Art & Craft Comparisons · Reviewed November 5, 2026
Speedball Water-Soluble vs Fabric Block Printing Ink
You can print the same carved bird on a greeting card and a cotton tea towel. Only one of those birds is headed for the washing machine. Speedball’s Water-Soluble black is the paper ink; its Fabric black is the one to choose for a washable textile. Both come in a 2.5 fl oz tube, and both wash off your tools with soap and water. What separates them is what water does to the finished print.
Best for
Someone choosing black ink for a carved stamp or relief block, with a particular paper or textile project in mind.
Probably not for
A screen-printing setup, a finished fabric item that must be washed tomorrow, or a paper edition that specifically requires archival ink.
Specifications at a glance
| What to check | Water-Soluble black | Fabric black |
|---|---|---|
| Selected tube | 003500; 2.5 fl oz / 75 mL | 003570; 2.5 fl oz / 75 mL |
| Recommended surface | Paper | Fabric |
| Ink type | Water-soluble; non-permanent | Oil-based; water-washable during cleanup |
| Water after printing | Can move the printed ink | Wait a full week before wetting or washing |
| Heat setting for washable fabric | Not a washfast textile formula | Not required |
| Block and brayer cleanup | Soap and water | Soap and water |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Speedball Water-Soluble Block Printing Ink, black, 2.5 fl oz (003500)
Choose this tube for a run of bookplates, folded cards or proofs on paper. Speedball describes a satin finish and recommends the line for paper relief prints. The limitation matters even on paper: a design that will stay dry is a better match than a black outline you intend to brush over with a wet watercolor wash.
Pros
- Suited to printing from a linoleum, wood or compatible soft block onto paper
- A paper print run and its cleanup do not require a solvent station
Cons
- The dried print remains sensitive to water
- The paper formula is not the choice for laundry or an archival-ink specification
Who it’s for: Buy 003500 for the dry paper project on your table. Pass if water resistance is part of the design, even when the print itself will never enter a washing machine.
Check Speedball Water-Soluble Block Printing Ink, black, 2.5 fl oz (003500) on Amazon Paid linkSpeedball Fabric Block Printing Ink, black, 2.5 fl oz (003570)
This is a water-washable oil ink intended to leave a permanent print on fabric after curing. It suits a hand-stamped bandana or a repeated border on a tea towel without an ironing step to set the image. Allow for the first wash when planning the job; losing the heat-setting step does not mean losing the wait.
Pros
- Made for a textile print that needs to survive laundering after the cure
- No iron or heat press needed to set the design
Cons
- Requires a full week before washing or wetting the printed cloth
- A textile ink designation does not establish archival suitability for paper
Who it’s for: Buy 003570 for the cloth itself, not simply because the tube says permanent. If your only task is proofing a carving on dry paper, that textile capability solves a different problem.
Check Speedball Fabric Block Printing Ink, black, 2.5 fl oz (003570) on Amazon Paid linkStart with what will touch the finished print
A stack of place cards for a dinner party and a set of cloth napkins could carry the same monogram. For the cards, the Water-Soluble black is a straightforward choice. Print a spare on the same stock, fold it, and decide whether you like the black against the paper. For the napkins, the important question comes after dinner: can the owner put them in the wash? Start with Fabric black and build the cure into the schedule.
The boundary is not quite “anything made of paper.” Suppose the black lines are the first layer of an illustration and the next layer is watercolor. Speedball identifies the Water-Soluble line as non-permanent: water can cause the image to bleed or shift after printing. If crisp, undisturbed lines are essential, do not choose that tube on the strength of the word paper alone. For work that specifically calls for a permanent, archival relief ink on paper, look at Speedball’s separately labeled Professional Relief line.
Likewise, the word fabric is only half a label. Both tubes here are for block printing: the raised parts of a carved surface carry ink to the sheet or cloth. If the instructions for your design call for pushing ink through a mesh screen with a squeegee, buy from the ink line specified for that process. A black fabric screen-printing ink and this black fabric block-printing ink are not two names for the same purchase.
Read the towel’s calendar backward
A towel that has to be washed before it is given away needs a printing date at least a full week before that wash. Speedball puts touch-dry time at roughly 12 to 24 hours and separately recommends a week before the printed piece gets wet. The first milestone means the surface may feel dry; it is not the date to rinse a sample in the sink. Put the earliest wash date on a paper tag beside the drying pieces.
For a Saturday workshop, think about what participants expect to take home. If they can keep a stamped bandana dry for the week, the Fabric ink offers a project without a heat station. Give each participant the first-wash date along with the bandana. If the requirement is a fully laundered item the next morning, neither of these tubes meets that timetable. Switching to the paper ink or improvising with a hot iron is not a substitute for the maker’s cure guidance.
Speedball recommends prewashing the cloth before printing. If you are making a set, prewash an extra scrap of the same fabric with it. Print that scrap and the finished pieces on the same day. Keep the scrap for a wash check after the full week, observing the fabric’s own care instructions. A scrap can answer questions specific to your cloth and method without making the first wash of a completed gift your only reference.
Use the first impression to answer the right question
Before inking a whole run, make a paper proof: one impression pulled to inspect the carving. It can tell you whether a letter reads backward, a border is missing a corner, or a stray ridge prints where you wanted bare space. Speedball’s fabric-stamp project even uses a paper impression before printing cloth. If you already own the Fabric tube for a bandana, you need not buy the paper formula just to inspect the direction of the lettering.
That paper proof does not show how a fine mark will look across the weave. Put the ink intended for the finished piece onto the same type of cloth and examine that impression too. Speedball’s bandana instructions use several thin layers on the block. Try that approach on the scrap before changing the carving. If the stamp itself is still an open decision, the Speedy-Carve vs Speedy-Cut Easy block guide explains why the block’s own ink specifications matter.
A small stamp for a corner and a large repeating panel may also call for different rollers. The 2-inch vs 4-inch soft rubber brayer guide helps choose the roller width for the area you are inking. Keep that decision separate from the formula: changing the roller can change where ink goes on a stamp, but it cannot make the Water-Soluble print suitable for the laundry.
Keep two black inks straight at the worktable
At a shared table, label the inking surfaces “cards” and “towels” before squeezing out two similar-looking portions of black. Speedball recommends mixing colors within an ink line, not across the Water-Soluble and Fabric lines. Save the textile scrap as a reference and do not top up the Fabric roller with the last dab from the paper station. If there is only one roller, finish one job and clean the roller before starting the other.
Soap and water are for cleaning the tools; they are not an instruction to thin either tube with water. Speedball advises using a modifier intended for the ink if its working properties need adjustment. When you reorder, copy the part number as well as the color from the tube. Black 003500 gets you back to the 75 mL paper ink; black 003570 gets you back to the same-sized Fabric ink, with the same week to plan before washing.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 5, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Speedball block printing catalog: black tube sizes and codes, recommended surfaces, permanence and ink terminology
- Speedball Water-Soluble Block Printing Inks: intended materials, finish and cleanup
- Speedball Fabric Block Printing Inks: prewash, touch-dry interval, first wash, cleanup and mixing guidance
- Speedball bandana project: proofing on paper, inking a carved stamp and transferring the image to fabric
- Amazon US: Speedball Water-Soluble black, manufacturer part 3500, one 2.5 fl oz tube Paid link
- Amazon US: Speedball Fabric black, manufacturer part 003570, one 2.5 fl oz tube Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.