Music & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 2, 2026
Yamaha YRS-23 vs YRS-24B: Which Recorder for Your Class?
If the class list says German fingering, buy the YRS-23. If it says Baroque or English fingering, buy the YRS-24B. Both are beginner soprano recorders in C. The difference is what your fingers do to play certain notes, not which tunes you are allowed to play. Without a class requirement, the YRS-24B is a useful starting point for a learner who plans to play other sizes of recorder with Baroque fingering.
Best for
A family matching an elementary school instrument, a teacher sorting loaners, or an independent beginner choosing a first soprano recorder.
Probably not for
An alto recorder part, a request for a wooden instrument, or a player specifically looking for an arched windway.
Specifications at a glance
| What to check | Yamaha YRS-23 | Yamaha YRS-24B |
|---|---|---|
| Size and key | Soprano in C | Soprano in C |
| Fingering system | German | Baroque (English) |
| Fourth front hole, compared with fifth | Larger | Smaller |
| Body and windway | Three ABS resin sections; straight windway | Three ABS resin sections; straight windway |
| Lower toneholes | Double | Double |
| Yamaha-listed accessories | Cotton case and fingering chart | Cotton case and fingering chart |
| Amazon selection | Natural, one recorder | Natural, one recorder |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Yamaha YRS-23 soprano recorder, German fingering, Natural, one recorder
The YRS-23 makes sense for a student whose teacher demonstrates German fingerings. The right index finger alone takes care of the change from the first G down to F. A child can follow that demonstration at home with the same instrument, even if a different fingering turns up in an online lesson.
Pros
- Matches a German-system classroom or an existing YRS-23
- Low F follows the stepwise pattern of the basic scale
Cons
- A Baroque chart gives the wrong pattern for its low F
- Some sharps and flats have less straightforward fingerings
Who it’s for: Choose it as a home counterpart to a German school loaner. Pass if your music book specifically shows Baroque fingering and there is no teacher directing you to use the German version.
Check Yamaha YRS-23 soprano recorder, German fingering, Natural, one recorder on Amazon Paid linkYamaha YRS-24B soprano recorder, Baroque fingering, Natural, one recorder
The YRS-24B starts a player on Baroque fingering without requiring a more advanced instrument. Low F asks for fingers on either side of an open hole. That takes a little choreography at first, but it is the pattern you want to learn if your class, tutor or fingering chart uses it.
Pros
- Works with Baroque and English-system soprano materials
- A useful starting point for moving among Baroque recorder sizes
Cons
- Low F is not a simple one-finger addition to G
- An awkward match for lessons built around the YRS-23
Who it’s for: Choose it for a Baroque class, or for independent study with a Baroque soprano method. If you already own a YRS-23 and plan to switch, expect to revisit particular notes, not to start reading music from scratch.
Check Yamaha YRS-24B soprano recorder, Baroque fingering, Natural, one recorder on Amazon Paid linkWhat to ask when the school list just says “soprano”
Ask, “Which fingering do you demonstrate for F: German or Baroque?” That one question does more work than asking for a color or even a brand. If someone is ordering on your behalf, send the complete model number, including the B on YRS-24B. If the school lends instruments, a photo of the classroom model or a note from the teacher is more useful than a photo of its bag.
Suppose an older sibling has finished the same grade and left a recorder in a drawer. It could be exactly what you need, but the current teacher might use another method. Find the sibling’s model and compare it with this year’s requirement before buying a replacement. For two children in different programs, label each case with the player’s name and system so the right one goes to rehearsal.
How to identify a recorder with no box
Hold the recorder mouthpiece up, with the row of finger holes facing you. Count down the front from the first finger hole, skipping the rectangular opening near the mouthpiece. Compare holes four and five. On the German YRS-23, the fourth is larger than the fifth. On the Baroque YRS-24B, the fourth is smaller. Leave the thumb hole at the back out of the count.
This check identifies the system, not the exact model. Other recorders can share the same pattern. The little paired openings near the foot are no help in choosing between these two because both have them. If you are sorting several unmarked loaners, group them by the fourth and fifth holes before handing out charts. A chart borrowed from the next case is only useful if it matches the instrument.
Play one note on paper before you order
Find the lower F natural on Yamaha’s two soprano charts. On both models the left thumb covers the back hole and the first three left fingers cover the upper front holes. Now read the right hand. The German chart calls for the index finger down and the rest up. The Baroque chart calls for index, ring and little fingers down, with the middle finger up. That gap is what a teacher means by a forked fingering.
Try tracing G, F, E, F, G with a finger on the printed chart. The music is identical for either recorder; it is the traffic around F that changes. A student who has only played B, A and G may see no problem with a borrowed instrument at first. Before deciding that a troublesome F calls for harder blowing or another recorder, compare the cover pattern in the lesson with the chart for the model in hand.
When there is no teacher choosing for you
Start with the materials you actually want to use. If a tutor demonstrates Baroque fingering, buy the YRS-24B and follow along. “Baroque” is the name of the system here, not a restriction to old music. A folk tune that contains F natural still calls for the Baroque F pattern on this recorder. Nor does a tune written in German require a German-system instrument.
Yamaha points out that many recorders beyond the soprano use Baroque fingering and that some accidentals, the sharps and flats in a melody, are trickier on a German instrument. That favors the YRS-24B for a learner with a long-term interest in recorder ensembles. It does not make it an alto: a player assigned the alto part should check the required instrument and chart, not buy a Baroque soprano on the strength of that word alone.
Set up for the first lesson
Put the fingering chart beside the music instead of underneath it. That way you can check the F pattern without putting the recorder down to turn a page. A single loose sheet and a thick open method book make different demands on a stand; our guide to the two On-Stage music stands compares a folding wire rest with a solid desk for those setups.
Once the fingers know the route, take one troublesome change from a tune and give each note a whole beat. If you keep stopping at F to consult the chart, leave the metronome off for another pass. The Korg and Seiko metronome comparison is useful when you want a steady pulse for that exercise. The first purchase, though, is simply the recorder whose fingering agrees with the lesson.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 2, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Yamaha USA: model-by-model key, system, materials, body sections, toneholes, windway and accessories
- Yamaha USA: the 20 Series soprano models for beginners
- Yamaha: selecting German or Baroque fingering for scales, accidentals and other recorder sizes
- Yamaha: how to distinguish the two systems using the fourth and fifth holes
- Yamaha: separate soprano fingering diagrams for Baroque and German recorders
- Amazon US: Yamaha YRS-23, German fingering, Natural, one recorder Paid link
- Amazon US: Yamaha YRS-24B, Baroque fingering, Natural, one recorder Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.