Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Kitchen Comparisons · Reviewed November 10, 2026

Angel Food Cake Pans: Nordic Ware vs Fat Daddio's

Buy the Nordic Ware 54901 for a classic angel food cake: its feet hold the inverted pan off the counter, and its removable base lets you loosen the cooled cake from underneath. Buy the Fat Daddio's PAF-10425 if the same pan also needs to hold the buttery topping for an upside-down cake. There's no bottom joint for the liquid to find.

Best for

Bakers choosing a full-size, smooth-sided tube pan for a family angel food recipe or for a mix of foam cakes and fruit-topped rings.

Probably not for

A baker who needs solid rounds for a layer cake, a sculpted Bundt pattern, or a pan small enough for an individual dessert.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
What matters in the kitchenNordic Ware Naturals 54901Fat Daddio's ProSeries PAF-10425
BaseRemovable floor and center cone lift out togetherSolid floor with a fixed tube
MaterialUncoated natural aluminumAnodized aluminum
Interior size9.4 inches across by 4.4 inches deep10 inches across by 4.25 inches deep
Listed pan capacity18 cups; not a batter-fill instruction16 cups on the current product page; baking guide lists 9 cups of batter
After bakingRaised feet for inverted cooling; separate the insert after coolingPlan a stable support for inverted cooling; no base to remove
CleaningHand-wash both piecesHand-wash the one-piece pan

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Nordic Ware Naturals 2-Piece Angel Food Pan with Removable Cone, 54901

A smooth, uncoated aluminum tube pan with feet at the rim. The floor comes away with the center cone, leaving the underside of a cooled cake accessible.

Pros

  • Built-in feet provide an inverted resting position when the cake clears the counter
  • Removable floor lets you free a delicate cake in stages

Cons

  • The join below the batter is not a seal for runny toppings
  • The pan must be supported by its outside shell, not just by its loose floor

Who it’s for: For the baker who expects to whip egg whites and wants to serve the resulting cake intact, with berries at the table rather than syrup in the pan.

Check Nordic Ware Naturals 2-Piece Angel Food Pan with Removable Cone, 54901 on Amazon

Fat Daddio's ProSeries Anodized Aluminum Angel Food Cake Pan, 10 x 4.25 Inches, PAF-10425

An anodized aluminum tube pan with a solid floor and a rolled rim. The maker documents both a pan volume and a separate batter amount for this specific size.

Pros

  • No removable-base joint beneath a buttery fruit topping
  • Single vessel to carry and wash, with nothing underneath to seat or align

Cons

  • No way to slide an insert out to expose the underside of a delicate cake
  • Inverted cooling needs a suitable support that you check before baking

Who it’s for: For a baker who wants to alternate plain ring cakes with recipes that put fruit or a liquid topping on the pan floor before baking.

Check Fat Daddio's ProSeries Anodized Aluminum Angel Food Cake Pan, 10 x 4.25 Inches, PAF-10425 on Amazon

Where will the strawberries go?

If you plan to pile fresh strawberries over an angel food cake just before slicing it, choose the Nordic Ware. Nothing wet needs to sit against the joint between the insert and the shell. The useful feature comes at the end: a tall cake can stay attached to the base while you slide it out of the outer wall. You get a second chance to loosen the bottom instead of asking the whole cake to drop out in one piece.

Change the order of those ingredients and the choice changes too. Picture an upside-down cake that starts with melted butter, sugar and sliced fruit on the pan floor. The Fat Daddio's base is continuous from the outer wall to the tube. There is no insert seam beneath that first layer. A sheet pan under a loose-bottom pan might catch a drip, but it cannot put the butter back under the fruit. For a recipe calling for a solid tube pan, choose the fixed base from the outset.

Read the shape instruction as well as the ingredient list. An angel food pan leaves a smooth-sided ring; neither of these models will stamp ridges into a lemon pound cake. If the shape you want is a deep spiral or a crown of flutes, the Nordic Ware Heritage and Anniversary Bundt pan comparison shows those shapes and their different capacities. A plain ring is handy when the finishing touch is fruit or cream, not the molding itself.

What does a cup rating actually tell you?

