Photography & Printer Comparisons · Reviewed November 7, 2026
Ilford HP5 Plus vs Delta 400: Which 35mm Film Fits?
Both rolls give your 35mm camera 36 exposures at ISO 400. Choose HP5 Plus if the light and your exposure decisions will change faster than you can check them. Choose Delta 400 Professional if you can meter deliberately and want a smoother grain structure in an enlargement. The useful distinction is how much control you have from exposure to print, not whether you consider yourself a professional.
Best for
Photographers with a 35mm film camera and access to conventional black-and-white processing who want to pick one ISO 400 film for a project.
Probably not for
Someone buying for a 120 camera, looking for instant prints, or limited to a lab that offers only standard C-41 color-negative processing.
Specifications at a glance
| Decision point | HP5 Plus | Delta 400 Professional |
|---|---|---|
| Selected listing model | 1574577 | 1748192 |
| Selected format | 35mm cassette, 36 exposures | 35mm cassette, 36 exposures |
| Nominal sensitivity | ISO 400/27° | ISO 400/27° |
| 35mm base and coding | 0.125 mm acetate; DX-coded cassette | 0.125 mm acetate; DX-coded cassette |
| Emulsion family | Conventional PLUS film | Core-Shell crystal technology |
| Relative tradeoff described by Ilford | More latitude for exposure and processing variation | Finer, more uniform grain; more exacting exposure and processing |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Ilford HP5 Plus 35mm, 36 exposures (1574577)
HP5 Plus is the more forgiving choice of these two according to Ilford. That is useful on a walk through changing light, or in a class where the meter, tank and enlarger are all new to you. With fewer variables demanding precision at the same time, a contact sheet can tell you more about your exposure decisions.
Pros
- More tolerance of ordinary variation in metering and processing
- A familiar-looking grain texture if that is part of the picture you want
Cons
- Not the finer-grained of the two at the same nominal speed
- Exposure latitude cannot restore a shadow that received too little light
Who it’s for: Choose it for a first roll in a working camera, documentary work in mixed light, or a project that welcomes visible texture. Pass if smooth grain at this speed is the main requirement.
Check Ilford HP5 Plus 35mm, 36 exposures (1574577) on Amazon Paid linkIlford Delta 400 Professional 35mm, 36 exposures (1748192)
Delta 400 is the alternative when you want to retain ISO 400 but prefer finer grain. Its Core-Shell emulsion rewards a repeatable meter and a consistent development routine. A carefully lit portrait intended for a sizeable print is a clearer reason to pick it than the word Professional on the carton.
Pros
- Finer and more uniform grain than HP5 Plus in Ilford’s comparison
- Shares the ISO 400 meter setting and cassette format of HP5 Plus
Cons
- Less latitude for exposure errors than HP5 Plus
- Requires closer attention to the developer choice and processing routine
Who it’s for: Choose it for controlled work where the finished print or scan will show the distinction. Skip it if you are still diagnosing a meter problem or if the film must go through a C-41-only lab.
Check Ilford Delta 400 Professional 35mm, 36 exposures (1748192) on Amazon Paid linkStart at the lab counter, not the speed dial
Before a trip, ask your lab one specific question: do you develop conventional silver-based black-and-white film, and will you return the negatives? A shop that processes color negatives is not necessarily offering that service. These two rolls are not the C-41-compatible XP2 Super. Nor are they peel-apart or instant film. If you need photographs in your hand at the event, the Instax Mini color vs monochrome film guide addresses a different camera and process; neither Ilford cassette fits an Instax camera.
Now look at the format line on the carton, not just the bold film name. Both emulsions are sold in more than one format. Here the comparison is 135 film, the familiar 35mm cassette, in the 36-exposure length. A roll marked 120 is not another frame-count option for that camera. If you are comparing listings with a friend, check that neither of you has selected a multipack or a bulk length meant for loading separate cassettes.
Two ISO 400 films, two different kinds of insurance
Imagine a family gathering where people move from a sunny doorway to a shaded kitchen. You have time to check the meter, but not to recreate the moment if the exposure is a little off. HP5 Plus offers the more useful margin here. A bright doorway behind a face can still fool a meter; the film does not decide which part of the photograph matters. Read the light on the subject and use the wider latitude as breathing room, not as a replacement for metering.
