Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Travel Gear Comparisons · Reviewed November 12, 2026

Osprey Ultralight Stuff Pack 18L vs Dry Stuff Pack 20L

Take the 18-liter Ultralight Stuff Pack for a day of dipping into the bag at shops, stations and museums. Take the 20-liter Dry Stuff Pack when the whole point is to arrive with a dry change of clothes. The extra two liters matter less than the opening: a zipper you can leave partly open while you reach inside, or a roll-top you must close again to keep the weather out.

Best for

Travelers who leave their main luggage at their accommodation and want a second backpack for light loads on foot.

Probably not for

Carrying an unprotected laptop, keeping gear dry underwater or replacing a structured backpack for dense, heavy loads.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Black, one sizeUltralight Stuff PackUltralight Dry Stuff Pack
US model1000489310004890
Osprey capacity18 liters20 liters
Osprey empty weight0.329 lb (about 149 g)0.428 lb (about 194 g)
Main openingZipperRoll-top with buckle
Water protectionNo IPX5 rating listed by OspreyIPX5; not for submersion
Features for walkingTwo stretch side pockets; key clip; adjustable sternum strapStretch side pockets; adjustable sternum strap

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Osprey Ultralight Stuff Pack, 18L, Black (10004893)

The lighter of the two has a zippered opening and a key clip. It is the simpler bag to keep taking things out of, particularly if a companion is waiting for a ticket, snack or second pair of gloves.

Pros

  • Open the zipper only as far as needed to reach a small item.
  • A key ring can stay clipped in the same place as other items move in and out.

Cons

  • Osprey does not give this bag the Dry model’s water-protection rating.
  • Thin fabric is little help to a loose paper souvenir that needs to stay flat.

Who it’s for: Choose it for errands or sightseeing with frequent stops and easy shelter. Pack papers in a folder and give anything that cannot get wet its own protection.

Check Osprey Ultralight Stuff Pack, 18L, Black (10004893) on Amazon

Osprey Ultralight Dry Stuff Pack, 20L, Black (10004890)

The roll-top and coated seams make this the more useful pick for a long, exposed walk with spare layers inside. The water rating belongs to the closed pack, not to items tucked in the outside pockets.

Pros

  • IPX5 main compartment suits rain or spray without needing a separate bag for each layer.
  • Two extra liters leave more room for a bulky but light item.

Cons

  • Retrieving something from inside means undoing and remaking the roll.
  • Osprey specifically excludes submersion, so it is not an underwater case.

Who it’s for: Choose it if you can pack the main compartment once and leave it shut for the wet part of the day. Reconsider if you will be fishing for things inside at every stop.

Check Osprey Ultralight Dry Stuff Pack, 20L, Black (10004890) on Amazon

What comes out between the station and the hotel?

Take a rail journey with an afternoon to spare before check-in. Your suitcase goes in a station locker. You take a sweater, a sandwich and a guidebook into town in the small backpack. The guidebook comes out for the street map, goes back when you order lunch and comes out again to find the museum entrance. The zipper on the 18-liter pack suits that sort of day. You can open a short section, slide the book back on top and shut the bag without putting the whole thing on a café table.

Now change just one part of the journey: the afternoon is a long walk from a ferry landing to a cottage with nowhere to stop under cover. The sweater you packed is the one you want to put on when you arrive. Here the modest inconvenience of a roll-top happens twice, once at the terminal and once at the cottage. The benefit lasts the whole walk. The 20-liter Dry model makes sense even when the sweater, sandwich and guidebook would fit in the smaller pack.

Pack a roll-top from the bottom of the day upward

Think about the last thing you need, not the first thing that comes to hand while packing. For the ferry walk, put the dry shirt near the bottom, lunch above it and any layer you might need before arrival on top. Leave room at the mouth for the closure. If a tall vacuum flask sticks up into the portion you must roll, lay it down if it closes securely, carry it elsewhere, or leave something behind. A nominal two-liter advantage is no help if your actual load keeps the top from closing properly.

Keep the things you can use wet outside the closed compartment. A capped water bottle is a good candidate for a stretch pocket; a paper boarding pass is not. Slip the pass into an accessible protective pouch or a suitable jacket pocket before boarding. If the only place available for your phone is inside the Dry pack, download the route and look it over while you are under cover. Stopping to consult the screen at every corner means exposing the other contents each time you unroll the top.

Does everything need to stay dry together?

For a day at the beach the answer changes halfway through. A towel and a change of clothes can share dry storage on the way there. On the walk back, the swimsuit is wet, the book is sandy and the clean shirt is still clean. None of those things should go straight back into a single closed compartment together. A roll-top keeps weather on the outside; it cannot keep water on one side of the inside. Give the wet suit its own bag and open it to dry when you get back.

If most days are dry and only the shirt needs special treatment, a smaller protected bundle inside a pack you already own may do the job. The Sea to Summit Big River vs Lightweight dry bag comparison explains the difference between a dry bag carried inside another bag and one made to ride on the outside. If it is the towel that fills the pack, the Airlite vs Drylite camping towel guide compares two towels with the same open dimensions but quite different packed shapes. Changing that one item may save more space than switching backpacks.

A full bag is not always a heavy bag

An empty lunch box and a rolled fleece can take up most of the space without making a daypack hard to carry. A couple of books and two full water bottles can do the opposite. If you tend to browse bookshops on vacation, plan for the walk after the purchase, not just for the light walk from the hotel. A thin pack lets the corner of a hardback press toward your back. Placing the folded sweater between the cover and your back helps with the corner; it does not make the books lighter.

Osprey gives both packs an adjustable sternum strap. That lets you change where the shoulder straps sit; it does not make either pack a good substitute for the structured bag you already use to commute with a laptop. The difference in the listed empty weights is about 45 grams. For a trip where the second pack sits unused in the suitcase most days, taking the lighter one is reasonable. For a trip where you intend to fill it with heavy items every morning, start with the bag you know is comfortable loaded.

Separate rain protection from protection against damage

The important part of Osprey’s IPX5 description for the Dry model is the limit: it is not submersible. Getting sprayed while standing on a landing is a different job from protecting something after the bag falls into the water. The open stretch pockets are outside the protected space either way. If the itinerary involves swimming with your belongings or lowering equipment into water, neither of these bags supplies the required protection. Do not choose between them on the assumption that a tighter roll changes that limit.

Paper brings out another distinction. A sketchbook may need protection from water and also from bending. A soft daypack can fold around a water bottle, and its contents can be squeezed when another passenger puts a coat on top. For a few drawings, carry a flat folder that fits inside the opening with room left to close it. For a framed print or a camera with an exposed lens, a pack that happens to keep a sweater dry is not an answer to the risk of impact.

Which belongs in the suitcase?

For a weekend with a market on Saturday and a gallery on Sunday, the 18-liter Stuff Pack is the more useful second bag. Stash a light layer, clip the apartment key in place, and leave space at the top for the small things you acquire along the way. For several days of exposed walking, when a dry lunch and spare clothes matter more than a quick reach, pack the 20-liter Dry Stuff Pack. If the only extra job on the whole trip is getting breakfast pastries from the corner bakery, bring a shopping tote you already own and save the suitcase space.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 12, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.