Lawn & Garden Comparisons · Reviewed November 9, 2026
Reotemp Compost Thermometers: 20-Inch vs 36-Inch
If you can reach the middle of the pile with a 20-inch stem, the Reotemp FG20P leaves less metal sticking into the walkway. If you have a deep bay and must work from the front, the 36-inch A36PF-D43 gets you to material the shorter probe cannot sample. Both are analog thermometers; the longer one buys reach and a larger dial, not a different kind of measurement.
Best for
Home and community gardeners who turn batches of leaves and kitchen scraps and want to follow the heat inside the pile over time.
Probably not for
A countertop scrap-pail owner, a gardener content to let leaves break down slowly, or anyone needing automatic alerts or proof of a sanitation process.
Specifications at a glance
| Detail | Backyard FG20P | Heavy Duty A36PF-D43 |
|---|---|---|
| Stem length | 20 inches | 36 inches |
| Stem diameter | 1/4 inch | 5/16 inch |
| Dial diameter | 1.8 inches | 3 inches |
| Scale for the selected variant | 0 to 200°F, with activity bands | Dual scale: 0 to 200°F and -10 to 90°C |
| Reach in a 48-inch-deep bay, sampling horizontally from the front face | Stops 4 inches short of the midpoint | Reaches the midpoint with 12 inches of stem to spare |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Reotemp FG20P 20-inch Fahrenheit Backyard compost thermometer
A stainless steel probe with a sealed dial and three labeled activity zones. This is the 20-inch Fahrenheit version, not the shorter 16-inch stem or a Celsius variant.
Pros
- Shorter stem is easier to draw out straight between a bin and a wall.
- Labeled activity zones give a new composter a reference alongside the Fahrenheit reading.
Cons
- Cannot reach a spot 24 inches behind the face of a full bay.
- The 1.8-inch dial is the smaller target if several people want to read it together.
Who it’s for: Choose it for a modest bin you can approach from the top or sides and a log you keep in Fahrenheit.
Check Reotemp FG20P 20-inch Fahrenheit Backyard compost thermometer on Amazon Paid linkReotemp A36PF-D43 36-inch dual-scale Heavy Duty compost thermometer
The 36-inch member of the Heavy Duty family has a thicker stainless steel stem and a 3-inch dial. The D43 suffix identifies the Fahrenheit and Celsius face.
Pros
- Sixteen inches of extra reach lets you compare more depths from the open face of a large pile.
- Both units appear on one dial for a shared garden or classroom that uses different units.
Cons
- The three-foot stem needs a clear approach and somewhere to store it straight.
- Reading two scales is an extra opportunity to copy a number from the wrong ring.
Who it’s for: Choose it for deep bays, wider heaps or teaching plots where someone will use the extra reach or second scale.
Check Reotemp A36PF-D43 36-inch dual-scale Heavy Duty compost thermometer on Amazon Paid linkMeasure the path to the compost, not the height of the bin
Picture a wire cylinder three feet across, with compost right up to the wire and access on every side. Its center is about 18 inches from the side. If there is an opening in the mesh at a useful height, the FG20P can reach the middle without needing the whole stem. Now put the same amount of material into a tall solid bin with an opening only at the top. The distance that matters is from that opening to the part of the pile you want to sample. Knowing the bin capacity in gallons does not tell you that distance.
An open-front wooden bay makes the calculation easier. Suppose the filled bay is four feet deep and the face is vertical. Half that depth is 24 inches. Pushing the 20-inch probe all the way in from the front still leaves its tip four inches shy. A 36-inch probe reaches the same point without burying the dial in loose compost. If a removable side panel gives you a shorter route, measure that route too. Taking out one board may do more for access than buying 16 inches of extra probe.
With an empty bin, mark 20 and 36 inches on a garden cane and rehearse inserting it and drawing it back. Do not forget the space behind your elbow: a fence, low roof or second bin can make the longer stem awkward before its tip ever touches a leaf. If you are laying out several bays, the Stanley FatMax vs PowerLock tape measure guide is useful for measuring both the bay depth and the aisle you will work from.
A temperature belongs to a spot, not to the whole heap
A newly filled pile is rarely uniform. One forkful might be mostly chopped stems while the one beside it is damp grass mixed with leaves. Cornell recommends sampling several locations and depths and letting the needle settle each time. A warm reading in one pocket and a cooler one by the wall need not mean either reading is wrong. Write down where each one came from before deciding that something needs changing.
