Kitchen Comparisons · Reviewed October 31, 2026
USA Pan 9 vs 13 Inch Pullman: Which Loaf Fits Your Lunch Plans?
The 13 inch Pullman makes a longer loaf, not a wider sandwich. Both USA Pan models give the dough the same four-inch width and height. Pick the 9 inch pan for a shorter run of matching slices; pick the 13 inch pan if you already bake a full-size pain de mie or want more slices from one bake.
Best for
Bakers who want straight-sided sandwich bread with a flat top and are choosing how much loaf to make at once.
Probably not for
Someone who wants a wider slice for a large filling, or who wants only a rounded farmhouse loaf and already owns a suitable open loaf pan.
Specifications at a glance
| What to compare | Small Pullman with cover | Large Pullman with cover |
|---|---|---|
| USA Pan item number | 1170PM-1 | 1160PM-1 |
| Baking surface, length x width x height | 9 x 4 x 4 inches | 13 x 4 x 4 inches |
| Overall length, not baking length | 10.5 inches | 14.5 inches |
| Construction and finish | Aluminized steel; Americoat silicone nonstick | Aluminized steel; Americoat silicone nonstick |
| What is in the linked package | One small pan and matching sliding cover | One large pan and matching sliding cover |
| Maximum oven temperature | 450°F | 450°F |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
USA Pan Small Pullman Loaf Pan with Cover, 9 x 4 x 4 inches (1170PM-1)
The small model buys you a shorter loaf without downsizing the face of the slice. That matters if you want the same square French toast you would get from a longer loaf but would rather bake again later in the week than find room for leftovers now. Its included lid slides on from one end.
Pros
- Matches a recipe written for a 9 inch covered Pullman
- Takes four fewer inches of shelf length than the large model
- Makes a shorter loaf without requiring smaller sandwich fillings
Cons
- Fewer center slices from a bake if you cut both loaves to the same thickness
- A full recipe intended for the 13 inch pan needs adjusting
Who it’s for: Choose this for the loaf you want to finish fresh. It is also the sensible match if your favorite recipe already names a 9 x 4 x 4 inch pan and you like its yield.
Check USA Pan Small Pullman Loaf Pan with Cover, 9 x 4 x 4 inches (1170PM-1) on Amazon Paid linkUSA Pan Large Pullman Loaf Pan with Cover, 13 x 4 x 4 inches (1160PM-1)
The large model adds length along the row of slices. For a platter of tea sandwiches, that means more pieces between the two heels, without having to match up slices from separate loaves. A recipe that only fills the small pan does not become a square 13 inch loaf just because the lid is on.
Pros
- Matches a traditional 13 inch pain de mie recipe
- Longer run of the same size slices for packed lunches or freezer portions
- Only two heels on the longer loaf
Cons
- Needs a clear 14.5 inches of length for the pan itself
- More bread to portion or store if your household uses just a few slices
Who it’s for: Choose this for a bigger batch you have a plan for: sandwiches for a group, toast for several mornings, or slices you will freeze in pairs. Do not choose it to make an individual sandwich wider.
Check USA Pan Large Pullman Loaf Pan with Cover, 13 x 4 x 4 inches (1160PM-1) on Amazon Paid linkCount sandwiches, not just inches
Think about the last loaf you bought. Did the heels go into the toaster before the weekend, or did you find half a loaf in the bread box after everyone had moved on to something else? The two pans answer that question differently. The small pan suits a baker who enjoys a fresh loaf on Sunday and another midweek. The long pan makes sense if Sunday is the only day you can bake and there is space to put the extra bread.
Here is a way to picture the difference. If your slices average half an inch thick, the extra four inches of nominal loaf length represent roughly eight extra slices, or four two-slice sandwiches. That is planning arithmetic, not a serving count: it assumes both loaves fill the pan, ignores shrinkage and depends on how you cut the ends. If four extra lunches would get eaten, the long pan earns its cupboard space. If you prefer thick toast, the extra inches will go faster.
Buy for the recipe on your counter
Look for all three pan dimensions and the word covered in the recipe. A nine-inch loaf pan might be an open 9 x 5 inch pan with sloping sides. Its dough can expand into a tall dome. A 9 x 4 x 4 inch Pullman offers a different footprint and puts a ceiling over the dough. Matching just the first dimension is not a good reason to close a lid over your usual open-pan recipe.
