Baking Tool Comparisons · Reviewed October 26, 2026
OXO 73281 vs Mercer M18370: Which Bench Scraper Fits Your Baking?
For dough dividing and board cleanup, the useful choice is between a soft-grip, dishwasher-safe tool and a textured nylon-handled scraper with a taller published profile.
Best for
Home bakers choosing a straight metal bench scraper to portion dough, gather chopped ingredients and clear a suitable work board.
Probably not for
Scraping nonstick coatings, cutting on silicone baking mats, flexible bowl scraping, or replacing a kitchen knife for detailed slicing.
Specifications at a glance
| Detail | OXO Good Grips 73281 | Mercer Hell's Handle M18370 |
|---|---|---|
| Blade | Stainless steel | Precision-ground stainless steel |
| Handle | Soft non-slip grip | Dual-textured high-temperature nylon |
| Published overall dimensions | 6 x 1.5 x 4 in | 6 x 5 in; thickness not listed |
| Separate blade size | Not separately listed | 5-7/8 x 3-1/2 in |
| Markings | Quarter-inch marks on current maker page | Measurements along blade edge |
| Cleaning guidance | Dishwasher safe | Cited page provides general hand-wash care |
| Other documentation | OXO Better Guarantee | NSF listed; limited lifetime warranty |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
OXO Good Grips Multi-Purpose Scraper & Chopper 73281
A metal bench scraper with a broad cushioned handle and a ruler along the working edge.
Pros
- Explicit dishwasher approval simplifies cleanup
- Soft grip provides an alternative to a firm handle
- Shorter published overall height takes less space when laid flat
Cons
- Current maker and Amazon text disagree about marking increments
- Not a flexible tool for curved bowls
- Metal edge requires a compatible work surface
Who it’s for: Choose it for ordinary home baking when dishwasher cleanup and a soft handle matter. Skip it if the main task is sweeping batter from the inside of a bowl.
Check OXO Good Grips Multi-Purpose Scraper & Chopper 73281 on Amazon Paid linkMercer Culinary Hell's Handle Bench Scraper M18370
A red-handled bench scraper with edge measurements, a sealed handle junction and a taller overall profile.
Pros
- Textured handle offers a different grip feel
- Separate blade dimensions make the working face easier to plan around
- NSF documentation may matter in a commercial kitchen
Cons
- Taller profile occupies more space when laid flat
- No scraper-specific dishwasher approval appears on the cited page
- Heat-resistant handle does not make the blade safe to touch when hot
Who it’s for: Choose it when the taller form, textured grip or commercial documentation fits the kitchen. Skip it if explicit dishwasher approval is a purchase requirement.
Check Mercer Culinary Hell's Handle Bench Scraper M18370 on Amazon Paid linkStart with the jobs that happen between mixing and baking
A bench scraper earns its space when dough must move from one part of the board to another. Think of dividing a pizza batch, gathering flour after rolling pastry, or lifting a mound of chopped ingredients without dragging a knife edge sideways. Both tools serve that same basic workflow; neither needs to be treated as a complete replacement for the other utensils in the drawer.
If your main frustration is dough left inside a mixing bowl, a flexible bowl scraper is a better first purchase. A flat metal edge cannot conform to a curved wall. Likewise, delicate slicing still calls for an appropriate knife. Choose this category because a broad straight working edge is useful, not because one multipurpose tool is expected to do every preparation task.
Handle shape matters during repeated portioning
The OXO offers a cushioned grip, while the Mercer uses textured nylon. That is a meaningful preference rather than a comfort ranking: some hands prefer a softer contact surface, while others want a firmer shape to hold. Neither manufacturer provides a controlled comparison of fatigue between these exact models, so there is no basis to promise that one will make a long baking session easier.
Imagine holding the handle with flour on your fingers and pressing straight down through a dough rope. Your hand should stay above the food without needing a strained wrist angle. If possible, hold a display model before buying. For storage, allow clearance around the handle as well as the metal face; a wide scraper can jam a shallow drawer even when its blade fits the organizer.
Ruler marks help with length, not portion weight
Both blades have measurement references. OXO currently describes quarter-inch markings, whereas the linked Amazon text still says one-inch markings. Use the current manufacturer description as the specification, but check the supplied tool if that detail determines the purchase. Mercer confirms measurements along the edge without naming the increment on its current page; this guide does not invent a matching scale.
A ruler is useful for dividing a dough rope into similar lengths or checking a strip of pastry. Equal length is not necessarily equal mass when a rope tapers or has uneven thickness. For rolls that need consistent portions, place each piece on a kitchen scale and adjust it before shaping. The scraper makes separation convenient; it does not turn an irregular batch into identical portions automatically.
Match the surface before pressing down
A metal edge can damage a surface that is softer than the tool. Work on a suitable cutting or pastry board and follow that surface maker's instructions. Do not assume that a silicone baking mat is a cutting board, or that a nonstick pan can tolerate scraping because the tool is sold for baking. Move food to an appropriate surface before making downward cuts.
Keep the supporting hand clear of the edge and gather ingredients in manageable amounts. When transferring chopped food, slide the blade underneath instead of forcing an oversized pile onto it. A second hand can guide the food from above without wrapping fingers below the edge. For sticky dough, adjust the dough-handling method specified by the recipe rather than compensating with enough force to gouge the board.
Cleaning instructions are a real buying difference
OXO expressly allows dishwasher cleaning. The Mercer page displays general cutlery care that favors hand washing, rather than a clear scraper-specific dishwasher approval. That distinction is enough to guide a cautious purchase: choose OXO if machine washing is essential, or plan to hand-wash Mercer unless its supplied instructions say otherwise. Do not infer cleaning permission from stainless steel alone.
Remove dough before it dries into the handle junction, then wash and dry the tool according to its instructions. Check the edge for damage before returning it to the drawer. A metal scraper should not disappear under cloudy sink water where someone might reach for it blindly. The heat-resistant wording on the Mercer handle also does not authorize leaving either scraper on a hot pan or using bare fingers on heated steel.
Choose the useful difference, then confirm the model
For a household that cleans baking tools in the dishwasher, the OXO is the clearer fit. For someone who prefers a firmer textured handle and values the Mercer documentation, M18370 is a reasonable alternative. A kitchen that rarely portions dough may gain more from a flexible scraper first. There is no universal winner based on an unmeasured claim about speed, release or longevity.
The linked Amazon listings identify OXO 73281 as B00004OCNJ and Mercer M18370 as B00DT1XDXS. Match those model numbers and the single-tool configuration rather than choosing from the color alone. Review the selected listing and current purchase terms before ordering. This is a documentation-based comparison, not a hands-on test or a summary of Amazon customer reviews.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on October 26, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.