For a repeatable check, choose a landmark such as the second board up on the front of the bin. Pick an insertion depth that you can reproduce, note it, and compare that spot over time. Then deliberately try a different place. The first measurement tells you what changed at your regular station; the second tells you what your regular station may be missing. If only the longer thermometer can reach the deep station, do not interpret a higher reading there as evidence that the larger dial reads high.
For example, a gardener might record 110°F near the front and 130°F deeper in the pile on the same afternoon. A single entry of 120°F makes the notebook look tidy but loses the useful part: two parts of this batch are behaving differently. Keep the readings separate. For a book that stays by the compost bay, the Rite in the Rain 135 vs 146 field notebook comparison weighs pocket size against room for columns. Date, position, temperature and the last thing you did to the pile are enough to start.
Choose a dial the next person can read
The Backyard face pairs Fahrenheit numbers with the words Steady, Active and Hot. That makes a useful introduction if you have never watched a newly mixed batch warm up. Still, copy down the number as well as the band. A change within one band may be exactly what you want to see after a turn; two entries that both say “Active” erase that detail. The bands describe what the thermometer senses, not instructions to add water, turn the pile or harvest compost.
At a community garden, decide which unit goes at the top of the record sheet. The A36PF-D43 allows a volunteer who thinks in Celsius to read that scale directly, while another can work in Fahrenheit. If the next person sees a bare 55 in the book, there is a substantial difference between 55°F and 55°C. Put the unit beside each reading or use a preprinted column with a single unit. The larger face is a reason to consider this model for demonstrations even if both stems fit the pile.
When the needle falls, look inside before acting
A drop after a week of heat is a reason to investigate, not a diagnosis. Has the pile settled so far that your usual hole now puts the tip near the surface? Did someone add a wheelbarrow of dry leaves or turn the bay yesterday? Compare a second spot, then look at the material itself. Dry leaves that barely cling to each other and a dense, sodden mat can both accompany a disappointing number. Watering both piles because both needles fell would make little sense.
For a dry mix, the EPA advises adding moisture and turning; for a wet, smelly mix, incorporate dry browns and air as you turn it. Note what you actually changed and return to the same sampling spots. A batch that warms again after turning has told you something different from one that stays near outdoor temperature and no longer contains recognizable food scraps. There is no feature on either dial that distinguishes those cases without your observations.
Nor is a cool Tuesday reading enough to send a batch straight to the vegetable bed. The EPA recommends a curing period of at least four weeks once the material stops reheating after mixing and food scraps are no longer visible. Keep fresh additions in a separate batch while the first one cures. Otherwise the date in your notebook refers to older compost at the bottom and yesterday’s peelings on top, which makes it hard to say what is ready.
The last check: can you withdraw and store it straight?
A small tumbler can be deep enough for either stem yet have a door that accepts the probe at only one angle. Try that angle with the tumbler stationary. If the tip would meet the opposite wall after twelve inches, feeding more steel through the opening will not improve the reading. Remove the probe before rotating the drum or turning a heap with a fork. Neither the thickness of the Heavy Duty stem nor the shorter length of the Backyard makes it a suitable stirring tool.
For one accessible bin, the FG20P is the simpler fit if you can see the face and reach the material you care about. For several deep bays sharing one aisle, the A36PF-D43 earns its place when you can name a sampling spot the shorter stem misses and have room to take the probe back out. For an unattended leaf pile that you are happy to leave for another season, you can reasonably skip both. Temperature is worth measuring when the answer will change something you do in the garden.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 9, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Reotemp: FG20P Backyard construction, activity zones and 20-inch stem
- Reotemp: Heavy Duty thermometer dial, available scales and stem lengths
- Reotemp model catalog: FG20P dimensions and A36PF stem with D43 dual-scale option
- Cornell Composting: how and where to measure pile temperatures
- US EPA: managing moisture and recognizing when backyard compost can start curing
- Amazon US: Reotemp FG20P, 20-inch Fahrenheit Backyard compost thermometer Paid link
- Amazon US: Reotemp A36PF-D43, 36-inch Fahrenheit and Celsius Heavy Duty compost thermometer Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.