Home Cleaning Tool Comparisons · Reviewed October 13, 2026
OXO 12125800 vs O-Cedar 168017: Which Broom and Dustpan Set?
OXO pairs an adjustable full-size broom with a long-handled pan that locks open. O-Cedar uses an angled dual-bristle broom and a step-on hand pan with integrated cleaning combs.
Best for
Households choosing between an upright long-handled pan with an extendable broom and a foot-held compact pan with bristle-cleaning combs designed around hair.
Probably not for
Wet cleanup, carpet vacuuming, outdoor construction debris, or performance percentages and ergonomic outcomes not established by comparable independent testing.
Specifications at a glance
| Detail | OXO 12125800 | O-Cedar 168017 |
|---|---|---|
| Dustpan format | Extra-large upright pan with long handle | Compact step-on hand pan |
| Pan position | Locks open for disposal | Held to floor with a foot |
| Broom handle | Extends from storage height to 53 in | Fixed handle; length not published |
| Bristles | Feathered soft tips | Angled dual-bristle design |
| Bristle cleaning | Dustpan comb | Integrated cleaning combs |
| Floor contact | Flexible dustpan lip | Flexible sealing lip |
| Storage | Broom nests in pan; 3.25 x 10.875 x 39 in stored | Broom and pan; storage dimensions not published |
| Exact model | Official SKU 12125800 | Model 168017 |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
OXO Large Sweep Set with Extendable Broom (12125800)
A full-size broom extending to 53 inches with feathered soft-tipped bristles, paired with an upright pan that has a flexible lip, cleaning teeth and an open lock for carrying debris.
Pros
- Long-handled pan avoids lifting a small pan from floor level during collection
- Extendable broom provides a 39-inch stored height and 53-inch use length
- Nested upright storage dimensions are published for closet planning
Cons
- Stored set remains 39 inches tall and 10.875 inches wide
- Long-handled pan takes more vertical space than a small hand pan
- No pet-hair pickup percentage or controlled performance result is used here
Who it’s for: Choose it when upright collection, adjustable broom length and measurable storage fit matter. Skip it if a compact step-on hand pan is preferred.
Check OXO Large Sweep Set with Extendable Broom (12125800) on Amazon Paid linkO-Cedar PowerCorner Pet Pro Broom and Step-On Dustpan (168017)
An angled dual-bristle broom with a compact floor pan that can be held in place by foot, plus a flexible lip, integrated combs for clearing the bristles and a tap-to-empty design.
Pros
- Step-on pan can be held at the floor without a long pan handle
- Integrated combs are designed to pull hair and debris from broom bristles
- Angled head targets room edges and corners
Cons
- Pan still needs to be lifted for carrying and emptying
- Manufacturer does not publish overall handle or storage dimensions
- Pet-oriented design does not prove a specific pickup result in every home
Who it’s for: Choose it when a foot-held hand pan, corner-oriented broom head and bristle-cleaning combs fit the routine. Skip it if an upright long-handled pan or exact storage measurements are required.
Check O-Cedar PowerCorner Pet Pro Broom and Step-On Dustpan (168017) on Amazon Paid linkThe dustpan changes the entire sweeping sequence
OXO uses an upright dustpan with its own long handle. O-Cedar uses a smaller pan that stays on the floor when a foot presses its step area. Both approaches reduce the need to hold a pan edge by hand while sweeping, but they separate at the next step: OXO carries debris in the upright pan, while O-Cedar's hand pan must be lifted.
Think through the route from floor to trash can. An upright pan may suit someone who wants to remain standing during collection and transport. A compact pan can be easier to position in a narrow area and consumes less pan volume, but lifting it is part of the workflow. Neither format is automatically cleaner without considering floor texture, debris and technique.
OXO publishes an adjustable height and storage envelope
OXO's broom extends to 53 inches for use. Nested with the pan in storage position, the set measures 3.25 by 10.875 by 39 inches. Those exact dimensions are valuable when the set must fit behind a door, beside a refrigerator or within a utility closet. The broom nests into the dustpan so the two pieces can stand together.
An adjustable pole adds a joint that should be locked before sweeping. Retracting it reduces stored height but does not make the set short enough for a small under-sink cabinet. O-Cedar does not publish an equivalent handle or storage measurement on its current page, so this comparison does not guess one from photographs or third-party listings.
Bristle design reflects different stated priorities
OXO describes feathered, soft-tipped bristles intended to gather dust and debris. O-Cedar uses an angled dual-bristle design and positions PowerCorner Pet Pro around pet hair and corner reach. These descriptions tell a buyer how the makers shape and market the heads. They are not directly comparable laboratory results and do not establish an overall pickup winner.
Soft fine tips may be useful for light indoor particles, while stiffer or differently angled sections can address edges and mixed debris. Actual behavior depends on floor seams, static, hair length and maintenance. Avoid using either indoor broom on hot material, liquids or sharp construction waste that could damage bristles or create an unsafe cleanup.
Both pans include bristle-cleaning features
OXO builds cleaning teeth into the upright pan. O-Cedar integrates combs into the step-on pan and describes a tap-to-empty mechanism. Both features are meant to move clinging hair or debris from the broom into the pan without pulling it away by hand. They still need periodic inspection because wrapped threads and lodged particles may not release in one pass.
Use the comb in the direction intended by the manufacturer and keep fingers away from sharp debris. If long fibers wrap near the broom block, remove them only with the tool stationary and supported. A self-cleaning phrase should not be interpreted as maintenance free, and this guide does not repeat maker pickup percentages as independent evidence.
Flexible lips need a clean floor contact edge
Both brands describe a flexible lip at the floor. The purpose is to create a transition that debris can cross into the pan. Dust, hair or a warped storage position can interfere with that edge. Before sweeping, set the pan on a flat section and check that the lip contacts the surface rather than assuming a flexible material seals every floor texture.
Deep grout, uneven boards and textured tile can leave gaps beneath any pan. Change the pan angle, sweep from more than one direction and clean the edge after use. Do not press so hard with the O-Cedar foot step that the pan distorts, and do not treat OXO's open lock as a load-bearing feature beyond ordinary debris collection.
Choose upright transport or compact foot control
Choose OXO 12125800 when the user values a long-handled pan, a broom that extends to 53 inches and exact nested storage measurements. Choose O-Cedar 168017 when a compact step-on pan, dual-bristle corner design and integrated hair-clearing combs better fit the routine. Choose neither for wet pickup or for floors that require a vacuum or specialty tool.
The verified Amazon ASINs are B00L9WK5P8 for the OXO Large Sweep Set tied to base SKU 12125800 and B08Z9ZLLVX for O-Cedar model 168017. Confirm the product name and identifiers because packaging revisions may add suffixes to OXO's retail record. No price, stock, pickup percentage, durability, comfort or medical outcome is claimed.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on October 13, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- OXO: 12125800 set design, handle extension, bristles, pan features and stored dimensions
- O-Cedar: PowerCorner Pet Pro bristles, step-on pan, combs, flexible lip and emptying design
- Amazon: exact OXO Large Sweep Set listing with base 12125800 product identity
- Amazon: exact O-Cedar model 168017 listing and ASIN identity
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.