Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed November 8, 2026
OXO vs Rösle Food Mills for Applesauce and Tomato Sauce
Choose the OXO Good Grips if you want to switch between smooth applesauce, mash and a chunkier sauce with the discs in the box. Choose the Rösle Passetout if you want a known hole size for berry sauce or thick soup and like having a second handle to steady the mill. Both turn softened produce into a purée while leaving larger solids above a sieve. The useful difference is what happens between your pot of fruit and the bowl that catches it.
Best for
Cooks who make sauce from softened apples, tomatoes or berries and want to strain the fruit as they purée it.
Probably not for
Grinding dry grains, chopping raw vegetables for salsa, or blending everything in a soup without separating any solids.
Specifications at a glance
| What matters at the counter | OXO Good Grips 1071478 | Rösle Passetout 16252 |
|---|---|---|
| Discs supplied | Three: fine, medium and coarse | Two: 1 mm and 3 mm |
| How it sits | Three folding, non-slip legs; for bowls or pots up to 11 inches across | Three support points and a counter handle; flat profile for low containers |
| Maker-listed capacity | Approximately 2.3 US quarts | 3.1 liters (about 3.3 US quarts) |
| Bowl material | Stainless steel interior with a plastic exterior | 18/10 stainless steel |
| Additional textures | All three listed grades come with the mill | 2 mm, 4 mm and 8 mm inserts listed separately |
| Cleaning | Dishwasher safe; release lever detaches crank assembly | Dishwasher safe; removable sieve insert |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill, 1071478
The three included discs cover different finishes without another purchase. The release lever is useful if you split one batch of cooked fruit between two textures; the folding feet suit a mill that lives in a cabinet between batches.
Pros
- Three texture choices supplied, including a middle setting for applesauce
- Published 11-inch maximum for the receiving pot takes some guesswork out of fit
Cons
- Smaller stated capacity than the Rösle
- Not the choice for resting directly on a pot wider than the stated 11-inch limit
Who it’s for: Pick this for a 10-inch bowl and a family that likes its applesauce two ways. If your only receiving vessel is broader than 11 inches, budget space for another bowl.
Check OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Food Mill, 1071478 on Amazon Paid linkRösle Passetout Food Mill with Counter Handle, 16252
The 1 mm and 3 mm inserts give you two clearly specified starting points. The short handle opposite the long one gives your steadying hand a choice of position, particularly useful when you have room on both sides of the bowl.
Pros
- A specified 1 mm sieve for fine fruit sauces and a 3 mm sieve for thicker purées
- Higher listed bowl capacity and a second handhold
Cons
- The intermediate 2 mm insert is a separate accessory
- At 44.5 cm long, the assembled mill needs a planned place to hang or sit
Who it’s for: Pick this for recurring berry and vegetable batches when its two supplied sieves match what you make. If you want three grades immediately, compare the OXO before adding a third Rösle insert.
Check Rösle Passetout Food Mill with Counter Handle, 16252 on Amazon Paid linkStart with a spoonful of the sauce you want
There are two quite different things people mean by chunky applesauce. One has a little texture all the way through. The other has distinct pieces of apple floating in a smooth base. A food mill helps with the first. For the second, lift some softened apple pieces out of the pan before milling the rest, then fold those pieces back in. A bigger opening will let more pulp through; it will not preserve a spoon-size piece of fruit.
OXO suggests its fine or medium disc for applesauce. Imagine making a pan on Sunday to serve with roast pork, with some left over for stirring into oatmeal. Start with the medium disc and taste a spoonful. If that is how you want it alongside the pork, put that portion aside. Change to the fine disc for the rest. You get to decide after tasting the same apples, rather than committing two pots of fruit to two different recipes.
For someone who writes down a process and repeats it next season, the Rösle has a different appeal. Record the insert, the fruit and how soft you cooked it. A note that says “raspberries, 1 mm” tells you which sieve to fit next summer. It does not tell you a seed count or guarantee a clear juice. For a particularly smooth topping, check a little of the result before tipping the whole bowl over a cheesecake.
