Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Home & Cleaning Comparisons · Reviewed October 29, 2026

OXO Sink Strainer vs 2-in-1 Stopper: Do You Fill the Basin?

Both use a flexible basket that turns inside out for emptying. The important extra in the 13259500 is a twist-operated stopper, useful only if you actually want to hold water in the sink.

Best for

Households comparing removable kitchen sink strainers and deciding whether the same accessory should also plug the drain for hand washing.

Probably not for

Anyone replacing the installed drain assembly, seeking a guaranteed cure for slow drainage or needing verified compatibility with an unusual drain opening.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Manufacturer detailSilicone Sink Strainer2-in-1 Silicone Sink Strainer with Stopper
Exact model130820013259500
Main purposeStrainingStraining or plugging the sink
Stopper controlNo integrated stopper describedQuarter-turn knob, either direction
Listed overall dimensions4.4 x 4.4 x 1.6 inches4.4 x 4.4 x 1.7 inches
MaterialsSilicone and stainless steelSilicone and stainless steel
Emptying arrangementLift by center post and invert basketInverting silicone basket
Cleaning permissionDishwasher safeDishwasher safe
Purchase comparedOne strainerOne strainer with integrated stopper

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

OXO Good Grips Silicone Sink Strainer 1308200

The straining-only choice for a sink that you normally keep draining, or for a household that already has a separate stopper it likes. The center post is the lifting point for emptying the flexible basket.

Pros

  • No stopper-mode decision during ordinary rinsing
  • Flexible basket can be inverted to remove collected scraps
  • Manufacturer permits dishwasher cleaning

Cons

  • Does not provide the integrated fill-the-basin function
  • Overall width does not establish compatibility with every drain
  • Still needs regular removal and emptying

Who it’s for: Choose it when catching scraps is the job and plugging the sink is not. Skip it if you want one accessory to alternate between draining and holding wash water.

Check OXO Good Grips Silicone Sink Strainer 1308200 on Amazon

OXO Good Grips 2-in-1 Silicone Sink Strainer with Stopper 13259500

This version adds a stopper operated by the center knob. It is relevant when the basin itself is your washing vessel and you want to change functions without keeping a separate plug beside the sink.

Pros

  • Combines straining and stopping in one accessory
  • Quarter-turn control changes the intended function
  • Retains the inverting basket and dishwasher permission

Cons

  • You need to keep track of which mode is selected
  • Stopper usefulness depends on the fit of the actual drain
  • Adds a function that is unnecessary if you wash in a separate bowl

Who it’s for: Choose it when you regularly fill a compatible basin for hand washing. Skip it if you only want an open strainer or require a confirmed fit that the general product dimensions cannot establish.

Check OXO Good Grips 2-in-1 Silicone Sink Strainer with Stopper 13259500 on Amazon

Let the dishwashing routine decide whether you need a stopper

Think about your last few washing-up sessions. Did you fill the sink itself, use a separate washing bowl or rinse individual items under the faucet? The 2-in-1 function directly serves the first routine. For the other two, a stopper may contribute little. This is a better starting point than assuming that the product with another function is automatically the more useful purchase.

A double-bowl sink can make the answer different for each side. You might reserve one basin for wash water and leave the other available for draining. There is no need to make both sides identical if their jobs differ. Equally, if your existing separate stopper already works well, buying the 2-in-1 solely to replace two familiar pieces with one is optional, not a necessary upgrade.

Measure the drain area rather than the sink as a whole

Overall sink width does not answer whether either accessory will sit properly over the drain. Look at the opening, the surrounding flange and the space beneath the rim where the basket needs to rest. Notice any raised center part or other existing fitting. Take a clear photograph and measurements if you need the manufacturer to confirm a particular installation before ordering.

OXO lists the same 4.4-inch overall width for these two models, with a small difference in listed height. Those are product dimensions, not a universal drain-size specification. They do not establish how either basket fits a recessed opening or whether the stopper will seal against your particular drain. Avoid substituting a marketplace compatibility field for a manufacturer-confirmed match when the fit is uncertain.

Do not confuse a removable accessory with installed plumbing

These products are the removable pieces you lift to empty. They are not replacements for the fixed flange, the connections below the sink or a damaged drain assembly. Before buying, identify which part is actually missing or troublesome. A loose strainer cannot correct a leak at an installed connection, and changing the basket does not diagnose the reason a sink drains slowly.

Check how other sink accessories occupy the same space. A basin mat or bottom grid may have an opening that leaves plenty of room for the basket but makes the center control awkward to reach. Consider the assembled setup, including the dishes you usually place nearby. The relevant question is whether you can lift or operate the accessory in that arrangement, not merely whether it looks neat in an empty sink.

The two center controls have different jobs

On the strainer-only model, the center post provides a lifting point. On the 2-in-1, the knob also operates the stopper. Make that distinction clear to anyone sharing the kitchen, especially if you are replacing a familiar accessory. When switching between washing and rinsing, check the selected position instead of assuming the drain is open because the basket is visible.

For a basin used mainly to rinse produce or small utensils, a straining-only setup keeps that choice out of the routine. For a basin that regularly alternates between holding water and draining, the combined control may be the feature you want. Neither design eliminates the need to pay attention while filling the sink. A stopper function is not an overflow-control system or permission to leave running water unattended.

Plan where the collected scraps will go

The inverting basket is a shared feature rather than a reason to favor the more complex model. Before lifting it, have the appropriate waste container within reach. Carry the collected scraps to that container and empty the basket there, rather than undoing the collection step by rinsing everything back toward the open drain. Follow your local waste-sorting rules for what belongs in each bin.

The basket should be accessible often enough that emptying does not become a postponed chore. If dishes routinely cover it, change the clearing sequence before assuming another strainer will solve the problem. Move the dishes, remove collected material, then return the clean accessory to its place. A larger household may repeat this process more often, but the documentation does not give a tested debris capacity or a reliable interval between emptying.

Cleaning the basket and cleaning the dishes are separate tasks

Both manufacturer pages permit dishwasher cleaning. Choose the washing method and placement described in the instructions supplied with the actual item, and check the basket after cleaning before putting it back. The flexible form gives access when inverted, but that design alone does not establish a measured cleaning-time advantage or a guarantee that every residue will fall away without attention.

For the dishes themselves, our OXO-versus-Joseph-Joseph dish-brush comparison addresses bristle placement and how the brush rests between uses. The OXO folding-dish-rack comparison covers the drying stage after washing. Those are contextual choices, not accessories required for either strainer. Keep a working brush and rack if they already suit the space; a drain accessory does not require rebuilding the rest of the sink station.

Choose the function, then verify the exact listing

Choose 1308200 for a straining-only role when a separate stopper is already available or unnecessary. Choose 13259500 when you regularly fill the basin and the integrated control is worth having. If neither has confirmed compatibility with your drain, resolve that issue before choosing between the functions. The most useful feature cannot compensate for a poor physical match.

Documentation and listing identities were checked on October 29, 2026. The purchase links identify model 1308200, UPC 719812020822, and model 13259500, UPC 719812687537, each as one item. The latter listing also uses part number 13259500V1. This guide compares documented designs, not hands-on results or customer-review claims; it does not promise a clog-free drain, a particular flow rate or a watertight seal in every sink.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on October 29, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.