Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed November 7, 2026

Barfly M37038 vs M37039: Shake One Drink or Two?

Buy the M37038 for a bar where each order gets its own shake. Buy the M37039 if two people regularly order the same drink and you want room for a shared batch. Barfly calls the 17 oz model a single-drink shaker and the 24 oz model a two-drink shaker. The larger one adds seven fluid ounces of nominal capacity, not a second 17 oz chamber. Your recipe and ice still have to fit.

Best for

Someone who wants a closed three-piece shaker with its own strainer and is choosing how much to mix in one round.

Probably not for

A buyer looking for a two-tin Boston set, a mixing glass for stirred drinks, an insulated travel bottle or a complete kit of measuring and serving tools.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Maker detailHeavy Duty M37038Japanese Style M37039
Nominal capacity17 oz / 500 mL24 oz / 700 mL
Serving description from BarflySingle drinkTwo drinks
Set formatThree pieces with integral strainerThree pieces with integral strainer
Selected construction and finish18/8 stainless steel core; mirror stainless finish18/8 stainless steel core; mirror stainless finish
CapDimpled finger grip; replacements listedDimpled finger grip; replacements listed
What the model name identifiesHeavy Duty shaker setJapanese Style shaker set

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Barfly Heavy Duty 3-Piece Shaker Set, stainless M37038

The 500 mL model puts an integral strainer on a shaker intended for one drink. It makes sense for an individual recipe, particularly when the next glass calls for a different mixture anyway. Heavy Duty is the model name, not evidence that the larger model is flimsy.

Pros

  • A single-drink format without giving up the built-in strainer
  • Suits a menu of individually adjusted drinks that cannot be batched together

Cons

  • Less room than the M37039 for a second portion and its ice
  • One shared shaker still needs a reset between incompatible recipes

Who it’s for: Choose this if most orders are for one person. Pass if making the same pair of drinks in separate rounds is the problem you want to solve.

Check Barfly Heavy Duty 3-Piece Shaker Set, stainless M37038 on Amazon

Barfly Japanese Style 3-Piece Shaker Set, stainless M37039

The 700 mL version gives a host more space to combine two matching orders. The cap and integral strainer serve the same roles as on the smaller shaker. Its usefulness depends on the amount that needs shaking, not simply the number of seats at the table.

Pros

  • More space for ice and ingredients when doubling a suitable recipe
  • Can pour one shared mixture into two glasses without remeasuring a second batch

Cons

  • Two large builds do not necessarily fit just because the model is described for two drinks
  • Cannot keep two guests’ different ingredients separate

Who it’s for: Choose for matching pairs of drinks, or one recipe that needs extra room. Skip the capacity upgrade if your ordinary order is a single serving and it already fits comfortably.

Check Barfly Japanese Style 3-Piece Shaker Set, stainless M37039 on Amazon

Size the part that actually goes into the shaker

Start with the recipe card, not the size printed on the serving glass. A tall drink might call for a small shaken base poured over fresh ice, then a much larger addition of sparkling water in the glass. Count the base when sizing the shaker. The ice and sparkling water that stay in the glass are not part of that load. Conversely, a short glass does not guarantee a small shake: the recipe may call for ice in the shaker that will never enter the glass.

Consider a cold, still citrus mixture with 90 mL of juice, 30 mL of another juice and 15 mL of syrup per serving. That is 135 mL of liquid before adding ice. Two identical orders start at 270 mL. On Barfly’s rounded metric figures, subtracting that quantity leaves 230 mL of nominal volume in the M37038 or 430 mL in the M37039. Those numbers are not recommended ice quantities. Ice takes space, the top must seat properly and the mixture needs room to move. The arithmetic shows why doubling the liquid is only the first check.

Use the ice you intend to serve with. Large molded cubes and small loose cubes need not pack the same way even when drawn from the same freezer. If you have a measuring jug at home, use water and your usual ice to visualize the rough volume before buying. A jug is not the shape of either shaker, so do not use its markings to certify that the lid will close. If the proposed load is already close to the stated capacity, plan smaller batches.

