Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Art & Craft Comparisons · Reviewed November 13, 2026

Masterson Sta-Wet Handy vs Painter’s Pal: Which Fits?

Choose the Sta-Wet Handy if a small painting already fills most of your table. Choose the Painter’s Pal if you need to keep several mixtures separate while you work from a larger mixing patch. Both feed moisture through paper from a sponge. The upgrade buys room and paint cups, not a different way of keeping acrylics workable.

Best for

Acrylic painters choosing a lidded wet palette for a shared table, a class or repeated work on a series of panels.

Probably not for

An upright ride in a backpack, a ready-to-paint watercolor kit or traditional oils laid directly on wet paper.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
At the painting tableSta-Wet Handy 857Sta-Wet Painter’s Pal 912
Outside dimensions7 × 8½ × 1 inches12 × 13 × 1½ inches
Space to allow on a shelf59½ square inches of footprint156 square inches of footprint; the mixing palette itself is 9 × 12 inches
Wet palette supplies in the base kitOne sponge, five acrylic palette sheets, tray and lidOne sponge, five acrylic palette sheets, tray and lid
Separate mixturesFlat sheet; no paint cups listed in the kitFive paint cups with removable lids, plus a separate solvent cup with attached lid
Where to put brushesBring a separate brush holderSpace beneath the removable cup tray; check your brush length
Carrying a prepared paletteCarry flat; the lid is not watertightSame flat-carry requirement despite the larger case

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Masterson Sta-Wet Handy Palette 857

A lidded 7-by-8½-inch tray with one sponge and five sheets of permeable palette paper. This is the palette kit rather than the similarly named paper refill.

Pros

  • Small footprint leaves more room beside a panel or sketchbook
  • Same moisture-fed paper system as the larger kit

Cons

  • No separate lidded paint cups included
  • Less room to spread a range of neighboring mixtures across the sheet

Who it’s for: A compact choice for painting a single small study at a table you share.

Check Masterson Sta-Wet Handy Palette 857 on Amazon

Masterson Sta-Wet Painter’s Pal 912

The 9-by-12-inch mixing palette rides in a larger case alongside five lidded paint cups and a separate solvent cup. Brushes can sit beneath the removable cup holder.

Pros

  • Reserve a batch of a recurring color in a cup while varying it on paper
  • Room for several strings of light-to-dark mixtures on the mixing surface

Cons

  • The 12-by-13-inch case needs considerably more flat shelf space
  • Stored brushes sit under the cup holder, not in an independently opening drawer

Who it’s for: A studio choice for painters carrying the same custom colors across several panels.

Check Masterson Sta-Wet Painter’s Pal 912 on Amazon

Measure the shelf, not the sheet

The most consequential number on the Painter’s Pal is not 9 by 12. That is the size of the palette inside it. The case measures 12 by 13 inches and stands an inch and a half high. Imagine clearing a shelf ten inches deep, pleased that the nine-inch side ought to fit. Neither orientation will put the whole case on that shelf. The Handy takes a rectangle just seven by eight and a half inches and is one inch high. It will sit on the ten-inch shelf with room in front to get a hand underneath.

Cut two paper rectangles to the outside measurements and put them beside the actual work. Add your water jar and the rag where you normally reach for them. Can you move a loaded brush from palette to panel without passing it over the jar? On a shared table, check that the other person still has room to turn their paper. The larger case occupies about two and a half times the tabletop area of the smaller one. Some of that extra area houses the cups; it is not all extra elbow room for moving paint around.

Frame the measurement around the painting process, not just canvas size. An artist making postcard-size gel prints still needs space to roll paint and lay a clean sheet down. The Gelli Arts 6-by-6 and 8-by-10 plate comparison helps work out how much room the printing stage needs. Once the print station is set out, a Handy near the roller may be more useful than a Painter’s Pal parked across the room.

When five cups earn their place

Suppose you are making four little panels of the same corner store at different times of day. The base color of the storefront must match from panel to panel, while its lit side and its shadow change. With the Painter’s Pal you can mix the base color, put a portion in one paint cup and take out just enough to modify on the sheet. A dab of blue intended for the evening shadow need never reach the unaltered batch. Give the lid a temporary label so someone helping clean up knows which mix belongs to tomorrow’s panel.