For a first bake, King Arthur Baking has a small pain de mie written for a 9 inch Pullman and a separate pain de mie written for the 13 inch pan. They are not merely two printings of one dough: the small recipe uses honey, while the longer one uses granulated sugar and includes potato flour. Start with the recipe for the pan you bought. Once you like the result, you have something specific to compare against when you try another dough.
How to scale a known Pullman recipe
For these two pans only, the nominal width and height match, so you can use the lengths to estimate a batch change. To make a 13 inch formula in the 9 inch pan, multiply every ingredient by 9/13, about 0.692. In the other direction, multiply by 13/9, about 1.444. The calculation assumes the original dough filled its covered pan appropriately, that you want the same fill proportion, and that you are keeping the same formula. It does not tell you how much of an unfamiliar dough belongs under a lid.
As a worked example, the 13 inch King Arthur recipe lists 570 grams of all-purpose flour. Multiplying 570 by 9/13 gives about 395 grams for the smaller test batch. Make the same calculation for the liquid, fat, salt, yeast and other ingredients in that recipe. Changing only the flour changes the dough itself. Write the column of new quantities before getting the bowl out. The OXO and Escali kitchen scale comparison below can help if a wide mixing bowl hides the display when you weigh ingredients.
Keep the ratio off the oven controls. Multiplying a bake time or a temperature by 0.692 has no basis here; you reduced length while keeping the distance from the side of the pan to the center the same. Use a size-matched recipe for timing guidance, and check the signs of doneness for the dough you made. Record how high it rose before the lid went on and how it looked when sliced. That is more useful for your next bake than a timer reading alone.
Practice with the lid while the pan is cold
Before mixing dough, slide the empty cover on and off. USA Pan says to lead with the curled edge and slide until the indentation seats. To open, face the curled edge toward you and slide it away from you once the pan is safe to handle. A trial on the counter shows which end needs clearance. Plan a heatproof spot for the lid as well as for the pan, and use dry oven mitts when following a recipe that calls for uncovering the bread during baking.
The lid sets an upper boundary; it cannot lift short dough into the corners. King Arthur’s small-pan recipe lets the shaped loaf rise to roughly half an inch below the rim before fitting the greased lid. Its large-pan recipe specifies a rise to just below the lip. Use the cue from your chosen recipe, not a universal fill line. If the dough has already risen into the path of the cover, do not force the cover through it. An open-top loaf is a better outcome than dragging the dough along the rails.
Check the shelf, the rack and the cutting board
The 9 and 13 inch figures describe the baking surface. The actual lengths are 10.5 and 14.5 inches respectively. For a small oven, measure usable rack space with the door shut and follow the oven maker’s clearance rules. A rack exactly as long as the pan is not a clearance allowance. USA Pan gives differing outer widths and heights in two places on its small-pan page; if a cabinet opening is a close fit in either direction, confirm those measurements before ordering.
Let the loaf cool on a rack before cutting. For a picnic, decide how thick the finished sandwiches should be and cut two adjacent slices at a time so the edges line up. Cut on a board, not in the coated pan. If you have the right loaf shape but the bread compresses as you cut it, the Tojiro and Mercer bread knife comparison below looks at a different purchase: a serrated blade for slicing a cooled loaf.
Keep the pan and cover together
The finish does not distinguish the models. Both are aluminized steel with a silicone nonstick coating, and USA Pan sets the same 450°F ceiling for each. Follow the recipe for greasing, including the underside of the lid if directed, and skip aerosol cooking spray. Wash both pieces by hand with mild soap and warm water. Use a soft sponge, clear any crumbs from the lid channel and dry everything thoroughly before putting the pair away. A metal knife is not a tool for scraping dough from the track.
When checking the order, look for the words pan with cover and the selected length. USA Pan identifies the small set as 1170PM-1 and the large as 1160PM-1; Amazon lists the corresponding model numbers without the final suffix. Buying either complete set solves the question of which lid fits. The remaining decision is simply whether those extra four inches of bread already have somewhere to go.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on October 31, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- USA Pan: small 1170PM-1 with cover, baking dimensions, overall length, cover operation and care
- USA Pan: large 1160PM-1 with cover, baking and outer dimensions, cover operation and care
- King Arthur Baking: A Smaller Pain de Mie, a recipe for a 9 inch covered pan
- King Arthur Baking: Pain de Mie, a 13 inch formula with ingredient weights and proofing guidance
- Amazon: 9 inch USA Pan Pullman with cover, model 1170PM, ASIN B001TO3CN8 Paid link
- Amazon: 13 inch USA Pan Pullman with cover, model 1160PM, ASIN B002UNMZPI Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.