A party of four is not necessarily a two-drink job

Picture four people gathered around the counter. Two want the same lime drink at the same sweetness, one wants it without syrup and the fourth wants a completely different mix. The first two glasses are the opportunity for the larger shaker. Measure the ingredients for that pair, shake them together, and share the strained mixture between the prepared glasses. Alternate the pour between the two if that makes it easier to divide the batch evenly. The remaining two drinks are still separate orders.

Now change just one detail: everybody wants a different combination. A 24 oz body does not give you four separate mixing vessels. None of the flavors can be adjusted individually once they have been combined. Here the 17 oz model may be the more sensible purchase, with a place to empty it and rinse the strainer between orders. If the real bottleneck is measuring different recipes or finding clean glassware, increasing shaker capacity will not address it.

For one person preparing a pair, the point of the larger size is not to make an evening’s supply and leave it in the shaker. Set out the two glasses, prepare their garnishes, and measure the paired order while the recipe is in front of you. If the second guest has not yet decided what to drink, a single fresh portion now is a better match than making a second serving on speculation.

Three pieces solve a straining job, not a measuring job

In either set, the lower vessel holds the ingredients. The larger upper piece contains the strainer; the small cap covers the outlet while you shake. For pouring, uncover the outlet while keeping the strainer section seated on the body. Removing the entire top would also remove the feature you bought to hold the shaking ice back. That distinction matters to someone used to a Boston shaker, where straining is usually a separate tool choice.

Barfly describes the dimples on the cap as a grip feature. Its product pages do not specify a calibrated measure in that cap. Measure the recipe with a jigger or another suitable measure before adding ingredients. If your choice of measure is what slows you down, the OXO angled measure vs double jigger guide compares two ways to read a pour. Neither a second measure nor a larger shaker fixes a recipe that was doubled for the juice but not the syrup.

A built-in strainer is also not a promise of a particular mesh size or a pulp-free drink. It is a convenient first barrier for the shaking ice. For a recipe where fine particles matter, plan the finishing step separately. You might strain juice before it goes into the shaker or pour through your own fine sieve afterward. Do not buy the larger size in the expectation that its extra volume changes the fineness of the strain.

Follow the ingredients through the whole round

If the recipe begins with herbs or soft fruit, first decide where you will prepare them. A muddler and a shaker are different tools: one presses ingredients, the other mixes them. The OXO vs Barfly cocktail muddler guide covers that decision if you need it. When portions vary, keep the prepared ingredients for each order separate until you know which orders can be combined.

Leave fizzy additions for the glass rather than trapping carbonation under the cap. For a cold lime spritz, for example, shake the still base with ice, strain into the waiting glass and then add the sparkling mixer as the recipe directs. Besides keeping the sparkling ingredient out of a closed shaker, that order makes the capacity decision much simpler. You can measure the same base for a tall spritz or a shorter drink without treating their different finished glass volumes as shaker sizes.

Think about the sink, too. After pouring a fruit mixture, separate the pieces so you can see the strainer holes and rinse away what remains before starting a different drink. Barfly recommends hand washing stainless barware with a mild detergent and warm water. Its care guide allows dishwasher cleaning for stainless steel with restrictions on detergent and heated drying. The guidance for plated finishes is different; these links select the plain stainless versions.

Check the box when ordering a set or replacing a cap

The maker sells replacement caps as well as complete shakers. Seeing M37038 or M37039 in a listing title is not enough if the surrounding words say “replacement cap for.” Check that the selected item is the three-piece shaker set in stainless, not a cap or a different finish from a shared product selector. If you already own a shaker and only lost its cap, start from the replacement link on that model’s Barfly page. Do not assume the two caps interchange because both have dimples.

Choose the 17 oz M37038 when one measured order is the usual job and the integral strainer is the attraction. Choose the 24 oz M37039 when you can name a two-glass recipe that benefits from shaking together, with room left for its ice. If your favorite drinks are built in their serving glasses or stirred rather than shaken, a new shaker may not be the missing tool at all.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 7, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.