Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Garden & Outdoor Comparisons · Reviewed October 31, 2026

ProPlugger vs Garden Weasel Bulb Planters: Which Hole Fits Your Bulbs?

Choose the ProPlugger P246XL for small bulbs that fit its 2⅛-inch hole and need the same planting depth across a bed. Choose the Garden Weasel 91350 when you want its wider, nominal 3¾-inch opening in a single cut. Both are foot-operated tools. The difference starts below the footplate, not at the handle.

Best for

Gardeners adding individual bulbs to an established bed or lawn who want to cut planting holes from a standing position and know the size and depth their bulbs need.

Probably not for

Digging a continuous trench, planting an entire new bed that needs loosening, or working through a mat of established roots. Neither planter is a substitute for choosing a suitable site.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
What changes in the gardenProPlugger P246XLGarden Weasel 91350
Published planting-hole width2⅛ inches3¾ inches, nominal
Depth reference2- and 4-inch rings; 6 inches with no ring6-inch pointed tube; operator selects depth
After lifting the toolCores stack inside the shaftThe next cut pushes out the previous core
Where the soil goesInvert the tool over your chosen spotRetrieve the ejected core from beside the tube
For a bulb wider than one cutMaker illustrates adjacent cuts to enlarge the holeStart with a wider hole; still check clearance
ConstructionWelded carbon steelCarbon steel, T-bar grip and footplate

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

ProPlugger 5-in-1 Planting Tool P246XL

A narrow, hollow planter for making a series of bulb holes before emptying the soil. Use a depth ring when the planting directions match one of its two stops.

Pros

  • The narrower opening removes less surface area per hole
  • Defined depth settings suit repeated holes at the same depth
  • Collected soil can be emptied directly into a tub for backfilling

Cons

  • A bulb close to or beyond the tube width may need a wider opening
  • The shaft has to be emptied before you can use its soil for backfill
  • There is no separate ring for every intermediate depth

Who it’s for: Choose it for a run of small bulbs at one depth, particularly if you want to keep soil off the lawn. Skip it if most holes would need a second adjacent cut.

Check ProPlugger 5-in-1 Planting Tool P246XL on Amazon

Garden Weasel Long Handle Bulb Planter 91350

A footplate and pointed cutting tube make a wider opening. The tube carries a core off the ground; cutting the next hole displaces it so you can put it back over the preceding planting.

Pros

  • A wider first cut allows more clearance around a broad bulb
  • Previous cores become available individually as you work
  • A T-bar provides two hand positions above the footplate

Cons

  • The larger circle removes more turf around a small bulb
  • The published tube length is not a set of depth stops
  • The final core needs a separate release step

Who it’s for: Choose it when a wider cut lets a bulb sit upright without shaving the sides of the hole, and when you plan to replace individual cores rather than collect loose soil.

Check Garden Weasel Long Handle Bulb Planter 91350 on Amazon

Trace the two holes before buying

Take two pieces of scrap paper and draw a circle 2⅛ inches across on one and 3¾ inches across on the other. Set the widest bulb from your packet on each circle with its base down. Does its widest part clear the line, or does it cover the line? Leave room to lower the bulb into the opening unforced. A point that fits through the circle says little about whether the bulb underneath it will fit.

For example, a bulb 2½ inches across cannot fit inside the nominal ProPlugger circle in one pass. It leaves more than an inch of total clearance across the Garden Weasel circle on paper. That is a reason to consider the larger planter, not a promise about the finished hole. Garden Weasel publishes the 3¾-inch figure for the opening; it is not a guarantee of clearance at every point down a hole in crumbly soil.

Check where the bottom of the bulb will sit

Width settles only half the question. If the bulb packet calls for a planting depth of four inches, Illinois Extension measures planting depth from the base of the bulb to the soil surface. A two-inch-tall bulb sitting on the bottom of a four-inch hole would therefore have two inches of cover over its tip, not four. If a supplier specifies an amount of cover instead, use that wording and allow for the height of the bulb.

For a row that calls for four-inch holes, fit the four-inch ProPlugger ring and measure the first empty hole with a ruler. The two-inch ring gives a shallower stop. Six inches is the full setting with no ring, not a third ring you need to find in the box. Garden Weasel specifies a six-inch tube, but tube length is not an instruction to push it all the way in. Measure a first hole, especially when working at an intermediate depth. For a packet calling for deeper holes than either tool describes, choose another method.

Decide what to do with the soil before making hole two

Picture a row of bulbs beside a pale gravel path. With the ProPlugger you can leave the removed soil inside the shaft for several cuts. Put a shallow tub on the bed side of the row and invert the planter over it when you want to empty it. The tub gives you one place to draw backfill from without having to pick loose soil out of gravel. On a lawn where you want to preserve individual pieces of turf, mixing all the cores in one tub may be less useful.

The Garden Weasel manual describes a different rhythm. Lift the first core, cut a second hole, then take the first core from the side of the tube. If you want each piece of sod back in its original spot, keep the second hole close enough to reach the first and return the pieces in order. After the last planting hole, the manual directs you to step on one side of the footplate and shake the tool to release the remaining core. You do not have to dig a spare hole just to finish the row.

A few broad bulbs in a bag of small ones

Sort a mixed bag into bulbs that fit your smaller circle and bulbs that do not. If only one or two are too wide, you may still prefer the ProPlugger. Its planting guide shows cutting neighboring holes to enlarge the opening. Check that the resulting floor gives the entire base a place to rest. A bulb wedged above the bottom will not end up at the depth you measured, even if the narrow holes alongside it are deep enough.

If every bulb in a drift would need that extra cut, the Garden Weasel makes a stronger case. Mark the planting centers at the spacing the supplier gives, then lay a paper circle over two adjacent marks. If your circles overlap substantially, cutting plugs one at a time may leave little intact soil between them. For a dense group in a new bed, opening one planting area and placing the bulbs to the planned spacing can make more sense than buying either planter.

Know when the bed calls for a different tool

At the first marked position, see whether you can lift a core and leave a usable opening. ProPlugger recommends moist soil and warns that dry or saturated ground can interfere with plugging. If a trial hole collapses as soon as you lift the tool, the depth ring is not the problem. Stop before repeating that result down the row. If the cutting edge meets a stone or a woody root, move the planting position or expose the obstruction with a hand tool rather than leaning harder on the crossbar.

For two bulbs tucked between established perennials, the hand-trowel comparison below is relevant: a trowel lets you open one side of an irregular gap and see what is there. If you still intend to place the bulbs or replace turf at ground level, the kneeling-pad guide can help you select a pad that fits the strip beside the planting area. A standing planter changes how you excavate; it does not require you to complete every other task from the same position.

The buying decision in one planting row

Imagine twenty small bulbs with a four-inch depth instruction and enough room between their centers to leave the surface intact. The ProPlugger offers a reason to own a dedicated tool here: one narrow cut, a matching depth stop and somewhere to keep the soil until you are ready to backfill. Now change only the bulbs, making them too wide for the small tube but comfortably inside the larger circle. The Garden Weasel becomes the better match even though its handle also looks much like a standing planter.

Choose on the basis of the bulbs you actually have, not the largest bulb either tool might accommodate with extra digging. If most plantings are single pots or an occasional replacement in a crowded border, your existing trowel may already do the whole job. The specifications here come from the manufacturers, and the retailer links identify the P246XL and 91350 specifically. This comparison does not establish which tool takes less effort in your soil or which will finish a row sooner.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on October 31, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.