Take the Fat Daddio's numbers first because the distinction is unusually clear. The current product page describes the 10-inch pan as a 16-cup vessel. The company's cake baking guide assigns nine cups of batter to the PAF-10425. Those statements answer different questions. One describes space inside the pan; the other gives the baker an amount to start with. The seven cups of difference are not an invitation to add an extra half batch of whipped batter.

Nordic Ware lists 18 cups for the 54901, with an interior diameter of 9.4 inches and a depth of 4.4 inches. The Fat Daddio's interior is a little wider and a little shallower. A diameter measured across the outside rim does not tell you how much room the cone takes up or how high the batter can climb. Nor does a two-cup difference in rated pan volume predict how many more guests you can serve. The same recipe still goes to the table as the same quantity of cake.

Suppose a handwritten recipe says only 'large tube pan.' Before buying, ask the person who gave it to you whether the pan had a lift-out floor, and measure its inside width and depth if it is still around. If the old pan is gone, start with a published cake that names a size instead of doubling an unknown batter to fit your new pan. Fill according to the recipe and the maker's guidance, not to a line you remember from making banana bread.

Prepare the sides for the cake you are making

For traditional angel food, getting clean walls on purpose matters more than buying a pan that promises easy release. The batter needs to grip the sides. Leave the walls and tube ungreased when the recipe calls for an ungreased pan. Fat Daddio's recommends parchment on the bottom for a stiffly beaten egg-white batter. A ring of parchment confined to the floor is different from lining the sides or coating the whole pan with cake-release spray.

Keep the Nordic Ware insert seated before you spoon in the foam. Set the outer shell on the counter and lower the cone and floor into place. Make sure there are no crumbs under the floor. When you move the filled pan, take hold of the shell itself: pushing the insert up from below is precisely what you want to do after cooling, not before baking. The solid pan removes this particular handling step, although its tube still needs to stay free of grease for a classic foam cake.

Separate each egg over a small clean cup, then transfer the white to the mixing bowl once you know the yolk is intact. A broken yolk then affects one white instead of the whole bowl. If you want a separator that rests on the cup while you crack the next egg, the OXO and Chef’n egg separator comparison explains the different rim supports. For a butter cake in the same tube pan, put the angel food rules aside and follow that cake’s own pan-preparation instructions.

Give the inverted pan somewhere to stand

Before you turn on the mixer, turn the empty Nordic Ware upside down where the cake will cool. Its feet should sit level on a stable, heat-resistant surface. Look across the gap from the side: after baking, it is the pan that needs to take the weight, not the crown of the cake. Clear enough space that you can leave the cake there without moving it to get to the stove. Built-in feet are particularly useful in a kitchen that doesn't happen to have a suitable bottle.

For the Fat Daddio's pan, plan that resting place even more deliberately. King Arthur Baking describes inverting an angel food pan over the neck of a heatproof bottle or funnel. Check the fit while the pan is cold and empty; the support needs to stand securely and keep the cake clear of the counter. A neck that barely enters the tube or a funnel that rocks on its rim is not a solution to discover with oven mitts on. If you lack a stable setup, the footed Nordic Ware has the practical advantage.

Cooling upside down is part of the recipe for a classic angel food cake, not a serving flourish. Leave the cake attached until it has cooled as your recipe directs. Loosening it first takes away the very grip that supports it while it sets. An upside-down fruit cake has a different release problem, since the topping can set in the pan. Use its own instructions for how long to wait before turning it out rather than borrowing the long cooling time from the angel food recipe.

Getting the last inch of cake off the base

With the Nordic Ware, work around the cooled cake where it meets the outer wall before lifting the insert. Now the cake is out of the shell, but it is still on the metal floor. Loosen it around the center tube and run a thin, pan-safe spatula between the cake and its base. If you meet resistance at one spot, work there while the floor still supports the rest. The removable insert gives you access; it does not mean a foam cake should fall loose when you pick up the cone.

With the Fat Daddio's, free the outer edge and the center tube, then turn out the cake as its recipe directs. The floor stays where it is. For cooks who dislike trying to reach under a cake, that is the strongest reason to choose the two-piece design. Once the pan is empty, the balance tips slightly the other way: one solid pan to soak and hand-wash, without the ledge and underside of a separate insert to clean. Both makers recommend hand washing; neither pan is the choice for a dishwasher-only kitchen.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 10, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.