Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Lawn & Garden Comparisons · Reviewed November 8, 2026

AcuRite vs La Crosse: Which 5-Inch Rain Gauge Fits?

The AcuRite 00850A3 can go straight into soil. The La Crosse 705-109 needs a flat mounting surface, but its collector slides off while the bracket stays put. Both hold five inches of rain. Choose by where the rain can actually reach the opening, then by which scale you can see and empty on your way out to the garden.

Best for

A gardener who wants to know what fell at home between two visits to the gauge, without a battery, display console or app.

Probably not for

Anyone who needs rainfall alerts, an hourly record while away, or an approved instrument for a volunteer weather observation network.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
DetailAcuRite 00850A3La Crosse 705-109 Waterfall
Rainfall capacity5 inches5 inches
ReadoutWhite inch markings magnified by collected waterMarked scale and red floating indicator
MountBuilt-in soil stake or keyhole hangerIncluded bracket and hardware for a flat surface
Removing the collectorLift the gauge from its stake position or hangerSlide the collector off the fixed bracket
Body materialWeather-resistant acrylicPlastic

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

AcuRite 00850A3 5-inch magnifying rain gauge, blue

The acrylic gauge has a pointed base and a hole for hanging it on a support. Its scale uses the water itself to enlarge the markings. No separate float needs to be put back after emptying.

Pros

  • Can stand in an open piece of soil without drilling a fence or making a post.
  • An alternative hanging mount lets you bring the scale nearer eye level.

Cons

  • Ground mounting can put the scale below your natural line of sight.
  • If planted in a bed, the gauge must be set upright again after you lift it to empty.

Who it’s for: Choose it for a rented plot, a trial location or a yard where the clearest spot is nowhere near a rail.

Check AcuRite 00850A3 5-inch magnifying rain gauge, blue on Amazon

La Crosse Technology 705-109 Waterfall rain gauge

The Waterfall pairs a red floating marker with a collector that slips out of a mounted bracket. The bracket establishes one position for the collector; the marker rests inside it.

Pros

  • The marker gives you a colored reference for finding the water level.
  • After emptying, the collector returns to the same position without resetting a stake.

Cons

  • Needs a suitable flat mounting surface and permission to attach hardware.
  • The separate marker is another part to keep track of when tipping out rainwater.

Who it’s for: Choose it for an exposed post on a route you walk often. Skip it if the only place you can attach it sits beneath a porch roof.

Check La Crosse Technology 705-109 Waterfall rain gauge on Amazon

Start at the back door, then walk out into the rain

A deck rail can look like the perfect place for a gauge from indoors. Stand at the rail and look up. Does the roof overhang the spot? Does a gutter end nearby? One position can miss rain because it is sheltered; another can collect water from a patch of roof much larger than its own opening. A gauge that is easy to read through the kitchen window is not much use if either is true.

Consider a yard with a covered deck, a raised bed and a freestanding fence post at the far end of the path. If the post has open sky above it and you pass it to reach the compost bin, the Waterfall makes sense there. Its bracket stays at the post each time you lift the collector. If instead a maple branch hangs over the post and a stretch of open soil lies beside the path, choose the AcuRite for the soil. There is no need to put a new post in just to make the other gauge fit.

Think ahead to the height of summer. The spot between young tomato plants might be open in May and under a canopy in July. Move your planned location to the path side of the bed if foliage is likely to cover the opening. Leave enough room to carry a watering can past without knocking the gauge. A location that stays useful as the garden grows is worth a few extra steps.

What the float changes, and what magnification does not

On the blue AcuRite, the collected water enlarges the white markings behind it. The physical quantity you are reading is still the depth of rain represented by its scale. A larger-looking number is not a larger rainfall, and the gauge does not gain an extra decimal place. If the level falls between two marks, record a sensible approximation rather than writing a string of digits the instrument cannot show.

