Art & Craft Comparisons · Reviewed November 14, 2026
Staedtler Lumograph vs Black: Which Six-Pencil Tin?
A shaded jacket can be a patch of graphite with a metallic sheen or a deliberately matte dark. Choose the regular Mars Lumograph 100 G6 for the former; choose Lumograph Black 100B G6 for the latter. These six-pencil tins cover the same grade labels, so the buying decision is about the kind of mark you want, not which box contains more pencils.
Best for
People choosing a six-pencil set for dry monochrome sketches, portraits, still lifes and studies built from HB through soft B grades.
Probably not for
Anyone needing a complete hard-grade drafting range, water-soluble graphite, colored pencils or a charcoal set. Neither tin includes an eraser or sharpener.
Specifications at a glance
| What changes at the drawing table | Mars Lumograph 100 G6 | Mars Lumograph Black 100B G6 |
|---|---|---|
| Selected package | Six drawing pencils in one metal tin | Six drawing pencils in one metal tin |
| Grades in the tin | HB, 2B, 4B, 6B, 7B, 8B | HB, 2B, 4B, 6B, 7B, 8B |
| Manufacturer-described finish | Graphite with a subtle metallic lustre | High-carbon formulation for matte black tones |
| Approximate core diameter: HB and 2B | 2.0 mm | 3.6 mm |
| Approximate core diameter: 4B | 2.5 mm | 3.6 mm |
| Approximate core diameter: 6B and 7B | 3.6 mm | 3.6 mm |
| Approximate core diameter: 8B | 3.6 mm | 4.5 mm |
| H, 2H or harder pencils included | None | None |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Staedtler Mars Lumograph 100 G6, six-pencil metal tin
The regular graphite set contains one each of HB, 2B, 4B, 6B, 7B and 8B. Staedtler describes the marks as having a metallic lustre; this is not the matte Black formulation.
Pros
- Keeps the familiar graphite sheen as part of a finished pencil drawing
- Supplies six grades without adding colors or unrelated drawing tools
Cons
- Not the formulation to choose when a matte dark is the main requirement
- The six-pencil tin omits the hard grades found elsewhere in the wider Lumograph range
Who it’s for: Choose it for an all-graphite sketchbook or a class asking for ordinary graphite in these six grades. Skip this tin if the materials list calls for H or 2H.
Check Staedtler Mars Lumograph 100 G6, six-pencil metal tin on Amazon Paid linkStaedtler Mars Lumograph Black 100B G6, six-pencil metal tin
This six-grade set uses the high-carbon Black formulation. It runs from HB to 8B, with a 4.5 mm core in the 8B pencil and 3.6 mm cores in the other five.
Pros
- Offers a manufacturer-specified matte finish for dark passages
- Provides the same six grade labels as the regular tin for a focused change of drawing medium
Cons
- Changes the finish if introduced into an existing regular-graphite drawing
- Does not add hard grades, a white pencil or any wet-media capability
Who it’s for: Choose it when matte shadows are an intentional part of the picture, especially for a new drawing that can use one formulation throughout. Skip it if you want to match an existing regular-graphite study.
Check Staedtler Mars Lumograph Black 100B G6, six-pencil metal tin on Amazon Paid linkDecide what the dark passage should look like
Start with the finished picture, not the grade stamped on the end of a pencil. Imagine a small portrait with a pale face above a dark sweater. If you want that sweater to remain a matte shape, the Black tin is the more relevant choice. If the whole picture is meant to retain the visible character of conventional graphite, choose the regular tin. Staedtler identifies the finish difference explicitly. This is a material choice, not a claim that one set makes a more convincing portrait.
The same distinction matters when you add to a drawing already underway. Suppose the face, background and half the sweater are complete in regular Lumograph. Substituting Black just because the remaining area is dark also introduces another finish into that area. That may be a deliberate mixed-media effect, but it is not a neutral replacement. For a series of small studies intended to hang together, keep a note of the formulation on the back of each sheet as well as the grades you used.
For work you intend to photograph, the matte formulation is a reasonable starting preference when reflections are an unwanted variable. That is an inference from the stated finish, not a promise of a better photograph. Paper, illumination, camera position and glazing still belong in the plan. Decide whether you will share the bare drawing or photograph it in its frame before treating pencil choice as the answer to every bright patch in an image.
The same six labels do not make an identical value scale
Both selected tins contain HB, 2B, 4B, 6B, 7B and 8B. Neither contains B, 3B or 5B, and neither goes into the H grades. For a class list that specifies HB, 2B and 4B, the named grades are present in both. If the tutor specifies standard graphite, buy the regular set; if a materials list explicitly asks for matte or high-carbon pencils, check whether Black meets that brief. Six pencils is the package size, not evidence that the range covers every assignment.
