Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Art & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 4, 2026

Tombow Fudenosuke 2-Pack vs 3-Pack: Do You Need Gray?

If your lettering class asks for a hard tip and a soft tip, the two-pack already has your supply list covered. The extra pen in the three-pack solves a different problem. Imagine lettering a name in black on a place card: do you want a gray shadow behind it, or do you simply want to make the black downstrokes wider? The shadow gives the extra pen a job. The wider stroke is something you can practice with either set.

Best for

Someone lettering small cards, drawing in black ink or learning to vary a brush stroke, who wants to know what the third pen actually adds.

Probably not for

A shopper looking for an assortment of bright colors, several shades of gray, refillable pens or a rigid nib that always makes the same width of line.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Inside the selected set62038 two-pack62039 three-pack
Single-ended pensBlack hard tip and black soft tipBlack hard tip and black soft tip
Additional penNoneTwin brush tip: one black end and one gray end
Bodies / writing ends2 / 23 / 4
Tip behaviorFlexible brush tips; pressure changes line widthFlexible brush tips; pressure changes line width
Ink and refillsWater-based pigment ink; non-refillableWater-based pigment ink; non-refillable

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Tombow Fudenosuke 62038 hard and soft tip two-pack

Both pens write in black. Their value as a pair is that you can letter the same word with the same ink color and feel the difference between the tips. It is also the more direct set for a class where everyone needs to bring these two specific brush types. Nothing in the box provides a gray accent or doubles as a gray sketching pen.

Pros

  • Both black tip options for a lettering assignment without an extra body
  • Makes it straightforward to compare pressure and letter shape in one ink color

Cons

  • No gray end for shadows or a second value in a drawing
  • One of each tip, not a pair of replacements for a favorite hard or soft brush

Who it’s for: Choose 62038 for black names, monograms or lettering drills. Pass if the sketch you intend to make calls for black outlines and a separate gray tone.

Check Tombow Fudenosuke 62038 hard and soft tip two-pack on Amazon

Tombow Fudenosuke 62039 hard, soft and twin tip three-pack

You still receive the two separate black pens. The third body carries an additional black brush at one end and gray at the other. That arrangement makes sense for a sketchbook: use black for outlines and gray for a fold in fabric or the side of a building. It does not turn the set into a palette of three different colors.

Pros

  • Adds a separate gray ink for shading without giving up either original black tip
  • Black and gray share one body if you only want to carry a two-tone sketching pen

Cons

  • No second dedicated hard-tip or soft-tip single pen
  • The gray and its companion black end cannot be used by two people at the same time

Who it’s for: Choose 62039 if you regularly assign gray a job on the page. Skip the larger set if the third pen would only sit in a drawer while you work through black practice sheets.

Check Tombow Fudenosuke 62039 hard, soft and twin tip three-pack on Amazon

Hard and soft describe the brush, not the color

With a pencil, the word “hard” can make you think of a lighter mark. Here it describes how the tip flexes. Both single-ended Fudenosukes have black ink and both can vary a line as you change pressure. The hard version is the firmer of the two; it is not a metal nib or a fixed-width fineliner. The soft one gives more readily. If small letters you intend to keep open are filling in, try the hard tip before abandoning the size of the lettering.

Draw two baselines on a smooth scrap and write the same short name twice at the size it will appear on the finished card. Use one pen for each line. Look at the white space inside the smallest e or a. Then look at the gap between two upright strokes. If the soft brush gives the broad stroke you like but closes that gap, spread the letters slightly or try a lighter touch. If you can already get the shape you want with one of those two tips, there is no reason to choose a bigger pack for the lettering alone.

A different purchase makes sense for a different assignment. For ruled diagrams or line art where the border should stay the same width as you turn a corner, a fixed nib avoids making pressure part of the design. The Sakura Pigma Micron 01 vs 05 guide compares two such line widths. Owning both Fudenosuke tip styles is not the same as owning two calibrated fineliners.

Give the gray end an actual task

Picture a sheet of handwritten recipe cards. A black title, a thin underline and the cook’s initials can all be done in one color. If the ingredients are crowded, adding gray flourishes will not give the list any more room. Now picture a sheet of botanical sketches: the leaf outline can stay black while a gray vein runs through the middle. Those little marks remain distinct without having to make the outline much heavier. That is a reason to carry the twin-tip pen even when most of the drawing is black.

For a shadowed name, sketch the letter first and choose the side from which the light is supposed to come. If it is the upper left, plan just the lower and right-hand edges that will get a gray offset. Leave enough space between letters for the shadow to read as part of the previous letter rather than as another stroke on the next one. Do a single sample at its final size. A shadow that looks attractive on a large practice sheet may use up the whole gap between two letters on a small tag.

There are limits to what that extra end buys. It gives you one gray ink, not several numbered grays for building an illustration. For black-only artwork that will be copied, make a sample copy of your gray test mark before committing to it. The question is whether the distinction you drew is still visible in the finished copy. If you want all marks equally dark there, black hatching or an open outline may serve the design better without another color.

Test the card stock before the invitation batch

Tombow recommends smooth paper for these brushes. Its examples include marker paper and tracing paper. A pretty sheet with a pronounced woven texture is a different writing surface, even when the color matches the sample in your sketchbook. Ask for an offcut or save a spare card from the order. Use that piece to try the finest line you need, then the heaviest stroke you expect to draw. Check the back as well as the front, especially if a guest will write a message on the other side.

For a place card, mock up the fold and write the longest name on your list, not the shortest. Stand it up across the table where a guest would see it. Can you read the name easily, and is the gray detail visible from that distance? If the name is too small, a larger writing area or one less flourish may solve more than switching pens. The Dahle 507 vs Vantage 50 paper trimmer comparison covers a separate decision if you plan to cut matching blanks for the entire table.

When practicing from a printed alphabet, put smooth tracing paper over the sheet rather than making the printer paper stand in for the final surface. This also lets you use the same example several times without printing more copies. Label the first line with the brush used, then change only the pressure or only the letter spacing on the next. Changing paper, tip and size all at once makes it hard to tell what helped.

Buying for a class, sharing a desk or replacing a pen

Count the people who need to do the same exercise simultaneously. Two classmates each assigned the hard tip cannot share one two-pack if they need to follow the instructor at the same time. The three-pack has more working ends, but it still only includes one of the dedicated hard-tip pens. Conversely, if one person is practicing with the soft tip while another sketches with the twin-tip pen, the three-pack can cover those different activities at once. Count bodies as well as ends when dividing supplies.

For a replacement, read the markings on the pen you actually used up. These are not refillable. If the hard tip is an everyday tool and the soft one is still sitting unopened, buying the same mixed set again duplicates the pen you did not need. If you already have both black pens and only want gray, Tombow also documents the twin-tip pen as a separate item. Check that option before ordering three pens for one missing end. For a first set, the shorter decision is still the best one: two brushes for black lettering, or the same two brushes plus a black-and-gray tool that has a place in a real project.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 4, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.