Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Music & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 3, 2026

Shure SM58-LC vs SM58S: Who Should Control the Mic?

The Shure SM58-LC has no switch on its handle. The SM58S does. For an open mic where an engineer introduces one act after another, choose the LC and let the engineer open the channel. For a dance caller who runs the music and steps away from the mixer to demonstrate a move, the S puts a useful control in reach. Neither choice changes the pickup pattern or puts a cable in the box.

Best for

A singer, caller or venue buying a handheld wired microphone to plug into a PA with a microphone input, especially when deciding who will mute speech between cues.

Probably not for

A presenter who needs to walk cable-free among tables, an instructor who needs both hands free away from a stand, or someone looking for a direct USB connection.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Decision pointSM58-LCSM58S
Control on the handleNo on/off switchOn/off switch
Transducer and patternMoving-coil dynamic, cardioidMoving-coil dynamic, cardioid
Shure frequency response50 Hz to 15 kHz50 Hz to 15 kHz
Connection at microphoneThree-pin male XLRThree-pin male XLR
Included accessoriesA25D stand adapter and bagA25D stand adapter and bag
XLR cable in this packageNoNo

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Shure SM58-LC wired vocal microphone, no cable

The LC leaves the person at the mixer in charge of the channel. An emcee can pass the mic straight to a guest without explaining a switch. That is valuable at a showcase where a different person picks it up for every song and the engineer can see the stage.

Pros

  • No handle switch for a guest to leave off before the next introduction
  • Works well when one operator manages all the stage cues

Cons

  • No local off control for a presenter working alone
  • Setting the mic down does not silence an open channel

Who it’s for: Choose the LC for a staffed stage or for a permanent mic at a lectern with someone watching the mixer. Do not choose it expecting to mute a private aside with your thumb.

Check Shure SM58-LC wired vocal microphone, no cable on Amazon

Shure SM58S wired vocal microphone with on/off switch, no cable

The S lets the person holding the mic stop its signal without walking back to the sound system. A caller can let the backing track continue on another channel while giving a nearby dancer an instruction. Switching the microphone back on restores that source, provided its mixer channel is still open.

Pros

  • Performer can shut off this microphone without muting accompanying music
  • Useful when one person runs a class or a small event without a sound operator

Cons

  • An off switch at the handle can defeat an otherwise correct mixer cue
  • Does not turn the music down, set the vocal level or mute any other mic

Who it’s for: Choose the S when the same person will use and check the switch. For a pass-around audience mic, decide first whether every questioner really needs that control.

Check Shure SM58S wired vocal microphone with on/off switch, no cable on Amazon

Walk through the first and last words of a handoff

Picture a two-person introduction. The host finishes with “Please welcome Maya,” hands over the mic and steps aside. With the LC, the engineer can keep the channel open through the exchange so Maya can start with “Thank you.” With the S, a well-meaning host can switch off at the end of the introduction. The engineer’s channel is open, Maya starts speaking, and her opening words go nowhere. The switch is doing its job; the host and engineer just had different ideas about whose job it was.

Now reverse the scene. A caller runs an evening dance with a music player on one input and the mic on another. Between dances, she leaves the music playing and walks across the floor with the wired mic to explain a step to one pair. For that pause, turning off only the mic from her hand is exactly right. Lowering the PA’s master level would take the music away from everyone. If she always stays beside the mixer, though, the channel mute may already do everything she needs.

A switch at the mic is not a switch at the desk

Draw the signal path on a scrap of paper: talker, mic, cable, mixer, then the feeds out of the mixer. The S switch is before those feeds. In a room where the same mic supplies the audience speakers and a recording, turning it off at the handle removes the voice from both. That is useful when the presenter intends a break in both places. It is the wrong tool if the room should be silent but a remote audience still needs to hear the speaker. Have the operator control the destinations separately on equipment that permits it.

For a panel with a moderator, write down one rule before doors open. It could be “Leave the handle on; I will mute it between questions,” or “The moderator checks the switch before each handoff.” Try the rule once from the last row, where a question is likely to come from. If the operator cannot see a person’s hand on the switch there, the LC removes that particular uncertainty. Neither mic can tell the audience where to begin a question; a nod from the moderator is still useful.

Check the cable run before ordering the mic

Both selections end in a male XLR connector. For a mixer with a conventional XLR mic input, the female end of an XLR microphone cable goes on the mic and the male end plugs into the mixer. The supplied A25D is the clip that holds the microphone on a stand. It is not the stand, cable or a converter for a laptop. Shure lists the cable-equipped SM58-CN separately; its contents are not a packing list for either model here.

Trace the cable from the position where someone will actually speak to the equipment, following the route around the performance area instead of measuring a straight line through it. An existing cable that reaches the lectern might not reach a singer standing beside the piano. If the plan depends on working the whole audience without a cable run, look at a wireless system rather than debating the handle switch. These are the wired handhelds, not a wireless transmitter and receiver.

For a hybrid rehearsal, decide how you will get that analog mic signal into the computer. If the mixer already sends the required audio to the laptop, you may have the connection you need. Otherwise the Scarlett Solo vs AudioBox GO interface guide explains two separate XLR-to-computer setups. For a desk used only for computer audio, compare the Blue Yeti and ATR2500x USB microphones before buying a stage mic and a separate interface.

Set the speaking position, then check the mute

For sound check, ask the first speaker to say the first sentence of the introduction at the level they expect to use. Aim the grille at their mouth. With a cardioid mic, the direction it faces matters: point the front toward the voice and away from loudspeakers. Have the speaker turn to look at the projection screen and repeat the sentence. If the second version falls away because their mouth is no longer aimed into the mic, move the stand or coach the turn. Swapping the LC for the S would not change that geometry.

Run a second check with the accompanying music playing. Pause this mic by the method you plan to use during the show, then bring it back for the next sentence. Did the track stay on? Did the speaker’s first word reach both the room and any recording you meant to keep? If a switched mic goes silent unexpectedly, check the handle position and the correct channel’s mute before turning up gain. Extra gain does nothing for a mic that is off and leaves the level in the wrong place when it comes back. The right version is the one whose control you can find, and whose state the next person will understand, at that moment.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 3, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.