Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Workshop Tool Comparisons · Reviewed November 10, 2026

Starrett 505P-7 vs 505A-12: Which Miter Protractor?

Buy the 7-inch 505P-7 if your baseboard turns into short recesses or stops near door casing. Choose the 12-inch 505A-12 if you have open wall on both sides and want to see how a longer piece of straight trim will sit. Both give a miter saw setting for two matching pieces or for a single end cut. The useful difference is where their arms can rest, not how much arithmetic they save.

Best for

Fitting straight molding to real inside and outside corners, including corners that are close to square but open a visible gap with a pair of stock 45-degree cuts.

Probably not for

Copying the curved outline of existing trim, measuring the length of a wall run, or reading a blade tilt relative to a saw table.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
What you take to the cornerStarrett 505P-7Starrett 505A-12
Model size and material7 inches, hardened plastic12 inches, aluminum
ReadoutMechanical dialMechanical dial
Matching cuts on two piecesMiter Cut scaleMiter Cut scale
One piece meeting another surfaceSingle Cut scaleSingle Cut scale
Practical fitNarrow legs for short returns and tight spacesLonger legs for an open span on each side

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Starrett ProSite 505P-7, 7-inch narrow plastic miter protractor

The shorter mechanical model gives separate saw readings for a two-piece miter and an end cut on one piece. Its narrow plastic legs are the reason to choose it for a crowded corner.

Pros

  • Less arm to maneuver between a wall corner and an obstruction
  • Provides both saw-setting scales in a compact tool

Cons

  • Shows less of the adjacent wall than the 12-inch version
  • Can register on a local lump even if the full molding bridges past it

Who it’s for: Choose it for returns beside casings, shallow recesses, and jobs where only a short portion of each wall is exposed.

Check Starrett ProSite 505P-7, 7-inch narrow plastic miter protractor on Amazon

Starrett ProSite 505A-12, 12-inch aluminum miter protractor

The 12-inch aluminum dial model registers farther along both faces of an open corner. Use the extra reach to compare the angle at the corner with the direction the molding actually runs.

Pros

  • Longer contact edges make a change in wall direction easier to spot
  • Reads the paired miter or single end cut directly without batteries

Cons

  • The legs can hit casing or a cabinet before both edges seat
  • A distant high spot can tip an arm away from the face you intend to measure

Who it’s for: Choose it for open rooms, long baseboard runs and wide panels where both arms can lie in the same plane against straight faces.

Check Starrett ProSite 505A-12, 12-inch aluminum miter protractor on Amazon

Try two strips of cardboard before choosing a size

Look for the least accessible joint in the room, not the longest wall. In an alcove with a nine-inch return to a projecting door casing, a twelve-inch arm might touch the casing before it settles against the wall. It will still give a number. What it has measured, though, is a line from the corner to the proud face of the casing. The shorter Starrett has a better chance of touching only the surface the baseboard will follow.

To check, cut two straight strips of card the length of the model you are considering. Hold their ends together at the corner and swing the strips flat against each wall at trim height. Leave some space for the pivot: the paper is a reach check, not a full-size model of the tool. Try both lengths on an outside corner too. A cabinet toe kick or a radiator can interrupt the swing on one side even when the opposite wall looks completely clear.

On two long, bare walls, the same exercise can favor the twelve-inch tool. A short strip may follow a small patch of joint compound right beside the corner. A longer strip may rock on the edge of that same patch, leaving daylight between the strip and the wall farther along. Lay your actual molding offcut against the wall and see which contact points it uses. That tells you which measurement matters here; it does not establish that a longer protractor is inherently more accurate.

Read the joint you are cutting, not the angle you remember

For a picture frame, two pieces turn the corner together. For a shelf rail that butts into a side wall, only the rail gets an angled end. Those are different jobs even if the outline looks identical on paper. On either Starrett, follow the Miter Cut arrow when both pieces share the turn. Use the Single Cut arrow when one uncut face is staying put and the end of a single piece must meet it. Read the scale named by that arrow.

