Kitchen Tool Comparisons · Reviewed October 30, 2026
OXO vs Norpro Cookie Scoop: Soft Grip or All-Steel Handle?
Both are hand-operated release scoops with a stated 1.5-tablespoon portion. OXO adds soft grips and dishwasher permission; Norpro offers polished stainless steel with handwashing recommended. The useful choice is handling and care, not a promised cookie result.
Best for
Home bakers who regularly portion drop-cookie dough and want a reusable squeeze-operated scoop in the 1.5-tablespoon size class.
Probably not for
Cut-out cookies, adjustable portion volumes, a tool for weighing dough or a guarantee of identical baked diameter and texture.
Specifications at a glance
| Manufacturer detail | OXO Medium Cookie Scoop | Norpro Stainless Steel Scoop |
|---|---|---|
| Exact model | 1055893 | 677 |
| Stated portion volume | 1.5 tablespoons, identified in OXO's linked product guide | 1.5 tablespoons / 22.5 ml |
| Operation | Squeeze handles to release dough | Spring-action release |
| Construction detail | Stainless steel with soft, non-slip grips | Polished stainless steel |
| Care guidance | Dishwasher safe | Handwashing recommended |
| Package linked | One medium scoop | One 39 mm scoop |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop 1055893
OXO pairs a stainless-steel scoop with soft grip surfaces. It is the relevant option when a covered handle and manufacturer-approved dishwasher cleaning matter more than an all-metal appearance.
Pros
- Soft, non-slip grip is explicitly documented
- Manufacturer permits dishwasher cleaning
- Single medium scoop rather than a set of sizes you may not use
Cons
- No adjustable portion volume
- Not the uncovered steel-handle option
- Squeeze operation still needs to suit your individual grip
Who it’s for: Choose it for the handle covering or dishwasher routine. Skip it if you want bare-metal handles, variable portions or a utensil without a squeeze mechanism.
Check OXO Good Grips Medium Cookie Scoop 1055893 on Amazon Paid linkNorpro Stainless Steel Scoop 677, 39 mm
Norpro documents a polished stainless-steel scoop with spring-action release. Its stated portion volume puts it in the same buying category as the OXO medium, with a different handle surface and care recommendation.
Pros
- Polished stainless steel for buyers who prefer an uncovered handle
- Manufacturer states both tablespoon and milliliter capacity
- Spring-action release for scoop-and-drop dough preparation
Cons
- Handwashing is recommended
- No soft covering comparable to the OXO grip
- The fixed portion size does not cover every recipe
Who it’s for: Choose it if steel handles are your preference and separate washing fits your kitchen. Skip it if dishwasher permission or a soft grip is a firm requirement.
Check Norpro Stainless Steel Scoop 677, 39 mm on Amazon Paid linkChoose the portion before choosing the brand
Start with the recipes you make repeatedly. A scoop is most useful when its portion size agrees with the recipe, not when you change every recipe to suit a new utensil. This pair belongs to the 1.5-tablespoon category. It is a reasonable shortlist for that specified amount, but neither provides a dial or interchangeable bowl for smaller and larger portions.
For occasional drop cookies, two ordinary spoons may already give you a workable routine. A dedicated scoop adds a release mechanism and a repeatable vessel shape, but also another utensil to store. For rolled dough cut into shapes, this is the wrong tool category entirely. Decide whether portioning soft dough is a recurring task before treating either purchase as a baking essential.
Treat the stated volume as a size choice, not a finished cookie size
OXO calls the 1055893 a size 40 portioner. Its official product guide links that medium model with a 1.5-tablespoon portion; Norpro directly lists 1.5 tablespoons and 22.5 milliliters for the 677. Use those stated volumes to understand the buying class. They are not evidence from a matched calibration test, and this comparison does not claim the tools dispense exactly equal masses of every dough.
Do not translate the scoop name into a guaranteed baked diameter. Follow the recipe for dough preparation, spacing and baking rather than assuming a brand or scoop number determines the result. If the recipe specifies grams per cookie, a scale remains the appropriate measuring tool. Our OXO-versus-Escali kitchen-scale comparison covers weighing separately from choosing a release scoop.