The useful count here is five paint cups, not six. Masterson lists a sixth container separately as a solvent cup with an attached lid. The paint cups have detachable lids. Also notice what is under the cup holder: the brush compartment. If you use that space with the palette in transit, take the brushes out before setting up the cups for the session. There is little point lifting a tray of freshly sorted colors every time you switch from a flat brush to a round one.

For a single pear study, the extra containers may solve nothing. Put a light yellow, a middle green and a dark mixture apart from one another on the Handy, leaving room to pull small transitions into the center. If all your changes happen on that one sheet and you finish before moving to the next subject, there is no master batch to protect. If you already have suitable lidded pots and a place to keep them, decide whether a tray that holds them in the same case is worth setting aside that much table space.

A palette that fits the way you mix

Think about one passage you repaint often. For the fold of a white shirt, you might need a cool dark, two intermediate grays and a light with a trace of warmth. Lay them in a row from dark to light. You want to be able to touch a middle gray without trailing your brush through the highlight. A painter who likes to prepare that whole row, plus a second row for the background, has a reason to use the Painter’s Pal even if all five cups remain empty.

Another painter might start from one dark and one light and mix a fresh step between them for each stroke. That uses little of the sheet at once. Here the Handy has a practical advantage: you can put it close to your brush hand without moving the easel or shifting the reference photo. Count the mixtures you want to see at the same time, not the tubes you own. A paint box with twenty tubes can still belong to a painter who uses only three colors in a given sitting.

Neither tray controls the final consistency for you. The sponge supplies moisture through prepared permeable paper. Masterson advises squeezing more water from the sponge when using more fluid paint and wiping surplus moisture from the paper surface. If a carefully separated row of grays spreads together under the lid, consider the water in the sponge before looking for a bigger palette. A larger sheet can give you a wider gap between colors; it cannot correct a surface that is too wet for the paint you put on it.

Pack for a flat trip home

A lid that limits evaporation and a lid that lets you carry water on its side do different jobs. Masterson specifically says these palettes are not watertight and should travel flat. Picture the trip back from an evening class: the Handy can be the right size for the base of a shallow carrier, yet the wrong choice for a narrow shoulder bag where the only way it fits is upright. Trace the base of the carrier, not the outline of a book you can already slide into it.

Before carrying a prepared palette, the maker recommends lifting the paper, gently squeezing most of the water from the sponge, then putting the layers back and fitting the lid. Leave yourself a place to do that while the table is still clear. For the Painter’s Pal, snap opposite corners first, then the other pair, and press along the edges. The cups are useful for separating colors but do not alter the flat-carry requirement for the case itself.

If the real assignment is to sketch on a park bench with no level place to put a wet tray on the way home, reconsider the medium and the kit. The Sakura Koi watercolor field set comparison covers an alternative with paints already in pans. That is a different purchase for someone who wants watercolor. Someone following an acrylic class supply list may be better off taking dry equipment in and setting up the wet palette at the classroom table.

Check the contents before restocking

Both standard kits here include a tray, its lid, one sponge and five sheets. A packet labeled for the Handy or the Painter’s Pal can also be a paper-only or sponge-only refill. Check the contents line, especially if buying supplies for someone who does not already own the tray. For replacement paper, match the palette name rather than guessing from the outside case measurement. The Painter’s Pal does not use a sheet that fills its entire twelve-by-thirteen-inch footprint.

A dry tear-off palette pad is not an equivalent refill just because a sheet can be trimmed to fit. Coated paper keeps moisture below the coating, whereas the Sta-Wet sheet is meant to pass it up to the paint. Follow the preparation directions supplied with the kit before laying out colors. Masterson says the sheets can be gently cleaned while paint is still wet and reused, including on the reverse side. Five sheets therefore does not necessarily mean five painting sessions.

For traditional oil paint the wet sponge and paper are the wrong setup. Masterson describes a separate oil-compatible palette placed inside the case with the wet layers removed. Do not count that insert as part of either standard kit. For acrylics, come back to the two physical questions: does the case sit flat where you paint and store it, and do you regularly need several independent mixes? A small, clear workspace argues for the Handy. Keeping a row of values and a reserved batch within reach argues for the Painter’s Pal.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 13, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.