Laynie Hasan.

← All offer guides

Art & Hobby Comparisons · Reviewed November 7, 2026

Strathmore Toned Tan vs Toned Gray: Which Sketch Pad?

Which color would you leave untouched in the drawing? That is what separates these two pads. The 412-9 leaves a warm tan between your dark marks and your white pencil; the 412-109 leaves a cool gray. Both contain 50 sheets of the same weight and listed surface. For a charcoal study of a white bowl and its shadow, consider gray. For a limited-palette drawing where exposed paper can stand in for sunlit brick, consider tan.

Best for

Artists choosing a 9 x 12 inch pad for pencil, charcoal or other sketch media and planning to use the unmarked sheet as a visible middle value.

Probably not for

Anyone needing a white ground, a bound journal meant to keep every page, or a heavyweight sheet specifically designed for repeated wet washes.

Specifications at a glance

Manufacturer specifications for the exact versions compared
Specification400 Series Toned Tan400 Series Toned Gray
Item number412-9412-109
Paper colorWarm tanCool gray
Detached sheet size and quantity9 x 12 inches; 50 sheets9 x 12 inches; 50 sheets
Binding and removalWire on 12-inch edge; micro-perforatedWire on 12-inch edge; micro-perforated
Weight and surface118 gsm (80 lb); medium surface118 gsm (80 lb); medium surface
Fiber and acidity claims30% post-consumer fiber; acid free30% post-consumer fiber; acid free

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Strathmore 400 Series Toned Tan Sketch Pad, 9 x 12, 412-9

Tan supplies a warm color even where there is no pencil at all. It can carry the unlit side of a piece of earthenware or the surrounding wall while you concentrate your marks on the deepest recess and the brightest rim.

Pros

  • Can supply an earth-colored passage without covering it with pencil
  • Provides a warm setting for a deliberately limited black, white and brown drawing

Cons

  • The exposed sheet can introduce warmth that was not in the subject
  • An erased passage goes back to tan, not to a white highlight

Who it’s for: Choose tan if leaving part of the sheet warm is an intended design choice. Skip it if a gray background is part of the assignment or you would immediately cover the warmth everywhere.

Check Strathmore 400 Series Toned Tan Sketch Pad, 9 x 12, 412-9 on Amazon

Strathmore 400 Series Toned Gray Sketch Pad, 9 x 12, 412-109

The cool gray gives you a middle step for drawings built with black and white. A warm-colored object can still be the subject: put that warmth in the pencil marks instead of also placing it in every uncovered part of the sheet.

Pros

  • Useful for planning a monochrome subject with separate light and dark passages
  • A natural starting point when the unmarked surroundings should look cool

Cons

  • It will not supply an earth tone when that color needs to run through the drawing
  • The maker calls this a cool gray; it is not specified as a calibrated neutral reference

Who it’s for: Choose gray for a study in values or a composition with a visibly cool ground. Pass if the warmth of unworked tan paper is part of the look you are after.

Check Strathmore 400 Series Toned Gray Sketch Pad, 9 x 12, 412-109 on Amazon

Decide which parts of the picture you will not draw

Set a mug on a folded cloth and sketch a thumbnail before buying a full pad. Instead of outlining every fold, give yourself three kinds of area: dark pencil, untouched page and light pencil. A fold turning away from the window might take the dark mark. Its rising face might stay unworked. A narrow edge catching the window might get a light line. The untouched shape is doing as much work as either pencil. Pick the color you want to see in that shape.

Now move outside the mug. Will the table, the gap inside the handle and the border around the entire composition all stay bare? A small amount of warm ground inside a drawing and a wide tan border around it are very different commitments. If you plan to place the finished sheet in a white mat, lay a small drawing or color sample beside the mat material. Look at the border, not just the most colorful object. It is often the largest area of uninterrupted paper a viewer will see.

Do not make the choice by subject label alone. Tan is not a universal substitute for skin color in portraits, and gray is not restricted to metal or winter scenes. In a portrait against a cool wall, you may want gray visible around the sitter while you build warmer notes only in the face. In a drawing of a silver spoon on a brown napkin, tan might do more work than gray because the cloth occupies most of the page.

Take inventory of your light marks

A white sheet gives you a ready-made highlight whenever you leave a gap. With either of these pads, a gap gives you a middle value instead. If your pencil case contains only graphite, you can draw darker than the ground, but lifting that graphite does not reveal white paper underneath. That limitation can be useful for a soft silhouette study. It is a poor fit for a brief calling for crisp white reflections unless you also have a suitable light medium.

Choose your light tool by the mark you need, not by the word white on its barrel. Do you want a broad, pale plane on the side of a building, or a pinpoint on a polished door handle? If you have access to a sample of toned paper, draw both marks with the tool you already own. Put an unmarked strip between them and the darkest pencil you plan to use. Compare under the light where you normally draw. The object is to see whether the three areas read separately, not to recreate an online swatch exactly.

If your colors are mostly translucent in the way you apply them, make a second strip using your ordinary pressure. The ground left between strokes matters when you hatch lightly. A densely covered passage may show much less paper. Before changing your whole pencil set, decide whether the real disagreement is with the paper underneath; the Polychromos vs Albrecht Dürer pencil comparison addresses the separate choice between dry and water-soluble pencils.

Match the paper to the assignment, not the cover color

For a class exercise, read what the instructor means by toned paper. If the exercise asks for five distinguishable values, either pad can contribute one of them without a mark. Draw the darkest and lightest patches first, leave one patch bare, and work toward the intermediate steps. If the instruction instead says cool gray ground, order the gray. A tan sheet can teach the same exercise, but it will not meet that color requirement. Neither product promises that its unmarked paper matches a numbered step on a particular value scale.

Check the rest of the supply list just as closely. Strathmore lists graphite, charcoal, colored pencil and several other sketch media for these 118 gsm sheets. Its separate 400 Series Toned Mixed Media paper is 300 gsm and specifically intended for wet as well as dry media. Similar colors and the same series number do not make those products interchangeable. If the main project is a watercolor wash rather than a drawing with a few highlights, select the support for the wash first. The cold-press vs hot-press watercolor block guide looks at that different decision.

Use the full sheet size deliberately

The maker lists both wire pads as nine by twelve inches after detaching at the perforation, with the binding on the twelve-inch side. That distinction matters if you need to deliver a loose sheet of a specified size. It does not mean the binding disappears while you are drawing. If your hand would rest on the wire during a large sweep, turn the pad or remove one sheet and clip it to a drawing board. Keep clips and fingers outside any area you intend to show in the finished mounting.

Think about reproduction, too. A phone or scanner set to turn the paper background white can lose exactly the middle tone you bought. If a sketch is destined for a portfolio file, take a photograph of a scrap with a few marks, including a light mark. Compare the displayed paper to the physical sheet before recording a whole series. A quick automatic correction that looks fine on white paper is not necessarily the correction you want on either of these colors.

Finally, check the product line, number, color, dimensions and sheet count together. A smaller pad, a hardbound book and a mixed-media pad can all carry the words Toned Gray. For these two single pads the match is 412-9 for tan and 412-109 for gray. If your supply list leaves the choice open, return to that mug-and-cloth thumbnail: buy the background you would be pleased to leave visible when the drawing is finished.

Official sources and further reading

Sources reviewed on November 7, 2026. Prices, availability and terms can change; recheck before buying.

Commission disclaimer

This article contains affiliate links. If you buy or sign up through one of them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That commission does not change the price you pay or the criteria used in this guide. Product details, prices, availability, and terms can change, so confirm the current information on the linked page before buying.