Compare the surfaces your hand will actually touch
The clearest handling difference is the OXO soft grip versus the Norpro polished steel format. Consider which surface you usually prefer on kitchen utensils. OXO is worth shortlisting if you deliberately seek a covered grip; Norpro is worth considering if you prefer the feel and appearance of an uncovered metal handle. That is a preference-based choice, not a ranking of strength or reliability.
If you can handle a display model, open and close it as intended and consider the spread between the handles. Overall tool dimensions alone cannot establish whether the grip will fit your hand during a full squeeze. Neither manufacturer specification supplies a directly comparable measurement of operating force, and a soft covering should not be presented as proof of less fatigue for every person.
Arrange the bowl, scoop and tray as one working area
Set the mixing bowl beside the prepared tray before starting. Leave a place for the scoop between portions so you are not balancing it on a narrow bowl rim or setting dough onto the bare counter. A small clean plate can fill that role. Consider where your other hand will steady the bowl, especially if the bowl is light or the work surface is crowded.
Use the recipe's portioning instructions consistently, including whether to level or shape the dough. Follow its chilling sequence rather than changing that step simply to suit the scoop. If a mixture does not move through the mechanism as intended, stop and consult the product instructions instead of forcing the handles. No unsupported claim about tackling frozen or exceptionally dense dough is needed to compare these two designs.
Plan the pan space independently of the scoop
Choosing a medium scoop does not tell you how many cookies belong on one tray. Lay out the portions with the spacing the recipe requires and account for the usable area inside the rim. If the prepared dough exceeds that layout, use another batch rather than crowding it in because a product photograph shows more cookies together. Keep your batch arrangement clear when moving between trays.
Our Nordic-Ware-versus-USA-Pan half-sheet comparison addresses pan construction, care and oven limits. It is related reading, not a requirement to buy a new tray with either scoop. A pan you already use successfully can remain part of the setup. Separating the tray decision from the scoop decision also keeps a handle preference from becoming an unsupported claim about browning or baking speed.
Cleaning permission is a real difference in this pair
OXO expressly permits dishwasher cleaning; Norpro recommends washing the 677 by hand. If all your small baking tools normally go into the dishwasher, OXO fits that routine more directly. If you already wash specialty utensils separately, the Norpro recommendation may be no inconvenience. Do not borrow dishwasher permission from another Norpro scoop or from a retailer's generic stainless-steel care field.
Whichever model you choose, inspect the bowl and release mechanism after cleaning and follow the supplied instructions for drying and storage. Stainless steel describes a material, not a guarantee that every moving part stays free of residue without attention. Put the scoop where other utensils will not press against its mechanism, and avoid treating the handle as a lever for unrelated kitchen jobs.
Check the exact single-scoop listing
The OXO link identifies model 1055893, part 1055893V4 and UPC 719812004112. The Norpro link identifies model 677, part NP677 and UPC 028901006778, matching the manufacturer page. Both checked listings describe one item. Confirm the selected size and package when ordering: a small scoop, a larger disher and a multi-size set are different purchases even when the photographs look similar.
Choose OXO when soft grips or dishwasher cleaning settle the decision. Choose Norpro when its polished steel format and handwashing routine suit you. Choose neither if the portion size is wrong for your regular recipes. Sources and identities were checked on October 30, 2026; these are documentation-based recommendations, not hands-on testing or conclusions drawn from Amazon customer reviews.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on October 30, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- OXO: exact 1055893 model, size 40 designation, squeeze operation, grip, stainless steel and dishwasher permission
- OXO: medium scoop volume of 1.5 tablespoons, linked directly to model 1055893
- Norpro: exact 677 model, stated portion volume, spring action, steel construction, handwash recommendation and UPC
- Amazon: OXO model 1055893, part 1055893V4, UPC 719812004112 and one-item identity Paid link
- Amazon: Norpro model 677, part NP677, UPC 028901006778 and one-item identity Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.