Do not read 4B as a measured promise that the two formulations will put exactly the same darkness on your paper. Make a reference strip for whichever tin you buy. Give each pencil a labeled rectangle, then use part of that rectangle for spaced lines and part for a shaded patch. Leave the pressure light enough that you can still add another pass. Keep that strip with the drawing. It answers a useful working question: which pencil and mark pattern produced the passage you want to repeat?
There is also no obligation to cycle through every pencil in order. For a small kitchen-object study, begin with the outline and the broadest light and dark shapes; reserve a darker accent for the narrow contact shadow beneath the object. A drawing that needs three kinds of mark need not become a six-step demonstration. If you find yourself reaching for a hard pencil to place faint construction lines, recognize the missing tool. Neither tin supplies it, even though the wider regular Lumograph family includes harder grades.
Separate core diameter from the width of your line
The Black HB and 2B pencils have approximately 3.6 mm cores, compared with about 2.0 mm in their regular counterparts. At 8B the figures are about 4.5 and 3.6 mm respectively. These are the diameters of the material inside the wooden pencil, not fixed line widths. A sharpened point, its angle to the page and the portion you place on the paper determine the contact area. Do not buy the regular tin expecting every mark to be finer simply because several cores are narrower.
For a drawing of a woven basket, decide which marks need a point and which need a broader stroke before sharpening all six pencils to the same shape. A few crisp intersections can explain the weave while wider marks describe the shaded side. On a practice corner, turn one pencil slightly between strokes and notice the shape of the contact. This is a more useful preparation than choosing a tin on the assumption that its largest core must always lay down the widest line.
Paper choice remains a separate purchase. If your intended drawing alternates fine ink contours with graphite hatching, the surface requirements differ from a pencil-only study built in broad layers. The Strathmore Smooth vs Vellum Bristol comparison helps make that decision. When changing pencil formulations, keep the paper the same for the first small study. Changing the pencil, surface and drawing scale together makes it harder to work out which choice you actually prefer.
Choose a drawing workflow before adding accessories
Consider a study of three overlapping leaves. First identify the unmarked spaces between them. Then put in their main directions, shade the portions beneath an overlap and only afterward add the smallest veins. The useful decision is where a light line, a broad midtone and a dark accent belong. Choose regular for a graphite-finish study or Black for a matte one, but use the same plan. A different core formulation cannot decide which leaf is in front.
Blending is another intentional choice rather than a required finishing operation. Staedtler’s stone-drawing lesson uses HB for edges and 4B for areas, then treats smoothing the hatching as optional. That is a useful distinction for other subjects too. Leave directional strokes visible where they describe a leaf or a woven surface; consider blending where you want a less visibly lined passage. Work on a small sample first, and avoid blending an entire page merely because the pencil packaging calls the medium blendable.
Plan highlights before covering the sheet. An untouched opening along a leaf edge is a different task from lifting a broad light patch after shading. A precision eraser may help with a tiny correction beside a line you want to retain; the Tombow MONO Zero round vs rectangular tip guide compares those shapes. It does not establish that either tip will remove these two formulations equally. Keep an offcut of the actual paper for checking a correction before applying it to a nearly finished drawing.
Buy the tin for the next project, not every possible medium
For a class, place the course list beside the six grades before ordering. For personal work, name the next picture: an all-graphite notebook study, a portrait with matte clothing, or a continuation of an existing drawing. Those briefs give a clearer answer than an undefined wish for more professional pencils. The regular 100 G6 fits the graphite brief and continuity with regular graphite; Black 100B G6 fits an intentional matte treatment. Neither is a complete drawing kit just because it arrives in a tin.
The model letters are worth checking. The selected products are 100 G6 and 100B G6, each a single six-pencil tin. Staedtler also uses the Lumograph name for aquarell 100A, charcoal 100C and woodless pure graphite 100G. Those are different products, not alternative package names for the two here. In particular, do not confuse the space in 100 G6 with the 100G woodless family, or assume that the word Black means you are buying the separate charcoal range.
Before putting a tin in a drawing bag, add the sharpener and eraser you intend to use and decide how to protect the sheet. Neither linked set supplies those accessories. Then keep the choice simple: regular when the look of graphite belongs in the work, Black when the matte finish belongs in the work. If your real need is water-activated washes, hard construction grades or large charcoal gestures, change the shopping brief. Choosing between these two tins will not provide those missing capabilities.
Official sources and further reading
Sources reviewed on November 14, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.
- Staedtler US: regular 100 G6 tin, graphite finish and grade-specific core diameters
- Staedtler US: Black 100B G6 tin, high-carbon formulation, matte finish and core diameters
- Staedtler UK product catalogue: exact six grades in the 100 G6 tin
- Staedtler: distinctions between regular, Black, aquarell, charcoal and woodless Lumograph families
- Staedtler drawing lesson: HB outlines, 4B shading and optional blending
- Amazon US: Mars Lumograph Graphite Pencil Set, six count, 100 G6, HB through 8B Paid link
- Amazon US: Mars Lumograph Black Drawing Pencils, six pack in a metal tin, 100B G6 Paid link
Commission disclaimer
This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.