy also mentions other jingle materials in the Cyclops range. Do not interpret that family-level wording as evidence that either selected instrument contains every material mentioned. Match the title, model and selected variant together, especially if navigating among related products changes the page selection.

LP170 here is the brass version, not a dimpled-brass model. Likewise, neither selected listing is the rod-mounted version. For a replacement purchase, use the existing model identifier instead of relying on a photograph of a black frame. Finish with a practical decision: choose LP150 for a deliberate steel-jingle purchase, LP170 for a deliberate brass-jingle purchase, and neither if the playing format does not fit the musician responsible for the part.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 6, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.