Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Outdoor & Travel Comparisons · Reviewed November 3, 2026

Park Tool PW-4 vs PW-5: Which 15 mm Pedal Wrench?

Buy the PW-5 for occasional pedal swaps on a bike with 15 mm spindle flats. Buy the PW-4 if you regularly work on different bikes and want two choices of handle angle plus a longer lever. The second opening on the PW-4 is not a second size. If your pedal has only a hex socket at the back, neither of these open-ended wrenches is the right purchase.

Best for

A rider swapping platforms for clipless pedals, a traveler packing a bike, or a mechanic deciding which pedal wrench to keep at the bench.

Probably not for

Pedals with no external wrench flats; someone who needs to measure installation torque; or a rider looking for one pocket tool for on-road adjustments.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Detail that affects the purchasePW-4 ProfessionalPW-5 Home Mechanic
Pedal fitting15 mm external flats15 mm external flats
Head layoutTwo 15 mm openings, at 30° and 45°Single 15 mm opening
Overall length per Park Tool395 mm290 mm
Tool weight per Park Tool617 g256 g
Selected retail itemOne PW-4; UPC 763477005625One PW-5; UPC 763477005632

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Park Tool PW-4 Professional Pedal Wrench

The asymmetrical head offers two ways to put the same 15 mm jaw on the pedal. If one leaves the grip uncomfortably close to the crank, the other starts the handle at a different angle. The long handle is an advantage on a workshop floor where you have room to use it; it is not an advantage in the bottom of a shallow tool drawer.

Pros

  • Two starting angles without changing the crank position
  • Longer lever for removal work at the bench

Cons

  • 105 mm longer to store than the PW-5
  • Second jaw does not add a hex fitting or another width

Who it’s for: Choose the PW-4 if pedal changes are a recurring job and a long, dedicated wrench can live within reach. Skip it if your biggest constraint is getting the tool into a case.

Check Park Tool PW-4 Professional Pedal Wrench on Amazon

Park Tool PW-5 Home Mechanic Pedal Wrench

The PW-5 is a vinyl-dipped, heat-treated spring-steel wrench made to reach narrow pedal flats. It leaves 361 grams out of the travel kit compared with packing the PW-4. It still measures 29 cm end to end, though: think tool roll or bike case, not the little pouch under a saddle.

Pros

  • Takes less room without changing the 15 mm fitting
  • Lighter of the two to bring to an event or on a trip

Cons

  • No second jaw to change the handle angle
  • Shorter lever when a compatible pedal is difficult to loosen

Who it’s for: Choose it for a known pair of pedals that comes off for a flight or an occasional change at home. If you want a tool for a busy fleet bench, first consider how often the second opening would help.

Check Park Tool PW-5 Home Mechanic Pedal Wrench on Amazon

Check the spindle, not the shape you stand on

Look at the little length of metal between the pedal body and the crank arm. You are looking for two parallel faces for a wrench to grasp. Now look at the other end of that spindle, on the inside face of the crank. Some pedals take a hex key there instead. A wide platform and a small clipless pedal can use the same wrench, while two similar-looking platforms can require different tools. The shape of the pedal body is a poor shopping guide.

Check the model instructions for the pedals already on the bike and for the pair going on. If the first pair has 15 mm flats but the new pair is hex-only, a PW-4 or PW-5 will get you through just the removal half of the job. For a bike that travels with both pairs, write the two tool fittings beside the pedal names on your packing list. The “15 mm” on this wrench describes the distance across the flats; it is not the diameter of the pedal thread.

An adjustable wrench that opens to 15 mm is not necessarily a substitute. Its jaws also have to fit into the gap between crank and pedal body and engage the flats fully. Conversely, do not assume that narrow jaws create a fitting where no flat exists. For a hex-only setup, check the required key size and reach. The Park Tool IB-2 vs Crankbrothers M17 guide covers what those folding tools actually include; matching the number stamped on a key is only the first check.

What the second opening does on a repair stand

Picture the right crank in the working position shown in Park Tool’s pedal-removal directions. The flats on the spindle determine where the jaws can sit. With the PW-4 you can lift the wrench off and engage the same flats through the other opening. The pedal need not turn for the handle to land somewhere else. This is useful when the bike is one you have never worked on before and you want a clear path for your hand. Park Tool’s 30° and 45° figures describe the openings, not torque settings.

Separate the question of starting angle from the question of leverage. The extra length of the PW-4 changes how far your hand can be from the spindle; the two openings change where the handle points. Neither feature identifies which way to loosen a pedal. Park Tool notes that the left pedal uses a left-hand thread, unlike the right pedal. Check the side and follow the removal directions before applying force. A longer handle is no remedy for turning the wrong way, engaging only the tips of the jaws or trying to force damaged threads.

For a bike trip, make two tool lists

The first list is for packing the bike at home; the second is for assembling it at the destination and packing it again to come home. It is easy to take pedals off with a shop wrench borrowed for the afternoon and forget that the wrench is staying behind. Ask whether the destination actually provides a suitable tool. If it does, you might prefer the PW-4 at home and carry neither. If not, set the PW-5 next to the pedal pouch before closing the case.

Measure the tool compartment itself. A 300 mm straight space can accommodate the PW-5 lengthwise if the head also clears the opening, but it cannot accommodate a 395 mm PW-4 lengthwise. A large case with a narrow zippered sleeve can have plenty of room for the bike and nowhere convenient for the longer wrench. If weight allowance is the issue, use the 361 g difference to plan, then weigh the whole packed case rather than adding labels. The Etekcity vs Travel Inspira luggage scale comparison explains the displays on two strap scales if the case is awkward to read while lifted.

Removal leverage is not a torque reading

For a new pedal installation, start with the pedal and crank manufacturers’ instructions, including the specified tool and tightening torque. Neither handle gives a torque reading. The feel of a pull on the long wrench cannot be carried over as the same pull on the short one. If your task explicitly calls for checking a numerical torque at external flats, Park Tool documents a separate 15 mm crowfoot, the TWB-15, for use with a compatible torque wrench. Follow the instructions for that setup; it is not a feature of either wrench linked here.

A useful final question is which part of the job prompted the purchase. If you already have a PW-5 and it seats fully on your pedals, a second handle only makes sense if you repeatedly wish for more reach or another starting angle. If what prompted the search was a torque specification or a hex-only replacement pedal, keep the PW-5 for the pedals it fits and solve that different problem directly. Buying the larger shop model would leave the missing tool missing.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 3, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.