Now imagine making a sequence of portraits against one plain wall. You can take a reading before the first portrait, leave the lighting alone, and process the frames together. That takes some of the uncertainty out of the chain. Delta 400 makes sense if you want quiet stretches of tone on that wall rather than pronounced grain. It does not require studio lights: a steady patch of window light and a repeatable exposure can serve the same purpose.
Do not buy Delta expecting to gain a shutter speed. At the same ISO setting, in the same light, the meter has no reason to suggest a different exposure merely because the emulsion changed. If subject movement is the problem, decide what shutter speed you need and whether the available light and aperture support it. The decision between HP5 and Delta, at their nominal speed, is about the negative you get from that exposure.
Grain matters at the size people will see
Think about the photograph after it leaves the scanner. A cropped detail enlarged for a wall print asks more of a small negative than a full frame reproduced in a small zine. In the first case Delta’s finer grain may be the feature you are shopping for. In the second, the more forgiving roll may be the better purchase even for an experienced photographer. Neither description tells you what grain will look like at a fixed print size on every paper with every developer.
There is also a difference between disliking grain and disliking a particular scan. Sharpening, scan settings and enlarging a small digital file can change how texture appears. If a lab offers several scan sizes, ask what you actually received before blaming the film. Compare examples at the same output size instead of putting a highly magnified crop of one beside a whole frame of the other. Look at skin, sky and blank walls as well as edges: a busily patterned shirt can hide much of the distinction.
A push is a plan for a roll
The number printed on the cassette is an ISO rating. An exposure index, or EI, is the setting you decide to meter at. For example, setting a meter to 800 instead of 400 gives one stop less exposure for the same scene. It does not turn the emulsion into a different film. Ilford supplies development guidance for higher meter settings for both products. Check the chart for the exact film, developer and dilution, or agree on a push with your lab before loading.
Suppose half the roll is for an outdoor lunch and the other half for an indoor performance. You can vary shutter speed and aperture from frame to frame, but a lab normally develops the whole roll together. Switching the camera’s ISO setting for the last few frames does not send separate instructions for those frames. If the two jobs need different development, separate rolls are the cleaner plan. Label each exposed cassette with the EI and processing request when you unload it.
A DX-reading compact camera adds one more check: does it let you override the speed it reads from the cassette? If it does not, an assumed push workflow may not be available in the way you intend. At box speed both of the linked rolls are DX coded. Someone using an older manual body instead needs to set the meter deliberately; the coding is not a substitute for checking the dial after a film change.
Make one comparison you can learn from
If the distinction still sounds abstract, start with the stock that fits your next real shoot. Save a few frames for a repeatable scene: a face by a window, a plain surface and a dark textured jacket in the same composition. Note the meter reading, lens, exposure and how you intend to print. On a later roll of the other film, repeat the scene under comparable light. Ask for the same output size and record the processing used for each stock. Requiring the same development time for two different emulsions would not be a fair match.
Keep strips from each roll identified after scanning. A filename such as “test-3” will not help you trace a dense or thin negative months later. If your lab cuts strips before returning them, agree on the strip length first; the Print File 35-6HB vs 35-7B negative-page comparison explains why that length matters when filing a 36-exposure roll. Tie the sleeve label to your frame notes, then judge an actual print or intended-size file rather than the film name.
For a single roll and an uncertain day, HP5 Plus is the practical choice when tolerance matters more than grain refinement. For a deliberately exposed series headed to considered enlargements, choose Delta 400. If your processing route is not settled, resolve that first. A verified lab and a properly labeled cassette will do more for the result than choosing between two films that never make it to the right tank.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 7, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Ilford: HP5 Plus 35mm product and exposure characteristics
- Ilford: Delta 400 Professional 35mm and Core-Shell design
- Ilford: direct comparison of emulsion structure, grain, latitude and processing
- HARMAN technical sheet: HP5 Plus cassettes, base, ISO rating, exposure index and development
- HARMAN technical sheet: Delta 400 cassettes, base, ISO rating, exposure index and development
- Ilford: film formats and the separate XP2 Super processing option
- Amazon US listing identity: Ilford 1574577, HP5 Plus 35mm, 36 exposures Paid link
- Amazon US listing identity: Ilford 1748192, Delta Pro 400 35mm, 36 exposures Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.