Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Art & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 6, 2026

Sakura Koi 12 vs 24 Colors: Which Watercolor Sketch Kit?

Choose the 12-color Koi XNCW-12H for a smaller selection that encourages you to learn a few mixtures. Choose the 24-color XNCW-24N when more ready-made colors and a removable mixing palette would help your sketching. Both are student-grade half-pan watercolor kits with a refillable brush. The larger set changes the available colors and working layout; it is not a different professional paint grade or a guarantee of better pictures.

Best for

Sketchbook painters choosing a first portable pan set, or a small travel kit for paper illustrations, color studies and handwritten journals.

Probably not for

Large-area painting that needs a separate brush and water setup, an instructor-mandated pigment list, cosmetic use, or fabric projects that must survive washing.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Kit detailKoi XNCW-12HKoi XNCW-24N
Paint selection12 standard-color half pans24 standard-color half pans
Included water brush4 ml reservoir, medium tip9 ml reservoir, medium tip
Mixing surfaceDivided palette inside the lidRemovable mixing palette
Dabbing spongesOneTwo
Examples of additional colorsNo dedicated Quinacridone Rose, Burnt Umber or Payne’s Gray panIncludes Quinacridone Rose, Burnt Umber and Payne’s Gray
Paint familyStudent-grade Koi watercolor cakesStudent-grade Koi watercolor cakes
Compared packageOne standard 12-color kit with brushOne standard 24-color kit with brush, not CAC or an iridescent-medium bundle

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Sakura Koi XNCW-12H Pocket Field Sketch Kit, 12 colors with water brush

The 12-color kit suits someone who wants a contained palette for small sketches and is willing to mix intermediate colors. Its lid doubles as the mixing area, so there is no separate palette to position and put away. That simple layout is useful if you want to keep the paint box as one working unit. The tradeoff is fewer ready-made starting colors and a smaller water reservoir than the 24-color kit.

Pros

  • A limited selection gives you fewer pans to learn and label in a personal swatch chart
  • Lid palette keeps the mixing surface attached to the box

Cons

  • Fewer ready-made color choices when you want to move directly between distinct hues
  • 4 ml water supply needs more refill planning than the 9 ml brush, with actual use depending on technique

Who it’s for: Choose 12 for deliberate mixing practice and a small sketching routine. Skip it if the specific additional colors in the 24 set are already part of your usual palette.

Check Sakura Koi XNCW-12H Pocket Field Sketch Kit, 12 colors with water brush on Amazon

Sakura Koi XNCW-24N Pocket Field Sketch Kit, 24 colors with water brush

The 24-color box offers more starting points for a journal page that moves between flowers, buildings, food and lettering. Its removable palette separates the place you mix from the paint pans, and the included brush carries more water. Those are reasons to choose it even if you never use all 24 colors in one picture. They are not reasons to abandon mixing or assume the extra colors produce a wider range of successful results automatically.

Pros

  • More individual color choices before you begin making mixtures
  • Removable palette and two sponges offer more ways to organize the working area

Cons

  • More pans to map, keep distinct and learn rather than a substitute for color practice
  • Separate palette adds an item to reposition and account for when packing up

Who it’s for: Choose 24 when the additional hues or detachable workspace solve a specific inconvenience. Skip the expansion if a small familiar palette already covers the pictures you want to make.

Check Sakura Koi XNCW-24N Pocket Field Sketch Kit, 24 colors with water brush on Amazon

Decide whether you want to mix or select

The practical question is not how many colors a beginner deserves. It is where you want to spend attention while painting. A person making a small landscape study may enjoy finding several greens from a few starting colors. Someone recording a market stall might prefer to move quickly among separate patches of produce, signs and clothing. The 12 set favors getting to know a compact collection; the 24 provides more ready-made starting points. Neither approach prevents you from using the other.

The official color chart makes the difference concrete. The 24-color selection contains Quinacridone Rose, Ultramarine Deep, Burnt Umber and Payne’s Gray, while the 12-color selection does not have separate pans with those names. That can matter if you already reach for those colors in another kit. It does not establish that the smaller set can reproduce every one of them exactly, or that a familiar color name guarantees an identical pigment formulation across brands. Check a class materials list by its actual requirements, not by the total pan count.

A useful buying exercise is to describe the next three pictures you intend to paint. If each needs only a handful of related colors and you enjoy building mixtures, there is a clear case for 12. If they require many separate color accents and your frustration is repeatedly reconstructing the same starting mixtures, examine the 24-color chart. Buying extra pans because you can name their intended uses is more useful than assuming twice the selection doubles the value of every painting session.