A known square corner makes the distinction easy to remember. Two equal miters at that corner call for 45 degrees on the saw; the end of a rail that butts squarely against the wall calls for a square crosscut, or zero on a conventional miter saw. You can check this at the bench against a combination square before trying to read a dial down near the floor. If your square butt joint appears to call for 45, look at the other arrow.

For a less obvious case, sketch an inside corner that opens to 92 degrees. Two pieces of upright baseboard sharing that turn would each need a 44-degree saw setting, not 46. The saw starts at zero for a square crosscut, not at 90. The point of the Miter Cut scale is that it already accounts for this: do not subtract its reading from 90 or divide it by two again. Write down the number with the words “paired miter” so the next person knows what it represents.

Mark both pieces while you can still see the corner

Stand facing an outside corner and trace the two wall runs as an L on a piece of tape. Add a dot on the room side of the L and label the left and right pieces. The long point of an outside miter is on the exposed face. On an inside miter the long point is toward the wall. The number on the dial can be perfectly right while the long point ends up on the wrong side of the board. A sketch preserves the part that a number cannot.

Pick a consistent place to measure the length, such as the line along the back of the baseboard. On the sketch, show which end of that line is a short point and which is a long point. Mark the waste side on the wood before going to the saw. A face-to-face measurement copied to the back of thick molding shifts the joint along the wall; changing the saw angle to close that gap only spoils the good measurement you started with.

Not every awkward junction is an angle problem. Consider a baseboard ending against fluted trim: the two wall faces can be square, yet the straight end of the board cannot follow the hollows and ridges. If the job calls for reproducing that outline, a contour gauge for copying a molding profile answers a different question. Buying the longer Starrett cannot turn the outline of a curved surface into a single useful saw setting.

Use the dial differently for crown cut flat

With flat-backed baseboard standing upright as installed, the wall corner determines the table swing for a simple miter. Crown molding sits at a slope between wall and ceiling. If you lay it flat on a compound saw, the blade must tilt as well as swing. Measure up near the ceiling, at the height where the crown will touch the walls. A reading taken at baseboard height is not evidence that the corner is the same all the way up.

Starrett provides a crown guide for each of these models. The row you want in its conversion chart is the Miter Cut reading from the dial. Pick the column for the molding’s spring angle, the angle at which its back sits away from the wall when installed. For example, at a Miter Cut reading of 45, the chart for 38-degree crown gives a 31.8-degree miter and a 33.9-degree bevel. Crown with a 45-degree spring angle uses 35.3 and 30.0 degrees instead. The same corner has not changed; the stock has.

Identify the spring angle from the molding specification before using those columns. If the profile uses another angle, do not select the nearest column. Use settings for that profile and your chosen cutting method. Mark the edge that faces the ceiling and follow the saw and molding instructions for which face goes against the fence. Those details change between inside and outside corners. A pair of spare pieces from the actual profile makes a more useful check than a successful cut on a flat strip of wood.

Read the gap before changing the saw

Fit two sample pieces at the corner before cutting either finished length. Use stock long enough to support and clamp as your saw manual specifies. Back at the wall, let each piece take its installed position instead of pinching the joint closed between your fingers. A gap that opens from the front point toward the back suggests rechecking the wall reading and miter setting. A gap near the top with the bottom closed is a reason to check whether one piece is tipping forward or the cut face is out of square vertically.

If two readings of the corner disagree, mark where each arm touched, then repeat at the line the installed trim will occupy. This is where the buying decision pays off: the 505P-7 is useful when the relevant face ends before a long arm can sit against it; the 505A-12 is useful when you want the direction of a straight run beyond a lumpy corner. If your pieces meet cleanly with the square or bevel gauge you already have, there is no measurement here that obliges you to replace it.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 10, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.