Find a receiving bowl that stays put
Measure across the open rim, not across the bottom of the pot. A sauté pan with a 12-inch rim is too wide for the OXO specification even if its base measures only 10 inches. If it is where you cooked the tomatoes, leave them there and put the mill over a narrower mixing bowl. Ladle softened tomatoes across in portions. There is no reason the vessel that heated the food has to be the one that catches the sauce.
Set the empty mill on the empty bowl before adding food. Walk the crank through a full turn. If a foot misses the rim at the pouring spout, the bowl shifts, or your knuckles meet a cabinet, fix the setup while everything is clean and cool. The Rösle has three rests and a flat profile intended for low containers. That is not a promise that it spans a particular wide pot. All three points still need secure contact.
A shallow bowl can be convenient if a tall stockpot would put the knob up near your shoulder. It can also fill until the purée reaches the underside of the sieve long before the pan of tomatoes is empty. Keep a second bowl handy. Stop, lift the mill onto the empty bowl and transfer the first portion to the saucepan. Watching the level below the mill matters just as much as watching the fruit above it.
Know when the skins have done their job
A tomato skin sitting on top of the disc is not necessarily a blockage to push through. The point of milling sauce is to pass the soft flesh and leave unwanted pieces behind. Cook firm chunks until they yield to a spoon before starting. If the pulp stops moving, pause to see whether you have a layer of spent skins or another ladleful that still needs cooking. Neither problem calls for leaning harder on the handle.
On the OXO, the instructions specify clockwise turns for milling and occasional turns in reverse to move the food back into the path of the paddle. Fit the disc dome upward and secure the crank bar before loading it. These details are more useful than a promise about how fast a pan of tomatoes will go through: an incorrectly seated insert or food bunched up on one side changes what the turning handle can accomplish.
Suppose the goal is a smooth broth after removing herbs and cooked onions. You may not want to push the onions into the liquid at all. The OXO vs Rösle fine-mesh strainer comparison covers a simpler way to keep the solids behind. For tomato soup where the flesh belongs in the bowl but the skins do not, the paddle and perforated disc are doing a different job.
Separate a disc decision from a recipe decision
Rösle identifies its 1 mm insert for fine sauces and small-seeded fruit, and its 3 mm insert for thicker vegetable purées. Think of raspberry sauce for ice cream and carrot soup for lunch. That pair of dishes gives both included inserts a purpose. If your notes already specify a 2 mm opening, the mill itself is compatible but that disc is not in this two-sieve package. Check the accessory number against the mill before ordering one separately.
Hole size alone does not dictate how thick a sauce will be. A ladleful of tomato cooking liquid runs through either sieve; choosing the finer disc will not remove that water. If your recipe calls for adding liquid gradually, reserve some in a jug and stir it back into the milled pulp as needed. For a thinner soup that keeps all its softened vegetables, the KitchenAid vs Cuisinart hand blender guide covers blending them in the pot instead.
Plan one batch and the space to put it away
A three-quart pot of cooked fruit illustrates the capacity difference. It exceeds the OXO bowl’s listed 2.3 quarts and is near the Rösle’s nominal 3.1 liters. Those figures describe the mill bowls, not sensible one-pour loads. Leave working room for the paddle and for the fruit to move. Start with a portion you can turn comfortably and add more as the level drops. A larger bowl can leave room above the fruit; it does not eliminate the cranking.
Before buying the Rösle for its counter handle, put a strip of paper 44.5 cm long on the shelf where you would keep it. Check whether the cabinet door closes and whether you can get a hand around it without moving the stockpot first. The OXO’s feet fold, but its bowl still occupies space. Store the spare discs with the mill in either case. A fine insert lying under a roasting pan can turn a two-texture applesauce project back into a one-disc job.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 8, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- OXO: model 1071478, capacity, materials, discs, pot fit and care
- OXO: assembly, crank direction and food-specific disc suggestions
- Rösle: mill 16252 (now 160252), dimensions, capacity, supports and included inserts
- Rösle: 1 mm sieve for fine sauces and small-seeded fruit
- Rösle: 3 mm sieve for thicker soups and purées
- Amazon US: OXO Good Grips 2.3-quart mill with three discs Paid link
- Amazon US: Rösle 16252 food mill with handle and two sieves Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.