The palette layout changes the workspace

Royal Talens lists a mixing area in the lid for the 12-color box and a removable palette for the 24. Think about that difference with the sketchbook open, rather than judging the closed box alone. Where will the book sit? Where can you put a damp brush? Which hand reaches toward the paint? A layout that works on a desk may be awkward on a narrow bench. The removable part offers another arrangement to consider, but it also needs a place to go.

For a left-handed painter, or anyone who dislikes reaching across the page, make a quick arrangement with an empty container before buying. Put it where the paint would sit and leave space where a mixing area would extend. You are checking your available space and reach, not simulating either product’s handling. If the only convenient mixing position is inside the open lid, the 12-color design is already consistent with that preference. If you want the mixing surface moved away from the pans, the 24 gives you that option.

Keep one portion of your mixing area available for a pale color instead of filling every space with dark mixtures at the start. More pans do not help if every brushful picks up an unintended neighboring color. When changing mixtures, use a clean area and check the brush on scrap paper. The extra sponge in the 24 can be assigned a separate role in your own setup, but two sponges are not evidence of cleaner results without a consistent routine.

Water capacity is not painting time

The compared kits include medium-tip water brushes, with a 4 ml reservoir in the 12-color kit and a 9 ml reservoir in the 24. The larger barrel carries more water, but there is no defensible conversion from those capacities to a fixed number of pictures. Rinsing between colors, wetting the paper, the scale of the drawing and how much water you release all affect consumption. A short page of small color accents and a broad background wash make very different demands.

Plan the trip around a place to refill or a separate supply of clean water. Also carry an absorbent wipe and a way to keep damp materials away from the finished pages. Do not leave the water plan until you discover that a sketching location has nowhere suitable to rinse or refill. If the planned picture involves large, continuous areas of wash, consider whether a conventional brush and a water container would be more appropriate than relying on the included travel brush alone.

Sakura describes a brush that separates into a tip section and a water-carrying barrel. Follow the supplied assembly directions and practise releasing water onto a scrap before using the first painted page. You do not need to buy a second brush just because this is a new set. If you later identify a separate need for a smaller tip, the Pentel Aquash Small vs Medium guide covers that brush-size decision. It is an optional tool comparison, not a missing component in either Koi kit.

Learn the paints on the paper you will use

Before an outing, make a small labeled swatch map in the same order as the pans. Leave enough room beside each color to add a more diluted sample. The map gives you a reference that belongs to your own paper and water handling, instead of relying on a screen image or the dry paint’s appearance. Keep it with the kit. If a color looks similar to another in the box, the label helps prevent a mistaken selection when you return to the set after a break.

Then try only a few two-color mixtures that relate to your next subject. A full grid of every possible pairing can become a separate project, especially with 24 colors. You can instead record one useful green, one neutral and one warm mixture, including which pans you used. Leave the samples to dry before judging whether you would use them in the picture. This is a personal familiarization exercise, not a claim that either kit has passed a comparative performance test.

Paper is an independent choice. A larger paint selection cannot make an unsuitable journal page tolerate the wet technique you have in mind. If you already own watercolor paper, use it first and keep that surface consistent while learning the set. The Arches Cold Press vs Hot Press block comparison explains textured and smoother paper options for a separate purchase. Neither block is required simply to make these kits usable, and changing both paper and paint at once makes your own observations harder to interpret.

Check the standard-color kit before ordering

Koi is a family name, not an exact package description. This comparison covers XNCW-12H and XNCW-24N standard-color half-pan sets with brushes. Sakura also offers Creative Art Colors versions with metallic, fluorescent and pearlescent effects, as well as tubes, brush pens and larger studio sets. A listing that says 12 or 24 colors is not sufficient by itself. Read the model, the paint format and the pictured contents together before assuming the selection matches this guide.

The linked 12-color Amazon listing describes 12 half-pan cakes and a medium-tip 4 ml water brush. The linked 24-color listing identifies XNCW-24N and a medium-tip 9 ml brush. Amazon variation controls can show other counts or bundles on the same product family page, so confirm the selected option before adding it to the cart. A package with an additional iridescent medium is a different bundle; this guide does not treat that extra medium as included with the standard 24-color selection.

Choose 12 if your priority is a manageable set of colors and a lid-based workspace. Choose 24 if its named additional hues, removable palette or larger water supply address a need you can describe. Choose neither if a class requires a different pigment selection or your planned work needs a substantially different painting setup. Sakura specifically does not recommend these paints for washable fabric projects and has not evaluated them for cosmetic use. Keeping the purchase tied to paper-based work and an actual painting routine is more useful than choosing a universal winner by color count.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 6, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.