Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Craft & DIY Comparisons · Reviewed November 2, 2026

Clover Small vs Large Pom-Pom Makers: Which Size Fits?

For a row of little bobbles along a garland, start with Clover’s Small pair. For one pom-pom that gives a hat its silhouette, start with the Large. To see why, draw a 45 mm circle and a 65 mm circle and hold each against your project. Those are the closest sizes in the two packages. Even at that boundary, you may find that one leaves the stitch pattern visible while the other becomes the first thing you notice.

Best for

Knitters, crocheters and garland makers choosing between a repeated yarn accent and a single prominent topper.

Probably not for

An exact, untrimmed diameter between the four stated sizes, or a project that needs a flat motif instead of a ball of cut yarn.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Size and packageSmallLarge
Clover article number31243126
Contents of one packageTwo makers, one per sizeTwo makers, one per size
Approximate finished diameters35 mm and 45 mm65 mm and 85 mm
Inch sizes listed by Clover USA1 3/8 in and 1 5/8 in2 1/2 in and 3 3/8 in
Size difference within the pair10 mm20 mm

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Clover Pom-Pom Maker Small, 3124, two sizes

The Small pack gives you two neighboring sizes. That is useful on a pouch with two drawstring ends: you can try a quieter accent and a slightly fuller one without changing the rest of the design. Neither tool makes a pom-pom as wide as the smaller tool in the Large package.

Pros

  • Two close sizes for fine adjustments to an accent
  • Smaller circles leave more space between repeats

Cons

  • No starting size above 45 mm
  • Heavy trimming takes away much of an already small pom-pom

Who it’s for: Choose 3124 if your main question is how to decorate an edge without covering it. Skip it if the pattern specifically builds its shape around a 65 mm or 85 mm pom-pom.

Check Clover Pom-Pom Maker Small, 3124, two sizes on Amazon

Clover Pom-Pom Maker Large, 3126, two sizes

One Large package contains the 65 mm and 85 mm makers. The 20 mm step between them gives you two noticeably different outlines to try above a hat crown. This is the single Large package, not a multipack of identical packages.

Pros

  • Two distinct starting sizes for a hat topper
  • Room to trim a sample down toward an intermediate diameter

Cons

  • Neither size starts below 65 mm
  • Trimming down for small accents discards usable yarn

Who it’s for: Choose 3126 for a noticeable crown or a few widely spaced balls. If you would cut most of each one away to clear the next decoration, use the Small pair instead.

Check Clover Pom-Pom Maker Large, 3126, two sizes on Amazon

Try the spacing on paper before you wind a garland

Clover’s diameters describe the finished yarn balls, not the outside of the plastic tools. The inch and metric figures are Clover’s size labels, not exact conversions; for example, the Small package’s larger tool is labeled 1 5/8 inches in the US listing and 45 mm in the metric guide. For a layout, pick one unit and use it throughout. Cut a few paper circles and mark their centers. Lay a length of cord on the table in the curve you want it to hang, then line the centers up along it. The circles stand in for the front view of each pom-pom.

Suppose you want the attachment points 60 mm apart. Two 35 mm circles leave about 25 mm of cord showing between their edges. Switch to two 65 mm circles and the outlines overlap by 5 mm. Neither result is wrong: the first gives you separate dots of color and the second is the beginning of a fuzzy border. If you are cutting the paper mockups at a shared craft table, the comparison of Scotch and Westcott desk scissors covers that paper-cutting job; it is separate from choosing a blade that fits the maker’s groove.

Check a hat upright and a pouch in motion

A paper circle tells you how much of the crown will disappear behind the topper from the front. It cannot tell you how a soft hat will hang under the weight. Put the hat on a head form, or have its wearer try it. Attach one finished sample temporarily using its long center ties. Look from the side. If you like the width but the top folds over more than you want, try the smaller maker in the pair before changing the crown itself.

For a drawstring pouch, test both ends together. Tie on two samples and open the mouth fully, then pull it closed. Do the balls bump at the knot or cover the bit of cord you grab? If so, shorten the outline on paper first to see whether 35 mm is small enough. If the pattern also calls for a size H crochet hook, the Clover 5 mm crochet hook comparison addresses the grip choice for making the pouch. Hook size does not tell you what size the trim should be.

Keep one finished pom-pom as your sample

Both sizes use the same basic method. Wind evenly along one set of paired arches, close it and repeat on the other side. Clover advises leaving a little of the center of the inner arch showing. If the arms resist closing, unwind some yarn. With the arms closed, cut along the groove, pass a strong tie through the same groove and secure the center with a double knot before opening the tool. Leave the tie ends long if they are how you will attach the pom-pom.

Fluff the sample before trimming. Hold the long ties aside and turn the ball between small cuts so you can see the outline from more than one angle. Lay it beside the paper circle without squashing it. Yarn thickness, winding and trimming affect what you get, so record the maker size and save that first finished ball. If you are making a matched pair, set the two side by side for their last trim. Chasing one low spot on each in turn is a good way to end up with two progressively smaller balls.

When the pattern falls between sizes

A pattern asking for a 55 mm finish sits halfway between Small’s 45 mm and Large’s 65 mm. Winding extra yarn onto the 45 mm tool is not a reliable way to gain diameter. A nearer starting point for trimming from above is the 65 mm maker. If your sample comes out at 65 mm, taking 5 mm off all around removes 10 mm from its diameter. Compare against your target as you work; once the strands are cut, you cannot add their length back.

For a long run in a special yarn, weigh the ball of yarn before and after making several samples, then divide the difference by the number made. That estimate includes the ends you trimmed off, unlike weighing a finished pom-pom. Multiply by the number still needed and allow for variation. If you have just enough of a contrast color for a few small accents, choose the size you actually want to keep instead of planning to turn a batch of large pom-poms into small ones.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 2, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.