Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed October 13, 2026
OXO 11330900 vs RSVP PUNCH-5: Which 5-Quart Colander?
Both hold five quarts and use stainless steel. OXO adds elevated nonslip handles and three feet; RSVP specifies 18/8 steel, tiny pierced holes and a continuous wide rim base.
Best for
Cooks choosing between raised nonslip handles with three individual feet and a continuous-base design with very small precision-pierced openings.
Probably not for
Anyone needing a collapsible strainer, over-sink arms, a steamer insert, or verified claims about drain speed and food retention that the specifications do not establish.
Specifications at a glance
| Detail | OXO 11330900 | RSVP PUNCH-5 |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 5 qt / 4.7 L | 5 qt |
| Material | Stainless steel | 18/8 stainless steel |
| Openings | Perforations across bowl | Tiny precision-pierced holes |
| Handles | Two elevated nonslip handles | Wide metal rim; no nonslip handle claim |
| Base | Three raised feet | Continuous wide rim base |
| Published size | 11.032 x 12.411 x 6.2 in | 11 in diameter x 5.25 in high |
| Care | No dishwasher claim on current page | Dishwasher safe |
| Exact model | SKU 11330900 | SKU PUNCH-5 |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
OXO Good Grips 5 Qt Stainless Steel Colander (11330900)
A five-quart stainless colander with perforations around the bowl, two raised nonslip handles and three elevated feet. OXO also documents nesting with its stainless mixing bowls.
Pros
- Elevated nonslip handles create clear grip points away from the bowl
- Three feet raise the perforated bowl above a flat surface
- Documented nesting with OXO stainless mixing bowls can simplify compatible-set storage
Cons
- Current page does not identify the steel grade as 18/8
- Dishwasher status is not stated on the current product page
- Wider handle-to-handle measurement needs more cabinet width
Who it’s for: Choose it when distinct raised grips, three feet and documented OXO bowl nesting are useful. Skip it when a continuous base ring or explicitly published dishwasher care is required.
Check OXO Good Grips 5 Qt Stainless Steel Colander (11330900) on Amazon Paid linkRSVP Endurance Precision Pierced Colander, 5 Qt (PUNCH-5)
A five-quart 18/8 stainless colander with small precision-pierced openings across the bowl, a polished surface and a wide continuous rim base. RSVP states that it is dishwasher safe.
Pros
- Manufacturer identifies the material as 18/8 stainless steel
- Tiny precision-pierced openings distinguish it from larger-hole designs
- Wide rim base and dishwasher-safe care are explicitly documented
Cons
- No nonslip handle material is specified
- Continuous base ring creates a different sink-contact pattern than three feet
- Manufacturer page does not document nesting with a separate bowl line
Who it’s for: Choose it when small pierced openings, a continuous base ring and published dishwasher care matter. Skip it when elevated nonslip handles or three separated feet are priorities.
Check RSVP Endurance Precision Pierced Colander, 5 Qt (PUNCH-5) on Amazon Paid linkEqual capacity keeps the comparison focused on handling
Both exact products hold five quarts, so this is not a choice between a small berry strainer and a large pasta colander. OXO translates its capacity as 4.7 liters, while RSVP lists five quarts. The useful differences are how each bowl is lifted, how it sits above the sink, how the openings are formed and what the manufacturer says about care.
Five-quart capacity does not state working room for every food. A pile of greens occupies more volume than the same weight of pasta, and vigorous rinsing benefits from headroom. If the usual batch nearly fills a five-quart mixing bowl, consider whether a larger colander is appropriate rather than assuming either comparison item will prevent spillover.
OXO separates hands and sink with raised components
OXO gives the 11330900 two elevated nonslip handles. Those handles extend beyond the bowl and provide defined places to hold it without gripping a thin rim. Three feet lift the perforated body above the surface below. The design can be useful when carrying a filled colander or setting it in a sink, but the feet and handles also determine its storage footprint.
The published dimensions are 11.032 by 12.411 by 6.2 inches, with the longer dimension reflecting the handles. Measure cabinet width and dishwasher rack clearance rather than using the nominal bowl diameter alone. Nonslip describes the handle surface; it does not mean the loaded colander cannot shift, tip or become difficult to hold.
RSVP emphasizes pierced openings and a ring base
RSVP makes PUNCH-5 from 18/8 stainless steel and covers the bowl with small precision-pierced holes. The company publishes an 11-inch diameter and 5.25-inch height. A wide continuous rim supports the bowl above the sink floor. That ring differs from OXO's three points of contact and gives the product a more traditional footed-bowl profile.
The small holes are an observable design feature, but this guide does not claim a specific food can never pass through them. Shape, cooking state and orientation affect retention. It also does not claim that one product drains faster. Hole area, quantity, placement, water volume and food position would need a controlled like-for-like test before making that conclusion.
Base style changes cleanup and placement
Three individual feet leave open gaps beneath most of the OXO bowl. A continuous ring puts more material around the lower perimeter of the RSVP bowl. Either arrangement can keep the perforated bottom from resting flat on a sink, but each creates different areas to inspect for residue and trapped water after use. Rinse around the feet or rim and dry before cabinet storage.
Sink geometry matters. A center drain, sloped basin and disposal flange can change how a colander sits. Compare the published outside dimensions with the flat area available in the actual sink. Neither manufacturer statement establishes that the product will bridge a sink opening, so do not use it as an over-sink strainer unless it is supported safely within the basin.
Care information is not identical
RSVP explicitly calls PUNCH-5 dishwasher safe. OXO's current page describes materials, handles, feet, nesting, weight and dimensions but does not make a dishwasher statement for 11330900. Absence of that sentence is not proof that dishwasher use is forbidden; it means the comparison should not invent matching care instructions. Follow the current packaging and manufacturer guidance for the exact item received.
Both products should be checked around openings, handle junctions and base structures before storage. Water remaining in crevices can drip into a cabinet even when the visible bowl looks dry. Avoid abrasive methods unless permitted by the maker. A corrosion-resistant alloy claim also does not make a kitchen tool immune to staining, harsh chemicals or neglect.
Choose grip architecture or pierced-bowl detail
Choose OXO 11330900 when elevated nonslip handles, three separated feet and nesting with OXO stainless bowls match the kitchen workflow. Choose RSVP PUNCH-5 when documented 18/8 steel, very small pierced openings, a continuous rim base and explicit dishwasher care matter more. Choose neither if collapsible storage, extendable sink arms or a steamer function is required.
The verified Amazon ASINs are B09Z76236G for OXO model 11330900 and B000BUDDVM for RSVP model PUNCH-5. Confirm the model because each brand sells other capacities and constructions. No price, stock, stability, drain-speed, heat-safety or food-retention measurement is claimed. The recommendations interpret current physical specifications rather than customer reviews or hands-on testing.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on October 13, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.