Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed October 30, 2026

OXO Butter Dish vs Wide Butter Dish: Which Fits Your Butter?

The standard OXO dish is specified for one 4-ounce stick. The Wide version accommodates two sticks or a wider block. Start with the butter you actually buy, then consider where the covered dish needs to fit.

Best for

Households choosing a covered butter tray and deciding between a single-stick format and space for wider butter or two sticks.

Probably not for

Anyone seeking a temperature-controlled container, a verified airtight travel box, a butter crock or a guarantee of longer food storage.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Manufacturer-documented featureButter Dish 11122500Wide Butter Dish 11198400
Intended quantity or formatOne 4-ounce stick of butterTwo 4-ounce sticks, European-style butter or an 8-ounce cream cheese block
Stick shapes specifically describedLonger/slimmer and shorter/stouter sticksWider European-style butter
Butter-positioning featureStoppers on three sidesStoppers; side count not specified on the cited page
Grip or base featureSoft, non-slip gripNon-slip feet
Manufacturer-listed dimensions2 x 7.7 x 2.7 inches7.9 x 3.7 x 2.4 inches
MaterialPlasticPlastic
Measurement markingsMarkings for the two described stick shapesNot detailed on the cited manufacturer page
Dishwasher statement on cited manufacturer pageExplicitly dishwasher safeNot stated; follow the exact product instructions

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

OXO Good Grips Butter Dish 11122500

A covered plastic dish sized around one 4-ounce stick, with stoppers and markings for both long, slim and shorter, wider stick formats. It is the focused choice when one stick is the amount you want to present.

Pros

  • Manufacturer specifies compatibility with two common stick shapes
  • Shape-specific measurement markings
  • Express dishwasher permission

Cons

  • Not specified for two sticks together
  • A wide block may require a different dish rather than a forced fit
  • Markings do not replace weighing when a recipe requires mass

Who it’s for: Choose it for one 4-ounce stick at a time. Skip it if your usual purchase is a wider block or you want two sticks on the same tray.

Check OXO Good Grips Butter Dish 11122500 on Amazon

OXO Good Grips Wide Butter Dish 11198400

The Wide version supplies a larger-format tray for European-style butter, two 4-ounce sticks or an 8-ounce cream cheese block. Its additional capacity is useful only if it matches what you intend to put in it.

Pros

  • Manufacturer explicitly accommodates two 4-ounce sticks
  • Also specified for European-style butter and an 8-ounce cream cheese block
  • Documented non-slip feet and a lid designed to sit on the dish

Cons

  • Extra capacity may be unnecessary for a one-stick routine
  • Overall size still needs checking against the intended storage space
  • Cited manufacturer page does not give the same care detail as the standard model

Who it’s for: Choose it for a wide block or a two-stick arrangement. Skip it if the extra room would crowd your usual storage spot without solving a real capacity problem.

Check OXO Good Grips Wide Butter Dish 11198400 on Amazon

Read the butter package before choosing the dish

A stick is a useful shopping shorthand, but it is not a complete shape specification. OXO describes the standard dish as accepting both longer, slimmer sticks and shorter, stouter ones, with a stated capacity of one 4-ounce stick. That makes it relevant to households changing between those two formats. It does not mean every butter block sold under a familiar brand name will fit.

The Wide model answers a different quantity-and-shape question. OXO expressly lists European-style butter, two 4-ounce sticks and an 8-ounce cream cheese block. Look at the package you buy most often rather than a hypothetical purchase you might make once. If you usually open one standard stick, extra tray space is optional. If you buy a wider block, choosing around that shape may avoid cutting it simply to make it fit.

Treat capacity as a practical difference, not a ranking

These are comparable covered butter trays, but they do not have equal intended capacity. The Wide name should not be read as a premium performance claim. A larger tray can solve a real fit problem while being an unnecessary object for someone else. Neither product has demonstrated a longer useful life or better preservation in this comparison, and no purchase price is used to declare a winner.

For a shared breakfast table, decide how much butter you actually want on one dish and where guests will reach for it. If one stick is enough, the standard model addresses that job directly. If your planned arrangement calls for two, the Wide has manufacturer support for that quantity. More capacity is not permission to stack butter beyond the intended arrangement or assume the lid will clear any shape.

Measurement markings need the right stick shape

OXO documents markings for both stick formats on the standard dish. Their usefulness depends on placing the matching shape where the markings are intended to be read. They are a convenience for working with a recognizable stick, not a universal ruler for every irregular piece left from another recipe. Once a block has been cut unevenly, its position on the tray becomes part of the interpretation.

If a recipe gives a mass, weigh the quantity it requests instead of treating a tray mark as a calibrated scale reading. Our OXO-versus-Escali kitchen-scale comparison covers that separate decision. You do not need to buy a scale simply to own a butter dish; the point is to choose the measurement method the recipe requires. The cited Wide product page does not detail its markings, so they are not a claimed advantage here.

Check the covered shape and the lifting space

Use all three manufacturer dimensions when checking the intended location. OXO lists 2 by 7.7 by 2.7 inches for the standard dish and 7.9 by 3.7 by 2.4 inches for the Wide. These are published overall product measurements, not internal butter-clearance measurements. Do not infer usable tray width, lid height above the food or an exact capacity for an unlisted block from the exterior figures.

Also leave room to lift the lid and hold the base. A space that accepts a closed container can still be awkward when a neighboring jar blocks your fingers. Check the route from its storage position to the worktop or table, especially if you normally carry several breakfast items together. The right size is one you can place and retrieve deliberately, not merely squeeze into a gap.

A resting lid is different from a travel closure

OXO describes the Wide lid as fitting on top without falling off, but that is not a published leakproof or airtight rating. Neither cited product page establishes a latched transport system. Do not treat a covered serving dish as a sealed lunch container just because a lid is included. If transporting butter in a bag is the main job, look for a product whose documentation specifically addresses that use.

Support the dish by its base when moving it and choose somewhere clean to put the removed lid. Keep a separate utensil available for serving so that the lid does not become an improvised tool rest. A clear arrangement of tray, lid and utensil can matter more at the table than adding capacity. This comparison does not promise a storage duration or substitute a dish choice for the food package instructions.

Plan cleanup without transferring permissions

The standard model page explicitly marks the dish as dishwasher safe. The inspected Wide manufacturer page does not repeat that statement, even though its Amazon listing describes dishwasher cleaning. Follow the instructions supplied with the exact Wide product, and confirm with OXO if machine washing is an essential requirement. The shared brand and plastic construction are not, by themselves, a model-specific care instruction.

Whichever dish you choose, make cleanup part of the comparison: the tray, lid and areas around the stoppers all need attention after use. There is no measured cleaning-speed advantage here. If the broader task is organizing toast and butter at breakfast, our compact-toaster comparison may be useful related reading, but replacing another appliance is not necessary to make either butter dish work.

The final choice is the format you use repeatedly

Choose the standard 11122500 for a one-stick routine, the documented shape-specific markings and explicit dishwasher permission. Choose the Wide 11198400 when a wider block or two sticks is the reason you are shopping. Keep an existing suitable dish if it already accommodates your butter and care routine. Neither model becomes essential simply because it coordinates with other kitchen tools.

Manufacturer documentation and Amazon identities were checked on October 30, 2026. The standard listing identifies model 11122500, UPC 719812042268 and ASIN B00L9X6M6I. The Wide listing identifies model 11198400, UPC 719812049854 and ASIN B01MRHR860. Confirm the selected model before ordering. This guide is based on documented specifications and practical fit, not hands-on testing or customer-review summaries.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on October 30, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.