Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Outdoor & Travel Comparisons · Reviewed November 7, 2026

MSR Dromedary 4L vs 6L: How Much Water to Haul to Camp?

If you usually carry four liters or less, the 4 L Dromedary holds the same water in a shorter, narrower bag. The 6 L earns its space when the last two liters save a trip or let a group fill bottles without emptying the kitchen supply. Its empty weight penalty is only about 50 grams on MSR’s metric figures. Filling the extra capacity, though, puts roughly another two kilograms of water in one person’s hands.

Best for

Campers choosing a shared clean-water reservoir for cooking and bottle refills, with a specific carrying route, kitchen spot or pack compartment in mind.

Probably not for

Someone looking for a water filter, an included drinking hose, or a rigid self-standing dispenser with a tap beneath it.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
MSR specificationDromedary 4 LDromedary 6 L
Manufacturer SKU0958609587
Nominal capacity4 liters6 liters
Bag weight as listed200 g / 6.9 oz250 g / 8.7 oz
Listed width by length25.4 by 46.5 cm28.7 by 52.3 cm
Exterior and lining1,000-denier exterior; food-grade polyurethane lining1,000-denier exterior; food-grade polyurethane lining
Handling featuresPerimeter webbing; three-in-one capPerimeter webbing; three-in-one cap

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

MSR Dromedary 4 L water storage bag, black (09586)

The smaller bag makes sense for a water point you pass often or a cook kit that needs a measured refill rather than an entire evening’s supply. It has the same cap arrangement and exterior fabric specification as the larger bag; choosing less volume does not mean accepting a different dispensing system.

Pros

  • Shorter and narrower for a crowded pack or a shallow kitchen shelf
  • Sets a lower ceiling on the load you can put into a single carry

Cons

  • No reserve capacity above four liters
  • May require another collection trip when several people refill from the same bag

Who it’s for: Choose the 4 L for smaller, repeatable fills. Skip it if an ordinary kitchen refill plus the bottles beside it already total more than four liters.

Check MSR Dromedary 4 L water storage bag, black (09586) on Amazon

MSR Dromedary 6 L water storage bag, black (09587)

The 6 L lets one person bring a larger batch to a shared station. You can still stop filling at four liters when you do not need the rest. The decision is whether that occasional extra capacity is worth carrying the larger bag even on days when you use only part of it.

Pros

  • Two more liters at the same stop when water duties are shared
  • Can serve a smaller batch without committing to carrying a full six liters

Cons

  • All six liters are in one container and carried together unless you decant some
  • Greater listed width and length can complicate placement in a tight space

Who it’s for: Choose the 6 L for a basecamp or a longer walk between an established water supply and the cooking area. Pass if the only person collecting water would rather make two light trips.

Check MSR Dromedary 6 L water storage bag, black (09587) on Amazon

Work backward from the next refill, not the trip length

A three-night stay next to a campground tap can require less storage at any one time than a single picnic a long walk from the fill station. Set aside the number of days and list the containers or tasks the bag will serve before someone next goes for water. Count what will actually come out of the reservoir. If everyone arrives with a full bottle, do not count those bottles again unless you expect to top them up from the bag.

For a concrete packing exercise, put two one-liter bottles and your cookpot on the counter. Suppose you want to dispense two liters into the bottles, a liter into the pot and half a liter for a later kitchen task. That is three and a half liters. A four-liter batch covers that list with half a liter left. Add a second pair of empty one-liter bottles and the total becomes five and a half liters. Now the six-liter bag answers a specific problem: finishing the same round of refills without another walk. These are examples of container arithmetic, not recommendations for anybody’s drinking needs.

One useful way to trim the list is to separate water that must be at camp now from water that can wait for the next outing. If someone walks past the tap after dinner, there is little point in hauling tomorrow’s breakfast water in the afternoon merely because the reservoir has room. If the tap is by the parked car and nobody plans another visit, that extra capacity has a real assignment.

Distinguish empty weight from the load in your hand

Read the listed bag weights as empty gear, not the weight of the supply you will carry. At a four-liter fill, either bag contains roughly four kilograms of water; on the manufacturer’s rounded metric figures, the 6 L bag itself adds about 50 grams compared with the 4 L. At maximum fill the picture changes. The 6 L has two more liters inside, so the extra water alone is roughly two kilograms. Both comparisons are useful, but they answer different questions.

Think about who will carry that load and what else they will be holding. A six-liter collection run may suit someone walking an open path with both hands available. On a return to camp with food and loose utensils, the person doing the hauling might prefer to leave some capacity unfilled. Neither bag divides its contents between two backpacks on its own. If the group splits up, give each departing person the bottle they will need before the kitchen reservoir goes in the other direction.

A personal bottle and a shared reservoir do different jobs. If the awkward part of your current routine is opening a pack every time you want a sip, adding two liters at the cook station does not fix it. The Nalgene Wide Mouth vs CamelBak Chute Mag comparison addresses that separate choice of a bottle you keep within reach.

Try the outline in the place you intend to use it

Mark out the listed rectangles on paper: 25.4 by 46.5 centimeters for the 4 L and 28.7 by 52.3 for the 6 L. Set them on the shelf, pack panel or camp table you have in mind. Where does the cap end up? Can you get a hand around it with the stove case beside it? This costs no gear and can rule out an inconvenient layout. The paper is only a screening tool: a flexible bag changes shape as it fills, and the published width and length do not tell you the full thickness or guarantee a fit in a sleeve.

For the kitchen, give the bag a clean place separate from the burner. Decide where the pot will sit while you pour rather than planning to lift a full reservoir over a lit stove. Carry the filled pot to the burner afterward. If the problem is finding a stove that works with your intended cooking setup, the MSR PocketRocket 2 vs Deluxe guide covers that purchase. A bigger water bag does not increase the size of the pot or the usable cooking surface.

MSR supplies perimeter webbing for carrying or hanging on both sizes. Plan the support around the loaded bag, not a photograph of the empty one. If the only hanging point at a site is inconveniently high, a smaller supported bag that you can lower to pour may be more useful than a large one you have to reach overhead to handle. If you specifically want to park a container upright and fill cups underneath a fixed spigot, compare purpose-built camp dispensers before buying either flexible bag.

Same cap and fabric, different daily routine

Both Dromedarys use the three-in-one cap for filling, pouring and drinking. Nothing in this capacity choice adds a filter, so keep the decision about obtaining suitable water separate from the decision about storing it. A clean-water bag is much easier for a group to use correctly if everyone agrees on its job. Keep it distinct from containers used to collect untreated water or to hold dishwater. If your trip depends on a particular filter or hose connection, check the exact connection requirements instead of assuming that any outdoor reservoir will attach to it.

Allow space at home for cleanup as well as storage. MSR’s reservoir care guidance describes warm or hot soapy water for routine cleaning and gives separate steps for a more thorough clean. Follow the directions for the actual bag. An empty collapsible reservoir takes little room on a shelf, but it still needs attention after use; a packed bag with the cap shut is not a substitute for drying it. If you dislike looking after communal gear, filling the bottles already assigned to each traveler may be simpler than buying another container.

Finally, check the model wording, not just the capacity number on the selector. This pair is the black Dromedary in 4 L and 6 L, not the similarly named DromLite or the larger 10 L Dromedary. Choose 09586 when your list routinely fits in four liters and the smaller outline matters. Choose 09587 when you can name the extra containers you will fill and a sensible way to carry them. If you cannot yet name either, measure one actual meal-and-refill cycle with the kit you already own before deciding.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 7, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.