Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Music & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 1, 2026

Vic Firth American Classic 5A vs 5B: Which Drumstick Size?

If you like the reach of a Vic Firth American Classic but want more wood under your fingers, try the 5B. If a thick stick feels cumbersome during quiet strokes, try the slimmer 5A. The 5B is 0.030 inch wider, not longer. Both of these natural-finish pairs have the same listed length, taper category and tip shape.

Best for

A drum-set player choosing a first wood-tip pair or changing handle diameter without switching to an extended-length stick.

Probably not for

A player shopping for brushes, a different tip material, extra reach or sticks specified for another percussion instrument.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Standard wood-tip pairsAmerican Classic 5AAmerican Classic 5B
Vic Firth SKU5A5B
Diameter0.565 inch0.595 inch
Length16 inches16 inches
Wood and finishHickory, lacquer finishHickory, lacquer finish
Taper categoryMediumMedium
Tip material and shapeWood, teardropWood, teardrop
Amazon selectionNatural wood tip, single packNatural wood tip, single pack

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Vic Firth American Classic 5A, natural wood tip, one pair

The 5A is the narrower option. Choose it because the diameter suits the way you hold a stick, not because you have to graduate from it after a certain number of lessons. A player who already likes this grip has a perfectly good reason to keep using the 5A when the music gets more demanding.

Pros

  • Slimmer shaft without a shorter playing length
  • A direct replacement for a familiar standard wood-tip 5A

Cons

  • Does not address a preference for a fuller handle
  • No change of tip shape or reach relative to the 5B

Who it’s for: A useful starting point if you have tried a loaner 5A and liked it, or if the standard 5B occupies more space in your hand than you want. Skip it if your director has asked for a particular different model.

Check Vic Firth American Classic 5A, natural wood tip, one pair on Amazon

Vic Firth American Classic 5B, natural wood tip, one pair

The 5B puts the extra diameter along the shaft. Someone happy with a 5A’s length but repeatedly wishing its handle filled their hand a little more has a concrete reason to choose it. Someone who cannot comfortably reach a cymbal does not: the manufacturer specifies the same 16 inches from end to end.

Pros

  • Fuller grip for players who find the 5A too slim
  • Retains the 5A’s familiar reach and wood-tip design

Cons

  • Greater diameter may be exactly what a light-touch player dislikes
  • Cannot fix a kit layout that puts a drum or cymbal too far away

Who it’s for: Choose it for a preferred hand feel, whether the music is quiet or loud. It is a poor substitute for a different beater when the score explicitly calls for brushes or mallets.

Check Vic Firth American Classic 5B, natural wood tip, one pair on Amazon

Read the stick you already own

Start with the printing on your current pair, or ask your teacher what you used at your last lesson. Write down the whole name. “Five A” does not tell a shop whether you used an American Classic, a different series, a painted finish or a nylon tip. If you are replacing a lost stick before rehearsal, matching the familiar pair is a different job from exploring a new size.

If the markings have worn away, compare the straight part of the shaft rather than measuring near the end that narrows into the tip. A pair of calipers can help distinguish a shaft close to 0.565 inch from one close to 0.595 inch. That measurement is a clue, not a product identification: diameter alone cannot tell you the wood, tip or series. Bring the remaining stick to your next lesson before ordering several pairs on a guess.

What the extra thirty thousandths means

Put the sticks side by side on a counter with the butt ends aligned. Do not look for a step up in height. The printed difference is across the shaft: about three quarters of a millimeter. Wrapped around a circular handle, that translates to about 2.4 millimeters more circumference on the 5B, calculated from the published diameters. Think of that as a change in the shape your fingers enclose, not as a published change in weight.

That distinction matters when a shop lists a shipping weight or a package dimension. Neither tells you exactly how a stick will feel in motion. Both designs use a medium taper, meaning the section that narrows toward the tip belongs to the same design category. It does not mean the two pairs must feel identical. If the thing you dislike is the slickness of lacquer rather than the size of the shaft, switching between these two sizes will not solve it.

Bring one groove and one troublesome bar

If you can borrow both sizes, use a surface and part you already know. For example, play an easy eighth-note hi-hat pattern with snare backbeats, then keep the pattern going while playing a quiet note between two backbeats. Pay attention to the return to the quiet note, not just the accent. Which handle would you rather hold for another verse? Start each run at the same comfortable tempo; this is a choice about playing, not a race.

Then play a fill you use in real music. Move from snare to tom and land on the next downbeat without adding a pause to rearrange your grip. A pair that feels appealing during a few forceful hits might not be the one you want during that transition. Note where you changed your hold and whether you wanted to. The related Korg and Seiko metronome guide can help if you want a steady pulse for repeating the passage.

A pad can answer only part of the question

A practice pad lets you compare the grips without moving anything around the kit. It cannot tell you what happens when you switch from tapping a closed hi-hat to playing the bow of a ride. When you get back to the drums, play the actual cymbal part before making that part of your decision. Use the same cymbal and striking area each time so that moving the target does not become the largest difference you hear.

At a shared rehearsal kit, set up the stand holding your chart before you begin. If you have to reach past it to get to a cymbal, correct that obstruction rather than blaming a stick that seems too short. The folding-wire versus solid-desk music stand guide covers the choice of chart support. You can settle where the chart belongs independently of which diameter feels better.

Buying a first pair, a spare or a different sound

For a first lesson, the most useful question may be “Which pair will I be using in the room?” Matching the instructor’s loaner gives home practice a familiar reference. For a spare, buy the same complete model as the working pair if the goal is to carry on without adapting mid-song. For an intentional change, keep the old pair together and the new pair together. One 5A in one hand and one 5B in the other will confuse a comparison of how the two complete pairs play.

Finally, separate a request for a different sound from a request for a different handle. If your arrangement calls for the sweep of brushes, neither of these wood tips supplies it. If it calls for your normal sticks and you simply want less wood in the grip, the 5A is the appropriate direction. If it calls for the same reach with more handle to hold, choose the 5B. Check that the listing still shows the standard natural wood-tip single pack rather than a multi-pack or nylon-tip version.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 1, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.