The Waterfall gives your eye a different target: a red marker sitting on the water. That is a useful distinction if finding the boundary between water and clear plastic is your least favorite part of reading a gauge. Walk up to the front of the collector for the actual reading. From a chair off to one side of the deck you may see the red marker easily enough to tell that it rained, but that is not the same as aligning the marker with a particular line.

Try the mounting height before making holes. Hold a piece of paper roughly eight inches tall against the proposed post, stand where you would normally read the gauge, then walk over and reach as if to lift the collector. You need a view of its front and room to slide it free above the bracket. On the AcuRite, ask a different question: can you bend to read the ground-mounted scale without tilting a nearly full gauge toward yourself? If not, its keyhole hanger is a useful alternative.

Keep one useful number instead of counting a shower twice

Pick what one entry in your garden notebook means. After a shower, note the time, location and amount, then empty the gauge. Suppose you write down half an inch on Friday afternoon but leave the water in place. After the next shower the level reaches three quarters of an inch. Adding the two entries gives one and a quarter inches, even though only three quarters of an inch accumulated. Emptying after each reading makes the arithmetic much less interesting, which is the point.

If you leave on Friday and find water in the collector on Sunday, label it as the total since you left. Neither gauge can tell you whether it came in one hard shower or several gentle ones. If the water reached the top, do not invent the missing amount. Note that it reached capacity. Both models stop at the same five inches, so switching between them would not recover that information.

Keep the record where it will actually get filled in. A pencil and a card beside the back door might be enough. If the notebook lives in an apron or on a potting bench, the Rite in the Rain 135 vs 146 field notebook comparison helps choose between pocket space and room for wider rows. A column for “sprinkler running?” is often more illuminating than another column of decimal places.

Separate rain from what came out of the hose

An open collector does not know where its water came from. Suppose the sprinkler runs at six in the morning and a short shower follows at eight. A reading at breakfast is the combined catch if the gauge was in the spray. It is not a rain-only figure you can subtract from a planned watering amount. For a rainfall log, put the gauge beyond the sprinkler pattern. If the sprinkler moves with the hose, include the farthest place you normally move it when choosing the gauge site.

Measuring sprinkler coverage is a different job. Before buying either gauge for a single dry patch, try several identical straight-sided cans across the watered area. For a hose-end sprinkler, the University of Florida suggests spacing them along a line from the sprinkler toward the edge of its reach. Run the sprinkler for fifteen minutes and compare the water depths. If most catches are alike and the end one is nearly dry, running the same arrangement longer also adds water everywhere that already got its share.

Use the measurements to decide whether to move the sprinkler or change its run time. A timer controls time, not water depth. The Orbit one-outlet vs two-outlet hose timer guide explains when a second schedule helps with two different areas. Neither of these manual gauges sends a reading to that timer. Someone still has to check the catch, look at the soil and decide whether the next run should happen.

When an open post, an open bed or neither is the answer

For a shared community plot, the AcuRite has a practical advantage: the soil stake lets you use an open corner without altering a shared fence. Tell other gardeners what it measures and when to empty it. Two well-meaning people tipping out the same gauge without leaving a note can spoil a week of records faster than a hard-to-read scale. Make the reset part of one person’s watering round, or keep the log where everyone can see it.

At home, a bare fence post in a good spot can tip the decision toward the Waterfall, particularly if lifting out the collector is easier for you than pulling a stake from the bed. Keep hold of the marker as you pour, put it back in the collector and check that the collector sits level. Whichever you choose, clean away debris that interferes with the opening or obscures a mark. An empty, upright collector is the starting point for the next useful reading.

Neither model is the right choice for a balcony under the balcony above, or for a gardener who wants an alert while away for the week. A more readable scale cannot give a roofed-over site open sky; a larger collector cannot tell you when the rain began. For reporting to CoCoRaHS, consult the network’s approved gauge list before buying. For deciding whether to carry a hose down the path today, the more useful purchase is the one that fits an open spot you will actually visit.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 8, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.