Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Art & Craft Comparisons · Reviewed November 11, 2026

Strathmore 300 Bristol: Smooth or Vellum for Drawing?

Choose Smooth 342-9 for the clean spaces between fine ink lines. Choose Vellum 342-109 if you build shadows with graphite or colored pencil and want the sheet to pick up light strokes. The pads have the same weight, size and number of sheets; what changes is the texture beneath the point.

Best for

Illustrators choosing a 9 x 12 drawing pad for pen work, pencil shading or a finished picture that combines the two.

Probably not for

Transparent overlays, a book that stays bound for travel, or watercolor paintings that depend on soaking a sheet.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Pad detailSmooth 342-9Vellum 342-109
Sheet size9 x 12 inches9 x 12 inches
Paper weight100 lb Bristol / 270 gsm100 lb Bristol / 270 gsm
Format20 sheets, tape-bound along a 9-inch edge20 sheets, tape-bound along a 9-inch edge
SurfaceVery little toothFine texture that catches dry marks
Typical marksInk contours, hatching and fine mechanical-pencil linesLayered colored pencil, graphite shading and charcoal

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Strathmore 300 Series Bristol Smooth 342-9, 9 x 12 inches

A 20-sheet drawing pad with little texture beneath a pen point. The Smooth finish lends itself to narrow outlines and dark shapes whose edges need to stay distinct.

Pros

  • Little grain to interrupt tiny lettering or parallel ink lines
  • A useful surface for fine mechanical-pencil detail as well as ink

Cons

  • Less texture to pick up soft deposits of dry color
  • Not the obvious choice if a visible grain is part of the drawing

Who it’s for: A technical pen drawing, an inked comic panel or a diagram with small labels.

Check Strathmore 300 Series Bristol Smooth 342-9, 9 x 12 inches on Amazon

Strathmore 300 Series Bristol Vellum 342-109, 9 x 12 inches

The textured version of the same heavyweight pad. A pencil can skim the raised parts of the sheet or build a denser patch over several passes.

Pros

  • Tooth catches graphite and colored pencil even with a light touch
  • Grain can help describe surfaces such as stone, fur or fruit skins

Cons

  • Fine pen work may show more paper texture than intended
  • A very pale patch can read as flecks rather than a flat tint

Who it’s for: A pencil portrait, a shaded still life or an illustration where lines support areas of layered color.

Check Strathmore 300 Series Bristol Vellum 342-109, 9 x 12 inches on Amazon

What should the white space look like?

Imagine drawing a pear two ways. In the first drawing, curved rows of pen strokes describe the fruit. The narrow white gaps between strokes give the pear its shape; close a few gaps near the stem and the shadow turns black. In the second drawing, a yellow pencil barely touches the lit side, and layers of green and brown turn the form away from the light. Here you want the pencil to leave a little color without having to press. The pen drawing points toward Smooth; the shaded pear points toward Vellum. The subject has not changed, but the job of the paper has.

Tooth is simply the small-scale texture of the sheet. Smooth Bristol has very little of it. On Vellum, a light pass catches the high spots and leaves some paper showing between them. That is different from the stiffness you feel when you lift a sheet by one corner. Both of these pads contain 270 gsm Bristol. Buying Vellum does not get you a heavier sheet; buying Smooth does not get you more drawing space. If one surface feels like a poor match, a larger pad of the same surface will not change how your point meets it.

For a street map or inked panel, look at the smallest gap

Consider a hand-drawn map of a neighborhood. The building outlines can tolerate a wobble. The lettering inside a street name cannot tolerate as much: if the loop in a small lowercase e closes, the reader loses part of the word. Smooth is the better starting point here. Use the narrowest space in the design as your guide, not the broadest black area. A thick border may dominate the page visually, yet the little spaces inside the labels are what decide whether the map works at its finished size.

You can separate a pen-width problem from a surface problem before buying paper. Draw the troublesome label larger on a scrap, using the same pen. If the letters read well when larger, allow more room or choose a narrower point. If you like the line width and dislike the grain along its edges, Smooth is the more relevant change. The Sakura Micron 01 and 05 comparison covers the separate question of point size. A broad pen on the smoother sheet still lays down a broad line.

Do not rule out Smooth because your work begins in pencil. A fine mechanical pencil tracing a decorative border asks much the same thing of the page as a technical pen. There is no broad patch of tone to develop. On the other hand, if a comic panel is mostly smoky graphite with just a few ink accents, the word “comic” on your project brief is a poor reason to buy Smooth. Decide by the marks the reader will actually see.

For a pencil portrait, look at the middle values

The darkest pupil and the untouched glint in an eye are easy to spot. Between them sit all the quiet changes that make an eyelid turn. Vellum gives a light graphite stroke small high points to catch on. Start a shaded passage with loose, light strokes; return to just the darker part while leaving some of the first pass visible. The value builds in stages. This is where texture earns its place: it helps you place a middle gray without committing to a hard dark edge that you must later disguise.

Grain can be an advantage in one passage and an annoyance in the next. On the pear, the little points of paper showing through yellow can suggest skin. The same flecks might be unwelcome in a drawing of a polished enamel bowl. Decide whether those flecks will be visible at the distance the finished piece will be viewed. Hold the sample at arm’s length as well as close up. If the patch reads as an even light tone from across the table, there is little reason to work it harder just to hide every dot.

A colorless blender introduces another choice: whether to keep the evidence of individual strokes or merge them. Leave one small area alone before blending an adjoining patch. That gives you a reference when deciding if the darker, more unified area is actually closer to the subject. The guide to Prismacolor and Derwent blending tools separates blending from burnishing. Neither tool can put the original white gaps back once you have filled them, so save the brightest passages until you know how far you want to go.

When one drawing needs both pen and pencil

A recipe illustration can call for precise lettering, black outlines and colored fruit on the same sheet. Sketch a thumbnail at the intended proportions. If the lettering and contour carry the image and the pencil is just a blush along the edge of each apple, buy Smooth. A few light accents do not need to dictate the whole surface. If red, gold and green layers carry the image and the only ink is a short caption in generous letters, buy Vellum. You have room to make those letters larger if they need it.

For a closer call, make a small proof if you can obtain scraps of both finishes. Put the same four marks on each: the smallest letter, two parallel ink lines, one light pencil patch and a second patch shaded over the first. Use the actual pen and pencil for the job. Let the ink dry before passing your hand over it. Compare the results at the size people will see: a phone photograph reduced to a recipe-card layout tells you more about tiny lettering than zooming in on the original. Look for the failure that matters, not the sample that seems prettier in isolation.

When neither Bristol pad solves the problem

Vellum in this product name refers to the finish on heavyweight drawing paper. If you need to lay one drawing directly over another and see the lower lines, look for tracing paper or a specifically translucent drafting sheet. If your illustration starts with a large wet-on-wet sky, choose a watercolor paper suited to that process. The 100 lb number on the Bristol cover describes paper weight, not how long a wash will remain workable or how flat a sheet will stay after soaking.

Finally, check how the artwork will leave the studio. These pads are held together with tape along a short edge. They make sense for a set of separate finished illustrations; they are less convenient for a travel diary that you want to flip through as one bound object. When buying a replacement, match all three details on the pad: 300 Series Bristol, 9 x 12 inches and the finish. The near-identical numbers differ by a single extra digit: 342-9 for the clean ink map, 342-109 for the shaded pencil portrait.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 11, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.